A friend has asked about the rulings on the following:
(a) Seeking the intercession of angels as a means of drawing closer to God; (b) asking angels for help.
What is the ruling, particularly in the second case, given that they are not God’s vicegerents? (In his writings on the occult sciences, Hasan Zadeh Amoli describes various ways of seeking aid from angels in considerable detail, along with elaborate prescribed rites.)
What Is the Ruling on Seeking the Intercession of Angels and Asking Them for Help?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Seeking the intercession of angels as a means of drawing closer to God is valid when it is grounded in an awareness of their rank and esteem in God’s sight, and that esteem is treated as a means of drawing closer to Him. Asking angels for help is also permissible if it is simply a request for help and does not imply that they act independently. But if asking them for help is treated as an act of worship, or if they are regarded as having a status above that of servants of God, it amounts to shirk (associating partners with God).
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIf we understand the rights and exalted station of the great angels, and the esteem in which they are held by God, then there is nothing objectionable in making those rights and honours a means of seeking access to God in our prayers.
و أسألک بالاسم الذی دعاک به محمد صلى الله علیه و آله یوم الغار و أسألک بحق الکرام الکاتبین و بحق جبرئیل و میکائیل و إسرافیل أن تستجیب دعائی فیما سألتک به من أول الشهر إلى هذا الیوم و ...
اللهم إنی أسألک بحق وجهک الکریم علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق عزتک علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق عظمه جلالک علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق ملائکتک المقربین و أنبیائک المرسلین علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق جبرئیل علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق میکائیل علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق إسرافیل علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق عزرائیل علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق حمله عرشک و الکروبیین علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق آدم و محمد و من بینهما من الأنبیاء و المرسلین علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق محمد المصطفى خاتم النبیین علیک یا رب و أسألک بحق علی بن أبی طالب أمیر المؤمنین و ...
Means are ways of drawing near to God. But if they are misused and become a cause of forgetting God, then seeking intercession through them becomes an act of unbelief and idolatry.
The appeal for help mentioned here, if it is an ordinary act—such as people asking one another for help, or consulting a doctor, mechanic or shopkeeper to meet a need, without attributing supernatural powers or independence to them—is unobjectionable. But if seeking help is considered an act of worship, or something akin to worship, or if it elevates the angels from the station of servitude to a higher rank, then such an appeal is undoubtedly idolatrous.
In the first place, the reason for seeking help from the angels must be made clear. Why have we turned to an intermediary instead of seeking God’s help directly? This kind of appeal through an intermediary must be clarified.
The angels will curse those who seek intercession in an idolatrous way. If someone attains outward status through idolatrous appeals that stray from the path of the Qur’an and the Prophet’s family, then the devils have undoubtedly disguised themselves as angels and contented that idolater with licking the bones of this world.
سبأ : 40 و یوم یحشرهم جمیعا ثم یقول للملائکه أ هؤلاء إیاکم کانوا یعبدون
(Remember) the day when God gathers them all together, then says to the angels, “Was it you that these people worshipped?!”
سبأ : 41 قالوا سبحانک أنت ولینا من دونهم بل کانوا یعبدون الجن أکثرهم بهم مؤمنون
They will say, “Glory be to You! You alone are our protector, not they. (They did not worship us.) Rather, they worshipped the jinn, and most of them believed in them!”
الزخرف : 19 و جعلوا الملائکه الذین هم عباد الرحمن إناثا أ شهدوا خلقهم ستکتب شهادتهم و یسئلون
They made the angels, who are servants of the All-Merciful, female. Were they witnesses to their creation?! Their testimony will be recorded, and they will be questioned about it!
الزخرف : 20 و قالوا لو شاء الرحمن ما عبدناهم ما لهم بذلک من علم إن هم إلا یخرصون
They said, “Had the All-Merciful so willed, we would not have worshipped them!” But they have no knowledge or certainty about this; they do nothing but lie!