Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 547 4 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

What Is the Difference Between Taqwa and Waraʿ?

Primary reference: See the answer text 58 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Taqwa is the strength to protect oneself from sins and observe the etiquette of servitude before God. Waraʿ is an elevated expression of taqwa that leads a person to shun anything tainted by impurity or sin—even matters of doubt. Taqwa has three degrees: avoiding what is contrary to God’s commands, avoiding doubtful matters, and avoiding what is forbidden.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Taqwa is a power that protects and safeguards the soul from sin, and a power that enables one to observe the proper etiquette of servanthood before the Creator of all existence.

Waraʿ may be regarded as the highest expression of God-consciousness: it makes a person flee from anything tainted by impurity and sin.

الورع الوقوف عند الشبهه.(غرر) Waraʿ means holding back when faced with something doubtful.

Taqwa in the words of al-Sadiq, from the family of Muhammad

قال الصادق ع التقوى على ثلاثه أوجه تقوى بالله و هو ترک الخلاف فضلا عن الشبهه و هو تقوى خاص الخاص و تقوى من الله تعالى و هو ترک الشبهات فضلا عن الحرام و هو تقوى الخاص و تقوى من خوف النار و العقاب و هو ترک الحرام و هو تقوى العام و مثل التقوى کماء یجری فی نهر و مثل هذه الطبقات الثلاث فی معنى التقوى کأشجار مغروسه على حافه ذلک النهر من کل لون و جنس و کل شجره منها یستمص الماء من ذلک النهر على قدر جوهره و طعمه و لطافته و کثافته ثم منافع الخلق من ذلک الأشجار و الثمار على قدرها و قیمتها قال الله تعالى صنوان و غیر صنوان یسقى‏ بماء واحد و نفضل بعضها على‏ بعض فی الأکل فالتقوى للطاعات کالماء للأشجار و مثل طبائع الأشجار و الأثمار فی لونها و طعمها مثل مقادیر الإیمان فمن کان أعلى درجه فی الإیمان و أصفى جوهره بالروح کان أتقى و من کان أتقى کانت عبادته أخلص و أطهر و من کان کذلک کان من الله أقرب و کل عباده مؤسسه على غیر التقوى فهی هباء منثور قال الله تعالى أ فمن أسس بنیانه على‏ تقوى‏ من الله و رضوان خیر أم من أسس بنیانه على‏ شفا جرف هار فانهار به فی نار جهنم و تفسیر التقوى ترک ما لیس بأخذه بأس حذرا مما به البأس و هو فی الحقیقه طاعه بلا عصیان و ذکر بلا نسیان و علم بلا جهل مقبول غیر مردود
مصباح الشریعه، ص: 39

(Chapter Eighty-Two: On Taqwa) Imam al-Sadiq said that taqwa has three forms:

First, taqwa for God and in His way: giving up permissible things, and even refraining from matters that are doubtful.

Second, taqwa out of fear of God: avoiding doubtful matters, and refraining from what is forbidden.

Third, taqwa out of fear of the Lord’s Fire and punishment: abstaining from what is forbidden.

The first form is the taqwa of the most select, belonging to the most devoted among the believers and servants of God Most High, and to those who are His friends. The second is the taqwa of the select: it belongs to those who are travelling the spiritual path, striving to perfect their faith, and engaged in spiritual discipline and struggle. The third is the taqwa of the generality, encompassing all who follow the path of knowing God and Islam.

In the purity and clarity it brings, taqwa—the state of refraining from disobedience and rebellion—is like clear water flowing in a river. Trees of different shapes, kinds, and colours grow along its banks and draw nourishment from that water. Each tree is nourished according to its capacity and needs, and in keeping with its own qualities of flavour, taste, delicacy, and colour. People, in turn, make use of those trees in various ways, benefiting from their wood, leaves, and fruits according to their nature and particular qualities.

God Most High says: “Some are grown from branches that are paired, and some are not; all are watered with the same water, yet We make some better than others in their fruit.”

