Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2319 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Is the Report That Sheep Avoided the Euphrates Because of Imam Husayn’s Martyrdom Authentic?

Primary reference: See the answer text 34 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2319

The Prophet Ismail علیه‏السلام had a large flock of sheep. One day, the shepherd took them out to graze in the desert and was watching over them when he suddenly noticed that they would not drink from the Euphrates. He reported this to the Prophet Ismail علیه‏السلام, who sought a solution from his Lord. Then a voice came from God: “Ask the sheep themselves why.” The Prophet Ismail علیه‏السلام asked them, “Why will you not drink this water?” By God’s will, they replied, “Your son, Husayn علیه‏السلام, will be martyred of thirst in this land, beside this river. We, too, will not drink this water, out of grief for his suffering and tragedy.” (Bihar al-Anwar, vol. 44, p. 243.)

In light of the above, a question arises. Please clarify the matter:

Was not the Prophet Ismail علیه‏السلام in Mecca? How, then, could the sheep have been taken to graze some 1,800 kilometres away?

According to Shi‘i belief, prophets and Imams know the unseen. Why, then, would the sheep in this story know a secret that the prophet of God, Ismail علیه‏السلام, did not know?

And if, as the story says, all living creatures refused to eat or drink because of the events of Karbala, would that not have led to the extinction of humans and animals in that region?

Now that Karbala is a city, do the animals there drink water and eat food?

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The report that sheep avoided drinking from the Euphrates out of grief over Imam Husayn’s martyrdom is considered mursal (with a gap in its chain of transmission) and weak. Objections concerning Prophet Ismaʿil’s residence in Mecca, the prophets’ knowledge of the unseen, and the end of his descendants at Karbala can be addressed by examining similar reports and considering divine wisdom. Prophet Ismaʿil’s principal residence in Mecca does not preclude his traveling to other regions, and the prophets’ knowledge of the unseen does not mean that they have complete knowledge of all things.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

The report in question is mursal, and some Shi‘i scholars have criticized it, describing it as weak in both its chain of transmission and its content. In fact, Shi‘i scholars objected to this hadith even before the Wahhabis did!

و روی أن إسماعیل کانت أغنامه ترعى بشط الفرات ...

Bihar al-Anwar (Beirut edition), vol. 44, p. 244

However, the mere fact that this report exists does not undermine the possibility that the event took place, since similar reports have been transmitted that are sufficiently reliable both in their chains of transmission and on rational grounds.

Since similar objections may be raised against other hadiths, we will examine the matter.

The fact that the Prophet Ismail (peace be upon him) was based primarily in Mecca does not mean that he never left his homeland during his blessed life and mission, whether to convey his message or for other reasons.

The prophets’ knowledge of the unseen does not mean that nothing of the unseen was ever hidden from them. Some matters may have been kept from them for a particular wisdom. For example, although the Prophet Solomon (peace be upon him) could hear the speech of an ant:

الأنفال : 48 و إذ زین لهم الشیطان أعمالهم و قال لا غالب لکم الیوم من الناس و إنی جار لکم فلما تراءت الفئتان نکص على‏ عقبیه و قال إنی بری‏ء منکم إنی أرى‏ ما لا ترون إنی أخاف الله و الله شدید العقاب

“And [remember] when Satan made their deeds seem fair to them and said, ‘No one among the people will overcome you today, and I am your protector.’ But when the two forces came face to face, he turned back and said, ‘I have nothing to do with you. I see what you do not see. I fear God; God is severe in punishment.’”

النمل : 18 حتى إذا أتوا على‏ واد النمل قالت نمله یا أیها النمل ادخلوا مساکنکم لا یحطمنکم سلیمان و جنوده و هم لا یشعرون

“They went on until they came to the valley of the ants. An ant said, ‘O ants, go into your dwellings, lest Solomon and his armies crush you without realizing it!’” (18)

النمل : 19 فتبسم ضاحکا من قولها و قال رب أوزعنی‏ أن أشکر نعمتک التی‏ أنعمت علی و على‏ والدی و أن أعمل صالحا ترضاه و أدخلنی‏ برحمتک فی‏ عبادک الصالحین

Solomon smiled and laughed at her words, and said, “My Lord, inspire me to give thanks for the blessings You have bestowed upon me and my parents, and enable me to do righteous deeds that please You. By Your mercy, admit me among Your righteous servants!” (19)

Yet despite all his power and authority over the clouds, the wind, the birds, the jinn and others, the Prophet Solomon did not know where the hoopoe was when it was absent, and knew nothing of the Queen of Sheba or her sun-worshipping people.

النمل : 20 و تفقد الطیر فقال ما لی لا أرى الهدهد أم کان من الغائبین

“Solomon searched among the birds and said, ‘Why do I not see the hoopoe? Is he among the absent?’”

النمل : 21 لأعذبنه عذابا شدیدا أو لأذبحنه أو لیأتینی بسلطان مبین

“I will surely punish him severely, or slaughter him, unless he brings me a clear explanation for his absence.”

النمل : 22 فمکث غیر بعید فقال أحطت بما لم تحط به و جئتک من سبإ بنبإ یقین

Not long afterwards, the hoopoe arrived and said, “I have learned something that you have not learned. I have brought you certain news from Sheba!”

Thus, the fact that some matters were concealed from the prophets for a particular wisdom does not undermine their prophethood. Moreover, a question is not always asked in order to seek information. It may instead be confirmatory, honorific, intended to draw someone closer, or to establish a connection. A question may also serve to investigate a matter as a test, or to direct the attention of other listeners to the central issue.

Likewise, the sheep’s refusal at that moment does not mean that they would continue to refuse to eat. The matter could be remedied through prayer and other special graces, just as a person in mourning eventually returns to their normal state.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022