Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
login Login
category محور بنیادین از سند جامع معارف پژوهش‌های عقلی، کلامی، فلسفی و سلوکی

Theology and Creed

بازخوانی خردورزانه مبانی معرفتی، حکمت، کلام و معارف شیعی با تکیه بر سنت عقلانی و پاسخ‌گویی به پرسش‌ها و شبهات نوپدید فکری در پرتو آثار و مباحث استاد علی ساعی (عبدالله مشکات).

مجموع پرسش‌های کهف 73
جلسات صوتی ضبط‌شده 10
ویدیوها و نماهنگ‌ها 19
مقالات پژوهشی عمیق 15
psychology
شارح و استاد محوری Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

شما می‌توانید با پیگیری این دسته‌بندی، از انتشار آخرین جلسات صوتی و پاسخ‌های جدید در حوزه {topic} مطلع شوید.

rss_feed
expand_more
Question code: 36398
10 September 2026

What Role Do Language and Expression Play in Knowledge of Divine Oneness?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Language and expression in knowing the oneness of God are bounded by magnifying and declaring Him transcendent—an approach that is itself the essence of pure tawhid. The conviction that the Lord cannot be described leads one to acknowledge, plainly, one’s inability to describe Him.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36389
10 September 2026

What Is the Difference Between Mediated and Immediate Perception on the Path of Divine Oneness?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The difference between mediated and immediate perception on the path of divine oneness is that everyone moves from immediate perception to mediated perception. True immediate perception is beyond perception: it does not need to be perceived, and we all abide in it. Seeking knowledge of God’s Proof passes through immediacy, as the supplication for the Age of Appearance states.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36391
10 September 2026

Which Decrees Cannot Be Changed by Prayer?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Prayer has no power to change matters that have received God’s final seal, because God has willed that they remain unchanged. These seals include the divine way, the divine words, God’s promise, and the Lord’s appointed time. Badāʾ (the possibility of change) applies to divine decree, but not to what has been finally sealed.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36392
10 September 2026

Does Everything Being Written in the Preserved Tablet Mean That God Willed It All?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Everything being written in the Preserved Tablet does not mean that God willed it all; knowing is not the same as willing. Divine knowledge encompasses will, decree, destiny, and their fulfillment, and has no temporal or spatial framework. The stages that follow, by contrast, unfold within time and space. Divine knowledge transcends the limits of our minds.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36393
10 September 2026

Does a Change in Destiny Mean a Change in God’s Knowledge?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

A change in destiny does not mean a change in God’s knowledge; divine knowledge is unchanging. Change occurs within the sphere of the divine will before the decree takes effect, and even the possibility of *badāʾ* and erasure is already known to God. Divine knowledge encompasses all things and is beyond the limits of our understanding.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36395
10 September 2026

How Can We Reconcile the Mystic’s Experiential Oneness with the Philosopher’s Demonstrative Oneness?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

To reconcile the mystic’s experiential understanding of oneness with the philosopher’s demonstrative one, we must recognize that demonstration leads to oneness only when it articulates an innate vision. This innate vision is the vision of authentic reason, the voice of human nature.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36396
10 September 2026

What Does It Mean to Truly Know God Through God Himself?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

To truly know God through God Himself means that knowledge of Him is a decisive proof from God, placed within human nature. By their own free choice, people choose between acknowledging this knowledge and denying it. Knowledge comes from God; acknowledgment is the servant’s acceptance.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36397
10 September 2026

Are the Degrees of Divine Unity Proportional to the Level of Knowledge?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The degrees of divine unity correspond to a person’s level of knowledge and understanding. Knowledge is the path to recognizing divine unity, and the extent of one’s understanding determines the degree one attains. The perfection of divine unity lies in sincere devotion to the One worshipped, and the perfection of sincerity lies in denying attributes of God.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36388
10 September 2026

Is Fanāʾ the Erasure of the Servant or the Manifestation of the Lord?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The annihilation and abiding of all beings are both signs of the will of the Exalted Lord. The annihilation of beings manifests the Creator’s will that they pass away, while their abiding manifests His will that they endure. In both states—annihilation and abiding—the divine majesty, perfection, and will are manifest at their fullest, and nothing can stand in the way of the manifestation of God’s will.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36381
10 September 2026

Does the Station of the Master of Martyrs Transcend Divine Will?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The station of the Master of Martyrs (AS) even transcends the station of divine will: he describes the hearts of God’s friends as the abode of divine will, while calling himself “the trial of God’s friends.” This means that he possesses a station of divine knowledge that encompasses divine will. The souls of other human beings, too, can be a locus of divine will.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36382
10 September 2026

