An Analysis of the Ten Promised Paradise
What Is the Hadith of the Ten Promised Paradise? An Analysis
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The hadith of the Ten Promised Paradise is considered fabricated and unauthentic in Sunni sources; it is not found even in the two Ṣaḥīḥ collections. The hadith is not, in itself, open to interpretation, but stories about it have been related among Shiites in connection with tawriya (indirect speech) and taqiyya (religious dissimulation). In one such story, a Shiite man avoids speaking ill of the Companions through tawriya and taqiyya, and Imam Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq (AS) approves of his approach.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe report about the Ten Promised Paradise comes from a fabricated hadith. It is not counted among the authentic hadiths in Sunni books—not even in their two Ṣaḥīḥ collections.
This fabrication could not be explained away through interpretation; nevertheless, among the Shi‘a, certain situations have sometimes arisen in which equivocation and dissimulation were called for. One example follows.
**A delightful story of equivocation and dissimulation concerning the Ten Promised Paradise**
**Also**
**The delightful story of the equivocation and dissimulation of Hizqil**
Imam Hasan al-Askari علیه السلام said:
One of the opponents and enemies, in the presence of Imam Ja‘far al-Sadiq علیه السلام, asked one of the Shi‘a: “What is your opinion of the Ten Promised Paradise? They believe that the Messenger of Islam gave ten of his Companions the glad tidings of Paradise, and that their being destined for Paradise is certain. Among them are Ali علیه السلام, Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Abd al-Rahman, and others. What do you believe about them?”
The Shi‘i man replied, “I regard them with goodness, virtue, and greatness. This very belief and what I say about them will bring forgiveness for my sins and raise my rank.”
The man said, “Praise be to God, for what you have said has freed me from my resentment and hatred. I thought you were a Rafidi who hated the Companions.”
The Shi‘i man said, “Know that whoever hates even one of the Companions—upon him be the curse of God.”
The man, surprised and doubtful, said, “Perhaps there is some interpretation or equivocation in what you say. Tell me, then: what is your opinion of anyone who hates those ten?”
He replied, “Whoever bears hatred and enmity toward those ten—upon him be the curse of God, the angels, and all people.”
The man at once sprang up, kissed the Shi‘i on the head, and apologized. “Forgive me,” he said, “for until yesterday I called you a Rafidi.”
“I forgive you,” the Shi‘i replied. “You are my brother.”
The man then left, overjoyed.
After he had gone, Imam al-Sadiq علیه السلام said to the Shi‘i, “You handled that very well. This was a favor from God toward you. The angels in heaven were amazed and delighted by your excellent equivocation and the way you spoke, which saved you without your suffering the slightest harm to your faith. May God increase the grief and sorrow of those who oppose us, and deprive them of understanding the intentions and aims of our friends.”
Some of the Imam’s companions, who were present, said, “O son of the Messenger of God, we could make nothing of his words except that he agreed with that fanatical, hostile man and shared his views. How, then, can you praise him?”
The Imam replied, “If you did not understand, we understood what he meant, and God has rewarded this man. When a friend of our household—one who loves our friends and is an enemy to our enemies—is put to the test and confronted with the probing questions of our opponents, God enables him to answer in such a way that his faith, his honor, and his good name all remain safe. For this act of dissimulation and equivocation, God grants him a great reward.
“As for what your friend meant, when he said, ‘Whoever hates even one of them—upon him be the curse of God,’ he meant Ali علیه السلام, who is one of them. So what he said was true, whatever the listener might understand by it.
“Then, when he said, ‘Whoever hates those ten—upon him be the curse of God,’ that too was true. For if someone hates all ten and speaks ill of them all, he must also hate Ali علیه السلام. But if he is not hostile toward Ali and does not speak ill of him, then he does not hate those ten as a group—all ten together simply because they are ten. He may hate some among them, but not all of them. Hizqil, the believer from the family of Pharaoh, chose the same kind of equivocation and means of escape when dealing with Pharaoh’s informers.
