Is there such a thing as an unbelieving doppelgänger, and so on?
Is There Such a Thing as a Jinn Doppelgänger?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
A person does not have a jinn doppelgänger, but an angel and a devil accompany them, each calling their heart in a different direction. Angels protect people, while devils urge them to sin. This companionship reflects the inner struggle within every person and the constant pull toward guidance or misguidance.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterNo human has a jinn twin. But both an angel and a devil accompany each person, each beside the heart, calling it toward itself!
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: ما من قلب إلا و له أذنان على إحداهما ملک مرشد و على الأخرى شیطان مفتن هذا یأمره و هذا یزجره الشیطان یأمره بالمعاصی و الملک یزجره عنها و هو قول الله عز و جل عن الیمین و عن الشمال قعید ما یلفظ من قول إلا لدیه رقیب عتید.
Imam Ja‘far al-Sadiq (AS) said: “There is no heart without two ears. At one is a guiding angel, and at the other, a devil who incites to temptation. One commands it, while the other restrains it. The devil urges it to sin, and the angel holds it back. This is what God, Mighty and Majestic, says: ‘Remember when the two angels, seated on the right and left, receive [a person’s deeds]. Not a word does he utter without a watcher ready at hand.’” Surah, verse 50.
قال رسول الله (ص) ما من إنسان إلا و معه شیطان قالوا و أنت یا رسول الله قال و أنا لکنه أسلم بعون الله و لقد أتانی فأخذت بحلقه و لو لا دعوه سلیمان ع لأصبحن فی المسجد طریحا.
The Messenger of God (PBUH) said: “There is no person who does not have a devil with him.” They asked, “Even you, Messenger of God?” He replied, “Yes, but with God’s help he has submitted. He came to me, and I seized him by the throat. Had it not been for Solomon’s prayer, he would have been left lying in the mosque.”
As I have explained, there is no such thing as a jinn double in the external world. But if by this one means jinn, they have no right to violate people’s privacy or enter their domain, for God has appointed guardians to protect human beings—except for those who, through the occult sciences and mischief, open the way for them to enter.
یا معشر الجن و الإنس إن استطعتم أن تنفذوا من أقطار السماوات و الأرض فانفذوا لا تنفذون إلا بسلطان
“O company of jinn and humankind, if you can pass beyond the regions of the heavens and the earth, then pass beyond them. You cannot pass beyond them except with authority.”
و إن علیکم لحافظین
“And surely there are guardians appointed over you…”
عن أبی بصیر عن أبی عبد الله ع فی قول الله تبارک و تعالى إذ یتلقى المتلقیان عن الیمین و عن الشمال قعید قال هما الملکان و سألته عن قول الله تبارک و تعالى هذا ما لدی عتید قال هو الملک الذی یحفظ علیه عمله و سألته عن قول الله عز و جل قال قرینه ربنا ما أطغیته قال هو شیطان.
الإحتجاج سأل الزندیق الصادق (ع) ما عله الملائکه الموکلین بعباده یکتبون علیهم و لهم و الله عالم السر و ما هو أخفى قال استعبدهم بذلک و جعلهم شهودا على خلقه لیکون العباد لملازمتهم إیاهم أشد على طاعه الله مواظبه و عن معصیته أشد انقباضا و کم من عبد یهم بمعصیه فذکر مکانها فارعوى و کف فیقول ربی یرانی و حفظتی بذلک تشهد «1» و إن الله برأفته و لطفه أیضا وکلهم بعباده یذبون عنهم مرده الشیاطین و هوام الأرض و آفات کثیره من حیث لا یرون بإذن الله إلى أن یجیء أمر الله عز و جل.
“…In truth, through His compassion and grace, God has also appointed [angels] to watch over His servants. By God’s permission, they ward off from them rebellious devils, harmful creatures of the earth, and many other dangers from places people cannot see, until God’s command, Mighty and Majestic, comes [that this protection is no longer to continue].” This narration also points out that the angels who guard people protect them from the dangers posed by rebellious devils, whose nature is to transgress.
Beyond that, it is the very One, the All-Subduing, who watches over all!
فإن تولوا فقد أبلغتکم ما أرسلت به إلیکم و یستخلف ربی قوما غیرکم و لا تضرونه شیئا إن ربی على کل شیء حفیظ
“If you turn away, I have delivered to you the message I was sent to convey. My Lord will bring another people in your place, and you will not harm Him in the least. My Lord is the Guardian and Preserver of all things.”
Question: You said, “A human being has no jinn twin, but is accompanied by both an angel and a devil, each of whom stands beside the heart and calls the person towards itself!”
It is true that Satan calls a person towards himself—that is, towards sin and evil. But we should note that the angel calls the person not towards itself, but towards the one Lord of all existence, the source of all goodness and beauty.
In light of this, is that answer correct?
Master Ali Saei’s answer to the question: Yes, that is so.
However, when the point was pursued and a hadith cited, the omission in the explanation was corrected and the intended meaning clarified. In general, when God’s messengers call someone towards themselves, that call is in fact an invitation towards God. But the point is that we must take care in how we arrange our words, so as not to convey a mistaken impression.
یا أیها الذین آمنوا استجیبوا لله و للرسول إذا دعاکم لما یحییکم و اعلموا أن الله یحول بین المرء و قلبه و أنه إلیه تحشرون
“O you who believe! Respond to God and the Messenger when he calls you to that which gives you life. And know that God comes between a person and his heart, and that you will all be gathered before Him.”
As for the reference to one angel and one devil, although we know that the devils around believers are more numerous than flies gathered around a piece of meat, I should explain that this angel and devil are, in fact, specially appointed agents—not the only ones, nor the first or the last.
عن الفضیل بن یسار قال سمعت أبا عبد الله ع یقول إن الشیاطین أکثر على المؤمن من الزنابیر على اللحم