What is meant by the knowledge that the hadiths urge us to seek, especially when young people are specifically encouraged to pursue it? Could this include the university education and advanced degrees that most young people pursue today? If the knowledge in question is knowledge that brings us closer to God, how can we tell whether the knowledge we are pursuing brings us closer to Him—or, on the contrary, takes us farther away?
Answer
What Is Meant by the Knowledge Emphasized in the Hadiths?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The knowledge whose pursuit is emphasized in the hadiths is knowledge of piety, certainty, and self-knowledge—the kind that brings a person closer to God. Beneficial knowledge leads a person to sincere action and adorns them in this world and the next. It is difficult to distinguish true knowledge from ignorance without the guidance of the Quran and the Ahl al-Bayt, since many people pursue ignorance in place of knowledge.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterKnowledge is light, and light is essential to human life. Every kind of knowledge can illuminate the path of spiritual wayfaring—even knowledge of how to earn a living.
Yet without the Qur’an and the Prophet’s Household, it is difficult to distinguish knowledge from ignorance; the two are separated by a hair’s breadth. How many people, instead of seeking knowledge, pursue ignorance! They mistakenly think themselves students of knowledge, when in fact they are seekers of ignorance—and do not even realize it.
Knowledge, then, is something to be sought. But the kinds of knowledge for which we must give our very lives are the knowledge of piety and certainty, and the knowledge of the self.
قال الصادق ع العلم أصل کل حال سنی و منتهى کل منزله رفیعه و لذلک قال النبی ص طلب العلم فریضه على کل مسلم و مسلمه أی علم التقوى و الیقین و قال علی ع اطلبوا العلم و لو بالصین و هو علم معرفه النفس و فیه معرفه الرب عز و جل و قال النبی ص من عرف نفسه فقد عرف ربه ثم علیک من العلم بما لا یصح العمل إلا به و هو الإخلاص قال النبی ص نعوذ بالله من علم لا ینفع و هو العلم الذی یضاد العمل بالإخلاص و اعلم أن قلیل العلم یحتاج إلى کثیر العمل لأن علم ساعه یلزم صاحبه استعماله طول دهره قال عیسى ابن مریم ع رأیت حجرا علیه مکتوب اقلبنی فقلبته فإذا على باطنه مکتوب من لا یعمل بما یعلم مشئوم علیه طلب ما لا یعلم و مردود علیه ما علم أوحى الله تعالى إلى داود ع إن أهون ما أنا صانع بعالم غیر عامل بعلمه أشد من سبعین عقوبه باطنه أن أخرج من قلبه حلاوه ذکری و لیس إلى الله سبحانه طریق یسلک إلا بعلم و العلم زین المرء فی الدنیا و الآخره و سائقه إلى الجنه و به یصل إلى رضوان الله تعالى و العالم حقا هو الذی ینطق عنه أعماله الصالحه و أوراده الزاکیه و صدقه و تقواه لا لسانه و مناظرته و معادلته و تصاوله و دعواه و لقد کان یطلب هذا العلم فی غیر هذا الزمان من کان فیه عقل و نسک و حکمه و حیاء و خشیه و إنا نرى طالبه الیوم من لیس فیه من ذلک شیء و العالم یحتاج إلى عقل و رفق و شفقه و نصح و حلم و صبر و قناعه و بذل و المتعلم یحتاج إلى رغبه و إراده و فراغ و نسک و خشیه و حفظ و حزم
مصباح الشریعه، ص: 13
Imam al-Sadiq (AS) said: “Knowledge is the root of every noble state and the highest point of every exalted station. That is why the Prophet (PBUH) said, ‘Seeking knowledge is a duty incumbent upon every Muslim man and woman’—meaning knowledge of piety and certainty.
“He also said, ‘Seek knowledge, even in China.’ This means knowledge of the self, for through knowledge of the self one comes to know the Lord, Mighty and Glorious. The Prophet (PBUH) also said, ‘Whoever knows himself knows his Lord.’
“Next, you must acquire the knowledge without which your actions cannot be sound: the knowledge of sincerity. The Prophet (PBUH) said, ‘We seek refuge in God from knowledge that brings no benefit.’ This is knowledge that leads to action contrary to sincerity.