“The story was this: Hizqil was calling people to the oneness of God, to the prophethood of Moses, and to the superiority of the Prophet of Islam over all the prophets and all God’s creatures. He also called them to acknowledge the superiority of Ali ibn Abi Talib and the Imams of the Household علیه السلام over the successors of the prophets, and urged them to renounce Pharaoh’s claim to divinity.
“Pharaoh’s informers reported to him that Hizqil had risen in opposition to him, was calling people to these beliefs, and was helping his enemies oppose him. Pharaoh said, ‘How astonishing! My cousin, my deputy and heir apparent, would do such a thing? If your report is true, Hizqil deserves punishment, torture, and torment, for he has repaid my kindness and favors with ingratitude. But if you have reported falsely, the severest punishment awaits you, because you have brought this noble man into danger.’
“He immediately summoned Hizqil and the informers and began the proceedings. The informers said to Hizqil, ‘You deny Pharaoh’s divinity and disregard his kindness and favors.’
“Hizqil said, ‘O great king, I ask you: have you ever known me to lie?’
“Pharaoh said, ‘Never.’
“Hizqil said, ‘Ask these people who their god is.’
“Pharaoh asked them, ‘Tell me, who is your god and creator?’
“‘Pharaoh,’ they replied.
“‘And who provides for you, sustains your lives, and relieves your distress?’
“They replied, ‘Pharaoh.’
“Hizqil said, ‘O king, O sovereign…’” I call you and all these people present to bear witness that their God is my God, their Creator is my Creator, their Sustainer is my Sustainer, and the one who guarantees and puts right their lives and livelihoods is the one who guarantees and puts right mine. I have no god, Creator, or Sustainer other than the God, Creator, and Sustainer of these people. I also call you and all of them to witness that I disavow every god, creator, and sustainer other than theirs, and reject the divinity of any such being.
This is what Khirqil said. He meant that their God, Allah, was his God. He did not mean that he worshipped the same thing they did. But they—that is, Pharaoh and those present—did not understand what he meant. They imagined he was saying that Pharaoh was his God, Creator, and Sustainer.
Suddenly, in a fit of rage, Pharaoh said to the informers, “You wicked, vile people! You troublemakers, conspirators, and agitators, who are trying to set me against my cousin, even though he is my strong right arm! For the corruption and division you have sown, seeking to destroy my cousin and break my right arm, you deserve a painful punishment.”
He then ordered the stakes to be prepared. They drove them through the people’s chests and feet, and he commanded that their flesh be torn from their bodies with iron combs. This is the meaning of the blessed verse: “فوقاه الله سيئات ما مكروا”—“God protected the believer from Pharaoh’s family from the evil of their schemes”—and “و حاق بآل فرعون سوء العذاب”: a terrible punishment—the stakes and the tearing of their flesh—befell the informers.
*Bihār al-Anwār*—translation of volumes 67 and 68, translated by Mūsavī Hamadānī, vol. 2, p. 17.
**Problems with the Chain of Transmission of the Hadith of the Ten Promised Paradise, According to Sunni Scholars Themselves**
The hadith of the Ten Promised Paradise has a number of problems with its chain of transmission, including the following:
The hadith does not appear in the two most important Sunni hadith collections, Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī and Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim, in the sections devoted to the status and merits of the ten people it names. Yet both collections include hadiths on this subject that are far less significant than the one in question. This raises the possibility that the compilers of these two collections did not consider the chain of the hadith of the Ten Promised Paradise reliable.
In Sunan al-Tirmidhi and the Musnad of Aḥmad ibn Ḥanbal, the hadith is transmitted from Ḥumayd ibn ʿAbd al-Raḥmān, who, according to these two books, claims to have heard it from his father, ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn ʿAwf. However, according to reliable historical sources, Ḥumayd was less than a year old when his father died.
