What is our duty toward someone who unwittingly promotes unbelief and shirk? Is it permissible to declare such people unbelievers?
Can the fame and public standing of someone who disseminates statements and principles rooted in shirk prevent us from criticising what they say?
What Is Our Duty Toward an Unwitting Promoter of Unbelief and Shirk? Is Takfīr Permissible?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
It is incumbent upon those who affirm God’s oneness to prevent the spread of shirk. A person who commits shirk is an unbeliever; there is no need to declare them one. But if they persist in promoting shirk, their unbelief must be publicly declared so that others may be protected from doctrinal harm. Fame and public esteem are no reason to refrain from scrutinising what they say and speaking the truth.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe foundation of the religion of gnosis is tawhid. All monotheists are obliged to prevent anyone who promotes shirk from spreading it and to curb its expansion. A polytheist is an unbeliever; there is no need to declare him one. But if someone who promotes shirk persists in doing so, everyone is obliged to publicly declare that person an unbeliever, in order to protect people from the doctrinal harms of shirk.
God, the Almighty, is dearer than anyone else. Outward prestige and fame do not absolve anyone of the consequences of their words and actions.