Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 1852 20 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

What Is God, and What Does He Look Like? A Question Posed to Imam Ali (AS)

Primary reference: See the answer text 58 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-1852

What is God, and What Does He Look Like?*
* A Question Put to Imam Ali (AS)

A question that has surely crossed the minds of most people—Muslim and non-Muslim, young and old—is: Where did God come from? Where is He now? What is He made of, and what existed before God?

If you, too, would like answers to these questions, you should know that our reason and understanding cannot reach that level. But Imam Ali (AS), in response to the question of the unbelievers about God, gave a beautiful answer, explaining both the limits of our understanding and our inability to comprehend God’s existence.

The unbelievers asked Imam Ali (AS):

“In what year and on what date did your God come into existence?”

The Imam replied: “God existed before the creation of time, history, and everything else that exists.”

The unbelievers said: “How can that be? Everything that comes into existence must either have something before it from which it came, or must have been transformed from something else!”

Imam Ali (AS) said: “What number comes before three?”

They answered: “Two.”

The Imam asked: “And what number comes before two?”

They answered: “One.”

The Imam asked: “And what comes before one?”

They answered: “Nothing.”

The Imam said: “How can it be that the number one, after which there are so many other numbers, has nothing before it, yet it is impossible for there to be nothing before God, who is truly One and Unique?”

The unbelievers said: “Where is your God? In which direction is He?”

The Imam replied: “He is present everywhere and watches over all things.”

They said: “How can you be everywhere and oversee every direction?”

The Imam said: “If you were asleep in a dark place, and woke in the morning, from which direction and where would you see the light?”

The unbelievers answered: “Everywhere, and from every direction.”

The Imam said: “Then how can the God who is Himself the Light of the heavens and the earth not be everywhere?”

The unbelievers said: “Then your God is made of light—but light comes from the sun. What is your God made of? How can He be made of nothing, be everywhere, and still have power?”

The Imam said: “God Himself created the sun and the light. Have you never seen the power of a storm and the wind? What is wind made of? You cannot see it, and it is made of nothing, yet it is powerful. God Himself created the wind.”

They said: “Describe your God to us. What is He made of? Is He hard like iron, flowing like water, or like smoke and vapour?”

The Imam replied: “Have you ever been beside someone who was dying and spoken with them?”

They said: “Yes, we have.”

The Imam asked: “Did you speak with them after they had died?”

They said: “No. How could we speak with them when they were dead?”

The Imam said: “What was the difference between being dead and being alive that made them unable to speak or move?”

They answered: “The soul had left the body.”

The Imam said: “You were there, and you say that the soul left the body and the person died. Now describe for me that soul which left before your eyes. What was it made of, and what was it like?”

Everyone fell silent.

Imam Ali (AS) said: “You cannot describe the soul that left the body of God’s creation before your very eyes. How, then, can you comprehend the essence of the Most Holy and One God, the Creator of the soul?”

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Human reason and understanding cannot grasp the essence of God. Hadiths narrated from Imam Ali (AS) and Imam Baqir (AS) in al-Kafi state that God existed before time and space. Asking “Where?” in relation to God is meaningless, because He existed when there was no place. God’s essence cannot be described in material terms such as light or body; He alone is the Creator of all things.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

The statement, “Where did God come from? Where is He now? What is He made of, and what was there before God?!!” ... “If you, too, would like answers to these questions, you should know that our reason, insight and understanding cannot reach that level”—which seems intended as an introduction to the hadith—is not correct. God is neither bound by time nor subject to modality, so there is no super-rational or transcendent level for anyone to attain in order to know Him. God is not temporal and has no modality for anyone’s reason to reach.

I have not found the source of the hadith attributed here. Its translation seems to have fundamental weaknesses; without access to the Arabic text, it is difficult to judge. Hadiths of this kind address many of these questions.

عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: جاء حبر من الأحبار إلى أمیر المؤمنین ع فقال یا أمیر المؤمنین‏ متى کان ربک فقال له ثکلتک أمک و متى لم یکن حتى یقال متى کان کان ربی قبل القبل بلا قبل و بعد البعد بلا بعد و لا غایه و لا منتهى لغایته انقطعت الغایات عنده فهو منتهى کل غایه فقال یا أمیر المؤمنین أ فنبی أنت فقال ویلک إنما أنا عبد من عبید محمد ص و روی أنه سئل ع أین کان ربنا قبل أن یخلق سماء و أرضا فقال ع أین سؤال عن مکان و کان الله و لا مکان.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج‏1، ص: 89

Imam al-Sadiq (AS) said: One of the great Jewish scholars came to the Commander of the Faithful (AS) and said, “O Commander of the Faithful, since when has your Lord existed?” He replied, “May your mother mourn you! Was there ever a time when He did not exist, such that one might ask when He began to exist? My Lord was before all that is before, with no ‘before,’ and will be after all that is after, with no ‘after.’ There is no end, nor any limit to His end. All ends cease at Him; He is the end of every end.” The man asked, “O Commander of the Faithful, are you a prophet?” He replied, “Woe to you! I am only one of Muhammad’s servants.” It is also narrated that he was asked, “Where was our Lord before He created the heavens and the earth?” He replied, “‘Where’ is a question about place. God existed when there was no place.”