Taqwa, in relation to acts of obedience and worship, is like the water that nourishes plants and trees, bringing them freshness and beauty. Faith is like the innate qualities, colours, and flavours of trees and fruits. Without faith, a person’s life has no colour, flavour, sweetness, or taste; with taqwa, it comes to life, flourishing and growing green. The stronger a person’s faith, and the purer and clearer their inner nature and spiritual essence, the better they can draw upon the pure spring of taqwa and attain its highest and fullest degree. When a person is endowed with the finest quality of taqwa, their habits and acts of worship will, of course, be more sincere, pure, vibrant, and worthy. And when someone’s worship is accepted and approved, they are surely among God’s most beloved servants. The servant brought near to God Most High is one who, with complete faith, attains the highest degree of taqwa. Any act of worship or obedience that is not accompanied by taqwa is like a tree that has lost its freshness and vitality through lack of water; such worship will be like scattered dust.

In Sura al-Tawba, verse 109, God Most High says: “Is the one who laid the foundations of his life upon taqwa toward God and His good pleasure better, or the one who laid them on the edge of a crumbling bank, undermined and hollowed out beneath him, so that it collapses and casts him into the Fire of Hell?”

As for the true meaning of taqwa: it is to give up something that would not be harmful to take or do, out of caution about what might bring harm or difficulty. That is, it means refraining from anything doubtful or uncertain, in which there is a possibility of error or disobedience. In its true meaning, taqwa is pure obedience untouched by sin; constant remembrance of God, without forgetfulness or heedlessness; and knowledge, attentiveness, and certainty free of ignorance. It is action that is accepted and never rejected.

*Misbah al-Shariʿa*, translated by Mostafavi, text, p. 366.

Scrupulous piety in the words of al-Sadiq of the Household of Muhammad (AS)

قال الصادق ع أغلق أبواب جوارحک عما یقع ضرره إلى قلبک و یذهب بوجاهتک عند الله تعالى و یعقب الحسره و الندامه یوم القیامه و الحیاء عما اجترحت من السیئات و المتورع یحتاج إلى ثلاثه أصول الصفح عن عثرات الخلق أجمع و ترک خطیئته فیهم و استواء المدح و الذم و أصل الورع دوام محاسبه النفس و صدق المقاوله و صفاء المعامله و الخروج من کل شبهه و رفض کل عیبه و ریبه- و مفارقه جمیع ما لا یعنیه و ترک فتح أبواب لا یدری کیف یغلقها و لا یجالس من یشکل علیه الواضح و لا یصاحب مستخف الدین و لا یعارض من العلم ما لا یحتمل قلبه و لا یتفهمه من قائله و یقطعه عمن یقطعه عن الله عز و جل تعالى شأنه‏
*Misbah al-Shari'a*, p. 40

His Eminence al-Sadiq (AS) said: “Shut the gates of your limbs against anything that harms your heart, diminishes your standing with God Most High, and brings regret and remorse on the Day of Resurrection. Be ashamed of the sins you have committed. A person of scrupulous piety needs three principles: overlooking the failings of all people, refraining from wrongdoing toward them, and being unmoved by either praise or blame.”

و أصل الورع دوام محاسبه النفس (المحاسبه)، و صدق المقاوله، و صفاء- المعامله، و الخروج من کل شبهه، و رفض کل عیبه و ریبه، و مفارقه جمیع مالا یعنیه (لا یعینه)، و ترک فتح ابواب لا یدرى کیف یغلقها، و لا یجالس من یشکل علیه- الواضح، و لا یصاحب مستخف الدین، و لا یعارض من العلم مالا یحتمل قلبه، و لا یتفهمه من قائله (من قابله)، و یقطع عمن بقطعه (یقطع) عن الله عز و جل.

Translation

Scrupulous piety rests on the following foundations:

1. Keep a constant account of all your words and deeds, so that you do not bring harm upon yourself.
2. Let all your speech be truthful, sincere and upright.
3. Let all your dealings with God and with people be guided by pure and sincere intentions.
4. Keep away from matters that are doubtful and actions whose nature is unclear.
5. Avoid and shun anything that invites suspicion or is tainted by impurity.
6. Give up whatever is contrary to your purpose or of no benefit.
7. Do not enter into situations from which the way out or means of escape is unclear.
8. Do not associate with people who cast doubt on what is clear and evident.
9. Do not keep company with those who show no respect, concern or reverence for religion.
10. Do not contend with branches of knowledge and learning that your heart cannot bear.
11. Break off relations with those who have no connection or attachment to God Most High.

*Misbah al-Shari'a*, translated by Mostafavi, text, p. 141

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022