Greetings. In one of our Islamic studies classes, the instructor raised a question: Why are the principles of religion said to be three—divine oneness, prophethood, and resurrection? I am asking because the commonly cited principles of religion are five. Yet the instructor wrote on the board that, after gaining understanding, they are three: divine oneness, prophethood, and resurrection.
I asked one of the instructors on a religious Q&A forum, and this was the answer:
Is this correct?
The principles of Islam, which all Muslims accept as the fundamental principles of Islam, are three: divine oneness, prophethood, and resurrection. However, these principles themselves have branches and dimensions‼
One dimension of the discussion of divine oneness concerns the divine attributes. The question of divine justice also falls within the discussion of the divine attributes. However, because two different views have emerged concerning the interpretation of divine justice—one among a group of Muslims known as the Ashʿarites and another among a group known as the Adliyya, which includes the Shiites and Muʿtazilites—justice has come to be regarded as a distinctive principle of the Adliyya. Otherwise, the discussion of divine justice is not separate from the discussion of divine oneness.
Since the discussion of justice is one of the points distinguishing the Shiites and Muʿtazilites from the Ashʿarites, justice has been counted among the principles of the doctrine of these two groups, so that it may serve as a distinguishing feature separating them from the Ashʿarites.
The question of the imamate is also one of the matters that most Muslims, both Shiite and Sunni, consider obligatory. However, there are differences between Sunnism and Shiism regarding the nature of this matter. One such difference is that Sunnis regard the imamate as a jurisprudential matter and as one of the branches of religion, whereas Shiites regard the imamate as a continuation of prophethood and as one of its branches. In other words, they hold that the Imam must possess all the qualifications and responsibilities of a prophet, except for receiving revelation.
Therefore, from the Shiite perspective, the imamate is not an independent principle separate from prophethood; rather, it is its continuation. Since this belief distinguishes Shiites from other Muslims, the imamate is counted among the principles of the Shiite doctrine.
Thus, Islam in fact has no more than three fundamental principles; the other matters of belief, such as the imamate and divine justice, are branches and offshoots of these three principles.
Indeed, Islam essentially has one fundamental principle, namely pure monotheism, while prophethood and resurrection are its corollaries. Thus, the fundamental principle of the principles of religion is divine oneness, and the rest are branches of this principle.‼