#Consultation سلام علیکم A question from one of my relatives:
1- استاد, please explain: between a man's obligations toward his parents and his obligations toward his spouse, which is more binding?
For example, is it permissible for a man, out of fear of upsetting his parents, to live in a way that causes suffering and distress to himself and his wife, and sometimes even involves wronging his wife? In other words, to what extent is a man permitted to disregard and crush his wife for the sake of his parents?
2- If establishing an independent household causes a person to be regarded as disobedient by his parents, is living independently permissible under such circumstances?
3- Under what circumstances may parents regard their children as disobedient?
The Rights of Parents and Spouse: Which Is More Binding on a Man?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
A man's obligations toward his parents and toward his spouse are both binding, and neither replaces the other. Neither set of rights automatically takes precedence over the other, except in situations where the circumstances are equal; such cases require the ruling of a mujtahid. A child's establishing an independent household does not necessarily constitute filial disobedience, unless it is genuinely necessary and results in the parents being left without care or causes harm to their emotional needs.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center1
Everyone has rights, and those rights must be protected. No one’s rights should infringe on another’s, nor can anyone’s rights take the place of someone else’s. The rights of parents and of one’s spouse and family are no exception.
Although a child’s duties toward their parents are great, this does not mean that the rights of others, including their spouse and family, may be disregarded.
There is no general priority between fulfilling one’s parents’ rights and one’s spouse’s rights; each must receive their due. The exception is when the two claims are equal—for example, when maintenance is owed to both parents and spouse—in which case one should act according to the ruling of one’s religious authority.
2
Independence does not always amount to disobedience to one’s parents, unless the child’s presence with them is necessary.
If a child’s independence does not leave their parents without care, does not harm their emotional well-being, and does not prevent the maintenance of family ties—and if independence is necessary—then it need not be considered disobedience.
If the parents consent to their child’s independence, there will be no problem. But if they do not, several situations may arise:
First: If the child’s independence causes no financial, emotional or other difficulties for the parents, while living together entails unbearable hardships and leads the parents to wrong the child’s spouse and family, then independence may itself be an act of kindness toward the parents: it prevents them from committing injustice and keeps them from suffering its consequences. Of course, the child should make amends for living independently by maintaining family ties in appropriate ways and by offering emotional and material support.
Second: If the child’s independence causes difficulties for the parents, but the parents respect the boundaries and dignity of the child’s spouse and do not wrong them in any way, then in this case independence is unquestionably sinful.
Third: If the child’s independence causes difficulties for the parents, but the parents wrong the child’s spouse, and the spouse is unwilling to endure this situation, then a serious decision must be made. On the one hand, independence causes hardship for the parents; on the other, the situation leaves the spouse trapped in the parents’ injustice, ...
3
From so much as saying “uff” to mistreating one’s parents, and to neglecting them or failing to show them kindness! But:
لا طاعه لمخلوق فی معصیه الخالق = Obedience must not lead to disobedience to the Creator.
العنکبوت : 8 و وصینا الإنسان بوالدیه حسنا و إن جاهداک لتشرک بی ما لیس لک به علم فلا تطعهما إلی مرجعکم فأنبئکم بما کنتم تعملون
We have enjoined upon the human being kindness toward their parents. But if they strive to make you associate with Me that of which you have no knowledge, then do not obey them. To Me is your return, and I will tell you what you used to do.
—
عن الباقر ع قال سئل رسول الله ص من أعظم حقا على الرجل قال والداه
Mishkat al-Anwar fi Ghurar al-Akhbar, text, p. 159.