What is the difference between reason and instinct, bearing in mind that all inanimate objects and plants possess reason and consciousness, and that all things are governed by the principle of “the matter between the two matters”?
What Is the Difference Between Reason and Instinct?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
In human beings, fitra—the innate disposition—encompasses knowledge, principles, and the practices of servitude to God, with reason as its guide. Instinct, by contrast, refers to a set of particular dispositions and sensory faculties that help both humans and animals meet the specific demands of life. Every being has its own acts of worship: in humans, these are carried out through fitra and reason; in animals, through a guiding faculty.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterMaster Ali Saei:
Fitrah, in the case of human beings, may be understood as the knowledge, principles, and practices of servitude to God that He has placed within human nature. Reason sets fitrah in motion, along with its other distinctive functions.
Instinct, by contrast, may be understood as a set of particular practices and sensitivities that enable human beings and other animals alike to attain certain specific aspects of life.
Every being is engaged in worshipping God and has duties toward its Creator that it must fulfil. In human beings, these duties are bound up with fitrah and reason; animals, too, certainly have their own particular duties, guided and directed by a force that acquaints them with their acts of worship.