How can these two points be reconciled? Does divine decree not have an actual existence in the external world? 1- إن الدعاء یرد القضاء , supplication repels divine decree. ینقضه کما ینقض السلک وقد أبرم إبراما, supplication undoes divine decree just as a thread is unraveled, however tightly it has been tied. 2- Badāʾ applies to what has not yet come into external existence; once it has become manifest in external reality, there is no badāʾ for God, and God does whatever He wills.
How Does Supplication Repel Divine Decree, and What Is Badāʾ?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Divine decree is a ruling awaiting God’s ratification, and supplication can repel it. Badāʾ means the manifestation of a divine matter through change or confirmation, and concerns something that does not yet exist in external reality. Once it has acquired an actual existence, there is no badāʾ for God; God does whatever He wills.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterDivine decree is, in effect, a judgment awaiting God’s ratification. A decree must be carried out by God. He knows what will happen and what the final outcome will be: whether His decree will be confirmed or erased. God has therefore granted prayer the privilege of serving as the arbiter of His decree. Whatever the case—whether, by answering a prayer, He brings about a change in His decree, or, by not answering it, ratifies it—all of this proves that He is the Knower, the All-Knowing, the Originator, the One who wills, the All-Powerful, the Judge, the Sovereign, the Initiator and the Ratifier!
Badaʾ is, in effect, God’s resolve to confirm or alter His decree. God rules over all things—even over His own judgment and decree! And …
الرعد : 39 یمحوا الله ما یشاء و یثبت و عنده أم الکتاب
God effaces whatever He wills and confirms whatever He wills; with Him is the Mother of the Book.
الأنبیاء : 23 لا یسئل عما یفعل و هم یسئلون
No one can call Him to account for what He does, but they will be called to account for their deeds.
Thank you, teacher. There’s just one sentence I don’t understand: “For God, badaʾ concerns that which does not yet have an external existence …”
Does this mean that a human being, or an action a human performs, has no external existence and could therefore be subject to badaʾ? Do human thoughts and actions, or even human beings themselves, have an external existence and then undergo badaʾ—or …?
#Response 1114: Supplement
Definition of badaʾ:
Lexically, badaʾ means beginning, commencement, appearance and bringing into being.
As a technical term, badaʾ means that the change or confirmation of anything depends on God’s will.
In effect, badaʾ is the manifestation of God’s will to change or confirm something. When God issues a decree, that very decree awaits the Lord’s execution—whether by confirming and carrying it out, or by changing and bringing it about.
Badaʾ is the manifestation of what God knows, but others do not!
Badaʾ is the disclosure of something about which others had supposed otherwise, while the Creator knew what would come to pass.
Badaʾ is a matter in which the observers of the decree in the register of divine decree expect that very decree to occur; but the All-Knowing Creator brings about what He knows will come to pass.
Badaʾ is a form of knowledge of which no created being has any awareness!
Whatever those other than God, among the chosen ones at His court, know lies in the realm between divine will and divine decree; they have no access to the sanctuary of badaʾ. If God brings His decree to pass, He has, in effect, brought about badaʾ by making that decree real and confirming it. In other words, had He willed, He would have brought about badaʾ by erasing that very decree.
The coming-to-be of anything is a new beginning. The existence, survival and continuance of everything must be willed at every moment by the Creator, the Originator, for it to come into being.
The Creator has beautifully introduced Himself: «إنی أنا الله بدیء کل شیء»
God willing, I promise a fuller discussion in the commentary on the magnificent Supplication 33 of al-Sahifa al-Sajjadiyya.