On Laylat al-Qadr, you said that badāʾ could also occur concerning the appearance. Then they asked: Can badāʾ occur even in matters deemed certain? The Imam replied, “Yes, badāʾ can occur.” In other words, it is possible that the Sufyani may not come at all! None of the events that have been mentioned may happen at all, and yet the Imam may appear. They say, “At that moment, we were afraid. We were terrified, and we asked: Is it possible that یبدو لله بالقایم? In other words, could badāʾ occur in the appearance of the Mahdi too? Is it possible that the Mahdi will not appear? Could my actions be such that God does not permit him to appear and takes the Mahdi away...?” We were afraid. The Imam said: ان القائم من المیعاد.
He said, “The Qa'im is God’s promise. والله لا یخلف المیعاد God does not break His promise...” Is the chain of transmission of this hadith weak? Since some of the signs of the appearance are considered certain (such as the coming of the Sufyani), can badāʾ still occur in them? If badāʾ is possible in matters that are certain, why call them certain?
Could they then be subject to badāʾ later, or...?
Can Badāʾ Occur in the Certain Signs of the Appearance?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Badāʾ may occur in matters related to the appearance, including signs considered certain, such as the coming of the Sufyani. But God’s promise that the Qa'im (AJ) will appear cannot fail. God will fulfill His promise, for His power encompasses all things—even what is deemed certain—and nothing can withstand His will.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAlmighty God will surely fulfill His promise. Yet, by God’s will, anything can change—even what seems inevitable. But the divine promise stands above all inevitabilities, and the peerless Creator, by His unassailable will, will bring those promises to pass!
Everything is humbled and submissive before the One God—even what seems inevitable—for neither the inevitable nor the non-inevitable has any standing before Him; both are subdued beneath the shadow of His eternity!
This shows that divine power cannot be locked away!
المائده : 64 و قالت الیهود ید الله مغلوله غلت أیدیهم و لعنوا بما قالوا بل یداه مبسوطتان ...