Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2791 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Was Moses’ Rebuke of Aaron Due to His Denial of Calf-Worship in the System of Creation?

Primary reference: See the answer text 36 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The claim that Moses' rebuke of Aaron was because he denied the worship of the calf within the system of creation is a blatant slander against God and His messengers. The system of creation is founded upon monotheism, and there is no creaturely (takwīnī) polytheism. Divine permission pertains to the actualization of the creatures' voluntary acts, not to polytheism itself. The worship of the calf occurred within the system of legislation (tashrīʿ) and by divine permission, in order to bring about the will of the Children of Israel—not that polytheism itself is permissible within the system of creation.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

The person making this claim has plainly slandered God and His messengers!

It is clear that this person has no sound understanding of the divine order of creation and is unfamiliar with the order of divine legislation and its relationship to the order of creation.

We know that every act that takes place in the universe—even an act of polytheism or idol worship—does so by God’s permission and leave. That is, unless this permission is granted, the act cannot take place. Put simply, a creature’s voluntary act takes place only when divine permission for its realization has been granted. In other words, the unique Creator wills and gives effect to the creature’s exercise of choice in bringing the act about. This does not mean that the Most High Creator wills a creature’s act without the creature having any part in it; rather, He wills the realization of the act chosen by His creature—even though the all-powerful Creator has power and freedom over every act.

In the matter of calf worship, the Creator of the universe did not will or desire that the calf be worshipped. Rather, the people of the Children of Israel intended to worship the calf, and God granted permission for their wish to be realized.

It should be noted that every voluntary act of created beings must be brought into effect by God, the Creator and the One who wills, in order to take place.

In the order of creation, the foundation is divine oneness and the worship of one God; there is no place for polytheism or idol worship. In truth, no permission for polytheism or idol worship has been granted in the order of creation. In the order of divine legislation, God’s will operates within its own particular framework in bringing about the intentions and actions of created beings, whether they involve monotheism, polytheism or anything else.

Polytheism is not part of the order of creation; nor can it be considered true worship or interpreted as worship of God. In the order of creation, worship is realized through sincerity and the worship of the One alone.

Clear evidence for this is found in the verses cited below, which attribute polytheism to ignorance, not knowledge:

الحج : 71 و یعبدون من دون الله ما لم ینزل به سلطانا و ما لیس لهم به علم و ما للظالمین من نصیر

They worship, besides God, things for which He has sent down no authority, and of which they have no knowledge. The wrongdoers will have no helper or guide!

العنکبوت : 8 و وصینا الإنسان بوالدیه حسنا و إن جاهداک لتشرک بی‏ ما لیس لک به علم فلا تطعهما إلی مرجعکم فأنبئکم بما کنتم تعملون

We have enjoined upon the human being kindness to his parents. But if they strive to make you associate with Me something of which you have no knowledge, do not obey them. To Me you will all return, and I will inform you of what you used to do!

غافر : 42 تدعوننی‏ لأکفر بالله و أشرک به ما لیس لی‏ به علم و أنا أدعوکم إلى العزیز الغفار

You call upon me to disbelieve in God and associate with Him something of which I have no knowledge, while I call you to the Almighty, the All-Forgiving!

Those who maintain that the calf’s worship was part of the order of creation believe that the Prophet Moses, peace be upon him, was distressed because Aaron, peace be upon him, was upset by the calf worship. In other words, they seem to suggest that Moses should have been pleased, since the Children of Israel were merely exhibiting behaviour determined by the order of creation—in other words, that they were compelled to worship the calf. This was certainly not the case; such a claim is a slander against God and His messengers.

The verses concerning the Children of Israel’s calf worship and their subsequent punishment leave no room for the false claim made by those who assert that polytheism belongs to the order of creation:

و إذ واعدنا موسى أربعین لیله ثم اتخذتم‏ العجل من بعده و أنتم ظالمون(51)

ثم‏ عفونا عنکم من بعد ذالک لعلکم تشکرون(52)

و إذ ءاتینا موسى الکتاب و الفرقان لعلکم تهتدون(53)

و إذ قال موسى‏ لقومه یاقوم إنکم ظلمتم أنفسکم باتخاذکم العجل فتوبوا إلى‏ بارئکم فاقتلوا أنفسکم ذالکم خیر لکم عند بارئکم فتاب علیکم إنه هو التواب الرحیم(54)

And (remember) when We appointed a time with Moses for forty nights, and he came to the appointed place to receive the divine commandments, you took the calf as your object of worship after he had gone, and you were wrongdoers. (51)

Then We pardoned you after that, so that you might give thanks for this blessing. (52)

And (remember) when We gave Moses the Book and the Criterion, so that you might be guided. (53)

And when Moses said to his people, “My people, by choosing the calf to worship, you have wronged yourselves! So repent and return to your Creator, and kill yourselves [one another]! That is better for you in the sight of your Lord.” Then God accepted your repentance, for He is the Accepter of repentance, the Merciful. (54)

And (remember) when you said, “Moses, we will never believe you unless we see God plainly with our own eyes!” Then the thunderbolt seized you as you looked on. (55)

Then We brought you back to life after your death, so that you might give thanks for His blessing. (56)

البقره : 92 و لقد جاءکم موسى‏ بالبینات ثم اتخذتم العجل من بعده و أنتم ظالمون
Moses certainly brought you clear signs and proofs, yet after he had gone to Mount Sinai, you took the calf as an object of worship, wronging yourselves and the signs of God.

البقره : 93 و إذ أخذنا میثاقکم و رفعنا فوقکم الطور خذوا ما آتیناکم بقوه و اسمعوا قالوا سمعنا و عصینا و أشربوا فی‏ قلوبهم العجل بکفرهم قل بئسما یأمرکم به إیمانکم إن کنتم مؤمنین
And (remember) when We took your covenant and raised Mount Sinai above you, (saying,) “Hold firmly to what We have given you from the verses of the Torah, and listen and obey.” They said, “We hear,” but inwardly they meant, “We disobey.” Because of their disbelief, love of the calf had taken root in their hearts. Say, “If you are believers—and your faith commands you to worship the calf, kill, and deny the prophets—then what a terrible thing your faith commands you to do!”

الأعراف : 152 إن الذین اتخذوا العجل سینالهم غضب من ربهم و ذله فی الحیاه الدنیا و کذلک نجزی المفترین
Those who took the calf as their object of worship will soon be visited by their Lord’s wrath and humiliation in the life of this world. Thus do We punish those who fabricate lies against God!

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022