Can the Existence of the Hereafter Be Proved by Rational and Quranic Arguments?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The existence of the Hereafter can be established through rational and Quranic arguments. Rational arguments include the instinct for survival, sleep and wakefulness, the renewal of nature, and the course of the universe. The Quranic verses also explicitly affirm resurrection, the reward of the righteous in Paradise, and the punishment of the disbelievers in Hell, and describe them as everlasting.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36384
10 September 2026

Why Is Paradise Described with Material Blessings Such as Gold and Pearls?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Describing Paradise with material blessings such as gold and pearls is a way of appealing to hearts drawn to worldly things, while reminding us of the far greater and unimaginable delights of the hereafter. In Paradise, these blessings bring a joy beyond the fleeting pleasures of this world, and serve as good news for those who worship God in hope of reward. Yet the greatest blessing is God’s good pleasure.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36385
10 September 2026

Will God’s Essence Always Remain Beyond the Reach of the Human Intellect?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The essence of the Almighty Lord lies beyond the reach of the human intellect and does not need to be known. We come to know and relate to created beings through the divine names and attributes, for God’s majesty and grandeur are such that He has no need of any description or relationship. In this context, created beings exist within the realm of the divine names, attributes and acts.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36386
10 September 2026

What Is the Tawhidic Mystery Behind the Qur’an’s Combining of Anthropomorphic Language and Transcendence?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The Qur’an’s combination of anthropomorphic language and divine transcendence holds a mystery rooted in tawhid. Anthropomorphic language serves as a bridge for reflection and spiritual journeying toward God. Such language belongs to the category of ambiguous verses and must be understood in light of the clear, decisive verses. The sound doctrine of tawhid is the one set out in the Qur’an: neither absolute negation nor likening God to created beings, but affirmation of God’s existence and attributes without resemblance to creation.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36387
10 September 2026

Does the True Delight of Divine Oneness Lie in Understanding God, or in Admitting That We Cannot?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The true delight of divine oneness lies in a mode of understanding that transcends ordinary comprehension and leads us to the divine state beyond all description. This delight surpasses the ordinary pleasures we experience through understanding and thought. The state beyond description is a state beyond pleasure—it lies beyond pleasure itself.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36374
10 September 2026

What does “أحصیناه” mean in the verse “کل شیء أحصیناه فی إمام مبین”?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

In the verse “کل شیء أحصیناه فی إمام مبین,” “احصاء” means recording something quantitatively and qualitatively, with all its calculations and attributes; providing a complete and precise record, down to every nuance and subtlety; making a comprehensive and complete record of it in knowledge; and encompassing and mastering it in all its general and particular details. The Clear Imam is the very reality of the wilayah of the Immaculate Imams, peace be upon them, in whom the knowledge of all things is encompassed.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36375
10 September 2026

What Is the Philosophy Behind the Existence of an Imam, and How Does He Differ from a Social Reformer?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The Imam is the truth and spirit that governs the backbone of creation, and creation cannot do without him. When an Imam is martyred, another succeeds him without delay. The wisdom behind the continuity of the Imamate despite oppression lies in the test of creation; the establishment of the order of truth in its fullness will come to pass at the end of time.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36369
10 September 2026

What is the duty toward those who remove their hijab in the name of opposing the system?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

Those who remove their hijab in the name of opposing the system, or appear naked in public, fall into a category of disbelief, and their actions must be disavowed. Under certain conditions, the duty to enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong must not be neglected in dealing with them. In this context, disbelief means abandoning God’s commands and committing what He has forbidden.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36370
10 September 2026

What Is the Created Spirit, and How Does the Believer’s Spirit Differ from the Unbeliever’s?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

All spirits, including the spirit attributed to God, are His creation and were once nonexistent. The spirit attributed to God is His chosen and honored spirit, which He created and joins to whomever He wills. The spirit grows subtle and light through greater knowledge of God and piety, under the guidance of the Two Weighty Things (the Qur’an and the Prophet’s Household).

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Question code: 36372
10 September 2026

Who Are the Partisans of Personal Opinion, and How Can They Be Recognised?

verified Concise response by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Mishkat):

The partisans of personal opinion are those who disregard the inseparable bond between the Prophet’s family and the Qur’an, refuse to accept the authority of the Ahl al-Bayt (peace be upon them), and, when deriving religious rulings, place their own opinions above the rulings of the Imams (peace be upon them). They may try to justify this unwarranted preference with specious arguments.

منظومه معارف کهف سؤال Full text of the question and answer west
Display: از مجموع ۹۹ اثر در این بخش