Please explain the meaning of these two hadiths. Imam al-Kazim (AS) says: «God possesses two forms of will and two forms of volition: one is a definitive will and volition, and the other is a will and volition based on resolve. He prohibits something while willing it, and commands something while not willing it! Do you not see that He prohibited Adam and Eve from eating the fruit of that tree, yet He willed that they eat it? Had His will and volition been definitive, and had He not willed them to eat from the fruit of that tree, Adam and Eve’s will and desire could not have prevailed over God’s will. Likewise, He commanded Abraham to sacrifice Ishmael, but He had not definitively willed that he be sacrificed. Had His will and volition been definitive, Abraham’s will could not have prevailed over God’s will and desire».[Al-Kafi, vol. 1, p. 151.}
Abu Basir says: I asked Imam al-Sadiq (AS), “God willed, intended, decreed and made it definitive—was it something He desired and loved?” He replied: «No». I asked, “How could He will, intend, decree and make something definitive, yet not desire it?” The Imam (AS) replied: «This is how it has been transmitted to us».[Al-Kafi, vol. 1, p. 150.}
What Is the Meaning of the Two Hadiths Concerning God’s Will and Decree?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
God has two forms of will: a definitive will, whose fulfilment is subject to no condition, and a volitional will, whose fulfilment depends on the free choice of created beings. God’s prohibition together with His will, or His command without His will, points to these two kinds of will, as is clearly illustrated in the stories of Adam and Abraham.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe Inevitable Will and the Will of Resolve
Will belongs to God alone, but it is brought about either through a creature or without any intermediary.
No creature’s will can be realized unless the Most High Lord has willed that creature to have the capacity to will.
عن أبی الحسن ع قال: إن لله إرادتین و مشیئتین إراده حتم و إراده عزم ینهى و هو یشاء و یأمر و هو لا یشاء أ و ما رأیت أنه نهى آدم و زوجته أن یأکلا من الشجره و شاء ذلک و لو لم یشأ أن یأکلا لما غلبت مشیئتهما مشیئه الله تعالى و أمر إبراهیم أن یذبح إسحاق و لم یشأ أن یذبحه و لو شاء لما غلبت مشیئه إبراهیم مشیئه الله تعالى.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه) ؛ ج1 ؛ ص150 کلینى، محمد بن یعقوب بن اسحاق، 8جلد، دار الکتب الإسلامیه - تهران، چاپ: چهارم، 1407 ق.
Imam al-Rida, peace be upon him, said: “God has two wills and two forms of volition: an inevitable will and a will of resolve. He forbids, though He wills; He commands, though He does not will. Have you not seen that He forbade Adam and his wife to eat from the tree, yet willed it—that is, His will was that if Adam and Eve chose to eat, they would be able to do so? Had He not willed them to eat, their will could not have prevailed over the will of God, Exalted is He. And He commanded Abraham to sacrifice Isaac (in fact, the Prophet Ishmael), though He did not will him to be sacrificed. Had He willed it, Abraham’s will could not have prevailed over the will of God, Exalted is He.”
The inevitable will is the will whose decree and ratification the Creator has made unconditional. The will of resolve is one whose decree and ratification the Creator has made contingent on the realization of human choice: that is, He has ratified human freedom of choice, thereby making the human being capable of choosing. In reality, it is only this will of God that is realized in every case.
The realization of anything means that God has permitted and ratified it—whether He has permitted its occurrence unconditionally or made that permission conditional. In either case, whatever comes to pass is by God’s ratification and command.
If God permits an act of His servant to be realized through choice, then, in accordance with His ratification, the creature will inevitably choose, compelled to do so. In either case, both the creature’s capacity to choose and the occurrence of its act are by God’s permission.
More on this will come in the commentary on Supplication 33, ان شاء الله.