Peace be upon you. Is the following account authentic?
**The Fatwa of Mawla Sahib al-Zaman عج الله فرجه concerning tatbir**
People from Iran, Azerbaijan and the Caucasus would ask the scholars of Najaf for rulings on the drums played during mourning ceremonies for Abu Abdillah علیه السلام, as well as on striking themselves with swords, qama blades and the like. They would write these questions in separate letters, each person addressing his own religious authority, and send them to Najaf with representatives. They instructed the representatives not to open the letters once they had received the replies.
The letters were placed in a container and kept unopened until they were brought to the Shah Mosque—known as Khomeini Mosque—in Tehran. There, they were read aloud at gatherings attended by people from different regions, so that the followers of each religious authority could learn that authority’s ruling and fatwa.
This was during the time of the late Sayyid, author of *al-‘Urwa* (Sayyid Muhammad Kazim Tabataba’i Rashti). The representatives returned with the replies and announced a particular day for reading them aloud to everyone. People gathered at the Shah Mosque, where the replies and fatwas were read out, and every question was answered.
Some of the replies ruled these mourning practices impermissible, though they differed: some said they were impermissible if they caused harm, but permissible if they did not; others ruled that they were permissible. Then they opened the letter containing the fatwa of the late Ayatollah Shaykh Zayn al-Abidin, may he rest in peace, and read it. It said:
بسم الله تعالى شأنه
“I was uncertain about this matter and did not know whether to rule it permissible or forbidden. So I went to the Mosque of Sahla and met my master and lord, the Proof, son of Hasan, peace and blessings be upon him. I put the question to him and asked him about it. He replied that it was permissible, and so, following my master, I rule that it is permissible.
والسلام”
(Place of meeting: the Mosque of Sahla.)
When the people heard this fatwa, they said, “There is no need for the other fatwas. This is enough for us; we have learned the truth and need nothing more.”
بيان الأئمه للوقائع الغریبه و الاسرار العجیبه، vol. 2, pp. 461–462