What does it mean to worship the calf in the genesis (takwīnī) sense?
What Does It Mean to Worship the Calf in the Genesis (Takwīnī) Sense?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The worship of idols and bodies does not return to the divine realm. Every creature lies within the sphere of God's power and servitude; the monotheist servant is pleasing [to God], while the polytheist servant is subject to [His] wrath. Worship means expressing the servitude that is pleasing to God, not every state and utterance. The practice of polytheism unfolds in accordance with the divine will, as a test of servitude, and its occurrence is by God's permission. The command to honor one's parents is legislative (tashrīʿī), not genesis (takwīnī), because parental disobedience does in fact occur.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe One, All-Compelling God has not ordained that the worship of idols and bodies should be directed toward His sacred presence.
There is no doubt that no creature among God’s creation—whether monotheist or polytheist—can step outside the sphere of divine power, authority and sovereignty, or escape the circle of servitude to Him. The monotheistic and God-fearing servant is one who is accepted at God’s court, while the rebellious polytheist is a servant who has incurred God’s wrath. The servant accepted by God is the one who worships Him, whereas the servant who has incurred His wrath is the one who has deviated from worshipping God.
Worship means manifesting one’s servitude to God in the manner approved by the One worshipped. Only a state, utterance or action that leads to the satisfaction of the Eternal Beloved can be considered worship; otherwise, no state, utterance or action is worship. Worship has a path, and it must be attained solely through that path.
There is no doubt that the polytheistic acts of polytheists and sinners do not fall outside the sphere of the power, will and determination of the Self-Sufficient Lord. The practice of polytheism, in accordance with the divine will, allows the creature’s desire to be realised through the exercise of the privilege of free choice, so that the servant’s worship may be tested and tried. In reality, in this matter Almighty God grants permission for the creature’s act to take place.
Consider the noble verse:
الإسراء : 23 و قضى ربک ألا تعبدوا إلا إیاه و بالوالدین إحسانا إما یبلغن عندک الکبر أحدهما أو کلاهما فلا تقل لهما أف و لا تنهرهما و قل لهما قولا کریما
“Your Lord has commanded that you worship none but Him, and show kindness to your parents. If one or both of them reach old age in your presence, never say to them even ‘uff,’ nor rebuke them, but speak to them graciously.”
The command of the Lord in this noble verse is God’s legislative command concerning worship. Otherwise, if the Lord’s command were creative and ontological, self-worship, idol-worship, sin and disobedience could not occur; nor could the very root of polytheism come into existence. A careful examination proves this point:
The same command has also been issued concerning respect for parents. If the command to respect them in this verse were ontological, disobedience to parents would have no meaning. Yet we know that filial disobedience is an established reality.
5-15-2 The Inevitable Will and the Determinate Will
Will belongs exclusively to God, but its realisation may occur either through a creature or without any intermediary.
No will can be realised by any creature unless the Exalted Lord has willed that His creature possess the capacity to exercise a will.
عن أبی الحسن ع قال: إن لله إرادتین و مشیئتین إراده حتم و إراده عزم ینهى و هو یشاء و یأمر و هو لا یشاء أ و ما رأیت أنه نهى آدم و زوجته أن یأکلا من الشجره و شاء ذلک و لو لم یشأ أن یأکلا لما غلبت مشیئتهما مشیئه الله تعالى و أمر إبراهیم أن یذبح إسحاق و لم یشأ أن یذبحه و لو شاء لما غلبت مشیئه إبراهیم مشیئه الله تعالى.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه) ؛ ج1 ؛ ص150 کلینى، محمد بن یعقوب بن اسحاق، 8جلد، دار الکتب الإسلامیه - تهران، چاپ: چهارم، 1407 ق.
Imam al-Rida, peace be upon him, said: “God has two wills and two acts of willing: an inevitable will and a determinate will. He forbids while willing, and commands while not willing. Have you not seen that He forbade Adam and his wife to eat from the appointed tree, while willing that they do so? Had He not willed that they eat, their will and desire could not have prevailed over the will of God, Most High. And He commanded Abraham to sacrifice Isaac—though, of course, it was Ishmael—and did not will that he be sacrificed. Had He willed it, Abraham’s will could not have prevailed over the will of God, Most High.”
The inevitable will is the will concerning which the Creator has issued and ratified His decree. The determinate will is the will concerning which the Creator has made the realisation of His decree and ratification conditional upon human choice—in other words, He has ratified human free choice, thereby granting human beings the capacity to choose. In reality, it is only God’s will that is realised in every case.
The realisation of anything means that God has granted permission for it and ratified it, whether that permission to occur and come into being is unconditional or subject to certain conditions. In both cases, whatever comes to pass is God’s ratification and God’s command.
If God’s permission is directed toward the realisation of an optional act by His servant, then, in accordance with His ratification, the creature will inevitably exercise a choice and will choose under compulsion and coercion. In either case—the creation of the capacity to choose and the occurrence of the creature’s act—both take place by God’s permission.
Faḍīl ibn Yasār said: “I heard Abū ʿAbd Allāh ع say:
شاء و أراد و لم یحب و لم یرض شاء أن لا یکون شیء إلا بعلمه و أراد مثل ذلک و لم یحب أن یقال ثالث ثلاثه و لم یرض لعباده الکفر.
Al-Kāfī (Islamiyyah edition), vol. 1, p. 150. Al-Kulaynī, Muḥammad ibn Yaʿqūb ibn Isḥāq, 8 vols., Dār al-Kutub al-Islāmiyyah, Tehran, fourth edition, 1407 AH.
Faḍīl ibn Yasār narrated: “I heard Imam Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq عليه السلام say: ‘There are things God has willed and decreed, yet neither loved nor approved. He willed that nothing should exist except through His knowledge, and He willed the same concerning this matter. Yet He did not love that it be said that God is one of three gods, nor has He approved disbelief for His servants.’”
To love something means that the Almighty Lord loves His servant to do it by his own choice and volition.
The Lord’s not loving something means that He does not approve of its being done, while He has nevertheless granted His servant the possibility of bringing it about.