The hadith has been transmitted through several routes whose chains include narrators who, even by the standards of Sunni scholars themselves, are not considered reliable. One example is ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz ibn Muḥammad al-Darāwardī, whose narrations Abū Ḥātim does not consider trustworthy.
Another example is the version in Sunan Abī Dāwūd, in which the hadith is transmitted from Saʿīd ibn Zayd.
A man named ʿAbd Allāh ibn Ẓālim appears in the chain. Al-Bukhārī and Muslim did not consider him reliable, and al-Bukhārī explicitly stated that his hadith is not sound.
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn ʿAwf and Saʿīd ibn Zayd, who transmitted this hadith, are themselves among those promised Paradise in it. Yet none of the other people named in the hadith transmitted it. Nor was it transmitted by anyone outside this group who might have witnessed the event.
**A report attributed to Imam Ali (AS) concerning the Ten Promised Paradise**
فقال ع نشدتکما بالله أ تعلمان و أولو العلم من آل محمد و عائشه بنت أبی بکر أن أصحاب الجمل و أهل النهروان ملعونون على لسان محمدص و قد خاب من افترى فقال الزبیر کیف نکون «9» ملعونین و نحن من أهل الجنه فقال علی ع لو علمت أنکم من أهل الجنه لما استحللت قتالکم فقال الزبیر أ ما سمعت رسول الله یقول یوم أحد أوجب طلحه الجنه و من أراد أن ینظر إلى شهید یمشی «11» على الأرض حیا فلینظر إلى طلحه أ و ما سمعت رسول الله یقول عشره من قریش فی الجنه فقال علی ع فسمهم قال فلان و فلان و فلان حتى عد تسعه فیهم أبو عبیده بن الجراح و سعید بن زید بن عمرو بن نفیل «13» فقال علی ع عددت تسعه فمن العاشر قال الزبیر أنت فقال علی ع أما أنت فقد أقررت أنی من أهل الجنه و أما ما ادعیت لنفسک و أصحابک فإنی به لمن الجاحدین و الله إن بعض من سمیت لفی تابوت فی جب فی أسفل درک من جهنم على ذلک الجب صخره إذا أراد الله أن یسعر جهنم رفع تلک الصخره فأسعرت جهنم سمعت ذلک من رسول الله ص و إلا فأظفرک الله بی و سفک دمی بیدک «14» و إلا فأظفرنی الله بک و بأصحابک فرجع الزبیر إلى أصحابه و هو یبکی ...
…During the Battle of the Camel, ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib summoned Ṭalḥa and al-Zubayr and said: “Do you know that the people of the Camel are accursed?” Al-Zubayr replied, “How can we be accursed when we are people of Paradise?” Imam ʿAlī said, “If I knew that you were people of Paradise, I would not have fought you or considered fighting you lawful.” Al-Zubayr said, “Have you not heard the hadith of Saʿīd ibn ʿAmr ibn Nufayl, who heard from the Prophet that ten people from Quraysh are people of Paradise?” Imam ʿAlī replied, “I have heard that Saʿīd narrated this hadith during ʿUthmān’s caliphate, for his benefit.” Al-Zubayr asked, “Did he lie?” ʿAlī said, “I will say nothing until you name them.” Al-Zubayr named nine. ʿAlī asked, “Who is the tenth?” Al-Zubayr replied, “You yourself.” ʿAlī said, “Then you have acknowledged that I am one of the people of Paradise, but I deny what you have claimed for yourself and your companions.” Al-Zubayr asked, “Do you think Saʿīd lied?” ʿAlī replied, “I do not merely think so; I am certain the hadith is false. Some of those you named are in a coffin in the lowest depths of Hell, with a stone over the pit. When God wishes to torment the people of Hell, He will lift that stone. I heard this from the Prophet.” Al-Zubayr left Imam ʿAlī (AS) in tears.