Peace be upon you. May God grant you strength, dear teacher. If we learn that someone has committed a major sin or done something forbidden (while it is unknown to everyone else), are we allowed to tell the person concerned and speak about it?
May We Reveal Someone Else’s Hidden Major Sin?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
When it comes to revealing someone else’s hidden major sin, we must act according to the circumstances. If the sin has social consequences, the matter should be considered with the relevant legal and religious authorities. Even if its consequences are limited, the situation still needs careful thought. If disclosure would violate someone’s dignity, every aspect must be weighed; sometimes discretion is necessary, and sometimes disclosure is.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterOne must act according to the circumstances. If an individual’s sin has particular social consequences, a decision must be made about whether to inform the relevant legal and religious authorities.
If its consequences are limited—for example, to relatives, family, or the workplace—a decision must still be made, as before.
If the sinner’s wrongdoing has been kept secret, and exposing it would violate their dignity, all aspects of the matter must be carefully considered.
In short, at times it is necessary to conceal a sin, and at others to expose it; one must act according to the circumstances.