“Know that even a little knowledge calls for much action. Once a person has gained knowledge of something, they must put it into practice throughout their life.
“Jesus son of Mary (AS) said, ‘I saw a stone with the words “Turn me over” written on it. I turned it over, and on its other side I found written: “For the one who does not act upon what he knows, seeking what he does not know is a misfortune, and what he does know will turn against him.”’
“God Most High revealed to David (AS): ‘The least I do to a scholar who does not act upon his knowledge is more severe than seventy inward punishments: I remove from his heart the sweetness of remembering Me.’
“There is no path to God, Glorified and Exalted is He, except through knowledge. Knowledge is a person’s adornment in this world and the next; it leads them to Paradise, and by it they attain God’s good pleasure.
“A true scholar is one whose good deeds, pure devotions, truthfulness, and piety speak for him—not his tongue, disputation, argument, contentiousness, attacks, or claims. In earlier times, those who sought this knowledge possessed reason, devotion, wisdom, modesty, and reverent fear. But today we see people seeking it who possess none of these qualities.
“A scholar needs reason, gentleness, compassion, sincerity in conduct, forbearance, patience, contentment, generosity, and an open hand. A student, too, needs eagerness, determination, free time, devotion, reverent fear, attentiveness, and resolve.”
Misbah al-Shari‘a, p. 13
Imam al-Sadiq (AS) said that knowledge is the root of every noble state and the highest point of every exalted station. That is why the Messenger of God (PBUH) said, “Seeking knowledge is a duty incumbent upon every Muslim man and woman.” He meant knowledge concerning piety and the attainment of certainty.
He also said, “Seek knowledge, even in China.” This refers to knowledge of the self, for knowing the self leads to knowledge of the Lord Most High.
The Messenger of God (PBUH) said, “Whoever knows himself has surely known his Lord.” You must then acquire the knowledge that helps you perfect your actions and fulfil your duties—the knowledge of sincerity, without which no action can be sound or accepted.
The Messenger of God (PBUH) said, “I seek refuge in God from an action that brings no benefit.” Such an action is one performed without sincerity, and one that instead yields the opposite of sincerity.
Bear in mind that even a little knowledge calls for much action. Once a person has gained knowledge of something, they must continue to act in accordance with it throughout their life.
Jesus (AS) said, “I saw a stone with the words ‘Turn me over’ written on it. I turned it over, and on the other side I found written: ‘For the one who does not act upon what he knows, seeking what he does not know is a misfortune, and what he does know will turn against him.’” Knowledge that is not matched by action becomes a burden to its bearer.
God Most High revealed to David (AS): “The least I do to a scholar who does not act upon his knowledge is to take from his heart the sweetness and delight of remembering and conversing with Me; and this is more severe for him than seventy inward punishments.”
Know that there is no path to God Most High except through knowledge. Until a person has learned their duties and become familiar with the signs along the way and the disciplines of spiritual wayfaring, they cannot travel this path. Knowledge, then, is an adornment to a person in the outward life of this world; in its inward reality, it guides them toward Paradise and leads them to the station of God Most High’s good pleasure.
The true scholar, from whom one should seek guidance, is someone whose good, pure, and upright deeds, and whose piety, reveal their inner state—not someone whose standing is supposedly shown by their speech, disputation, argument with others, contentiousness, attacks, or claims. In earlier times, those who sought knowledge possessed reason, devotion, modesty, and reverent fear. But today we see people seeking knowledge who have none of these qualities.
A scholar needs reason, gentleness, compassion, sincerity and purity in conduct, forbearance, patience, generosity in sharing knowledge, and an open hand. A student, too, must possess eagerness, enthusiasm, determination, leisure to study, devotion, reverent fear, attentiveness to their duties, and care in retaining what they learn. They need these qualities to succeed in their studies and remain steadfast on this path.
Misbah al-Shari‘a, translated by Mostafavi, main text, p. 257
All the questions were posted in the Telegram group “Cave of Questions, Ruby of Answers,” and the answers are by Master Ali Saei.