عن أبی بصیر قال: جاء رجل إلى أبی جعفر ع فقال له أخبرنی عن ربک متى کان فقال ویلک إنما یقال لشی‏ء لم یکن متى کان إن ربی تبارک و تعالى کان و لم یزل «1» حیا بلا کیف و لم یکن له کان و لا کان لکونه کون کیف و لا کان له أین و لا کان فی شی‏ء و لا کان على شی‏ء و لا ابتدع لمکانه مکانا و لا قوی بعد ما کون الأشیاء و لا کان ضعیفا قبل أن یکون شیئا و لا کان مستوحشا قبل أن یبتدع شیئا و لا یشبه شیئا مذکورا و لا کان خلوا من الملک قبل إنشائه «1» و لا یکون منه خلوا بعد ذهابه لم یزل حیا بلا حیاه و ملکا قادرا قبل أن ینشئ شیئا و ملکا جبارا بعد إنشائه للکون فلیس لکونه کیف و لا له أین و لا له حد و لا یعرف بشی‏ء یشبهه و لا یهرم لطول البقاء و لا یصعق «2» لشی‏ء بل لخوفه تصعق الأشیاء کلها کان حیا بلا حیاه حادثه و لا کون موصوف و لا کیف محدود و لا أین موقوف علیه و لا مکان جاور شیئا بل حی یعرف و ملک لم یزل له القدره و الملک أنشأ ما شاء حین شاء بمشیئته لا یحد و لا یبعض و لا یفنى کان أولا بلا کیف و یکون آخرا بلا أین و کل شی‏ء هالک إلا وجهه له الخلق و الأمر «3» تبارک الله رب العالمین ویلک أیها السائل إن ربی لا تغشاه الأوهام و لا تنزل به الشبهات و لا یحار «4» و لا یجاوزه شی‏ء و لا تنزل به الأحداث و لا یسأل عن شی‏ء و لا یندم على شی‏ء و لا تأخذه سنه و لا نوم له ما فی السماوات و ما فی الأرض و ما بینهما و ما تحت الثرى‏.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج‏1، ص: 88

Abu Basir relates: A man came to Imam al-Baqir (AS) and said, “Tell me: since when has your Lord existed?” He replied, “Woe to you! ‘Since when?’ is asked only of something that did not exist before. My Lord—blessed and exalted is He—has always existed, living without modality. There was no ‘becoming’ for Him, nor was His existence something that came to be. His existence has no ‘how’; He has no ‘where.’ He is not in anything, nor is He upon anything. He did not create a place for Himself, and after bringing all things into being He gained no new strength. Before creating them, He was not weak. Before bringing any creature into being, He was not lonely. He resembles nothing that can be named. Before creation, He was not without dominion, nor will He be without it after all things pass away.

“He has always been living—not through a life that is joined to Him—and is King and All-Powerful before creating anything. After bringing the universe into being, He is the Almighty King. His existence has no modality or form; He has no place or boundary. He is not known through resemblance to anything. He does not grow old through lasting forever, nor is He struck down by anything. Rather, all things are struck down by awe of Him. He is living, but not through a life that came into being; His existence is not something that can be described, His modality is not bounded, and He is not confined to a place. He does not dwell in a place alongside anything. Rather, He is the Living One, known to all, and the King whose power and dominion have always endured.

“By His will, He brought into being whatever He wished, whenever He wished. He is neither bounded nor divisible, and He does not perish. He is the First, without modality, and the Last, without being confined to a place. Everything perishes except His Face; creation and command belong to Him. Blessed is God, Lord of the worlds.

“Woe to you, questioner! Imaginations cannot encompass my Lord, doubts cannot assail Him, and He is never perplexed. Nothing goes beyond Him, nor do events befall Him. He is not questioned about anything, nor does He regret anything. Neither slumber nor sleep overtakes Him. To Him belongs all that is in the heavens and the earth, all that is between them, and all that lies beneath the soil.”
Woe to you, questioner! Truly, my Lord is not subject to delusions, nor does any doubt revolve around Him. He is not bewildered, nothing passes into the sanctuary of His Essence, and no event befalls Him. He is not held accountable for anything, nor does He feel regret over anything. Neither drowsiness nor sleep overtakes Him. To Him belongs all that is in the heavens and the earth, all that lies between them, and all that is beneath the soil.

Usul al-Kafi, translated by Kamare'i, vol. 1, p. 260

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022