Peace be upon you, esteemed teacher. May God give you strength. What is your opinion of the clip above? I have no issue with the principle of tabarri itself; that is clear. But I would like to know whether you feel that, amid the speaker’s remarks, there is some deliberate editorial manipulation intended to undermine unity. We have Sunni Muslims who love the Ahl al-Bayt, as well as a group who deny this matter. I would like your position on this to be made clear to me. Thank you, teacher.
Is There Editing Trickery in the Submitted Clip Intended to Undermine Unity?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Tabarri must be practised sincerely and solely for the sake of God; it must not become a means of fostering resentment or undermining unity. Inexpertly practised tabarri loses its value and may lead opponents further astray or reinforce them in their misguidance. Tawalli and tabarri must follow the example of the Prophet and Imam Ali.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterDisavowal, like prayer, must be practiced sincerely and solely for God’s pleasure, not used as a means of stoking hatred.
The duty of disavowal springs from the human heart; together with allegiance, it forms a pair that safeguards the soundness of one’s faith. Yet the flames of disavowal and the showers of allegiance must be expressed with the utmost skill, following the example and tradition of the Prophet and the Imams. If these two duties become tools for harassing and provoking an opposing community, they depart from their prescribed path and may even lead that community astray or entrench it further in error.
Anyone who wields the Qur’an against an opponent insults the Qur’an; and anyone who practices disavowal ineptly strips it of its value.