Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 1710 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

What is the scholar’s view on opposition to Islamic medicine?

Primary reference: See the answer text 38 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-1710

Question 2612:
سلام علیکم و رحمه الله
Please share your thoughts on the following text.

At the beginning of this two-day workshop, Hujjat al-Islam Dr. Sayyed Kazem Sayyed Tabatabaei expressed his opposition to the term “Islamic medicine,” saying: “I oppose the term Islamic medicine. In other words, I do not accept that the aim of religion and the Sharia is to establish a system known as a medical system. I fundamentally have a problem with the term Islamic medicine, even though it has become very widespread in recent years. It also has no historical precedent.

He went on to explain the separation of medicine from religion and the Sharia, saying: “For example, in the reports we find someone named Abu Umar al-Mutatabbib, who was a physician and one of the companions of Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq عليه السلام. It is reported that he came to Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq عليه السلام and asked him about medicine and medical practice, saying, ‘I am a physician. I practise medicine, prescribe remedies and use the lancet, and my medicine is Arab medicine.’ What is interesting is that the Imam عليه السلام never reproached him for practising Arab medicine. في المثل, he did not say, ‘What is this Arab medicine? Why don’t you come and learn Islamic medicine from us?’ and so on. Why did the Imam not take a position against Arab medicine? Because these two fields—religion and the medical system—are entirely separate. Therefore, the term Islamic medicine is incorrect, and I do not see in the body of Shi‘i narrations the characteristics associated with a medical system…”

🌸🔆🌷بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم🌷🔆🌸
#Response2612
🍀🔅🌷علیکم السلام🌷🔅🍀

I invite you to read the previous responses: #Response2361 #Response2357 #Response1985 #Response1710 #Response2387 #Response2386_FirstPage

Ali Saei (Mishkat-e Tawhid, [23.10.17 14:59]
[In reply to Maryam Jannat]
☘️🔅🌱 # Question2386
سلام علیکم
People who deny Islamic medicine have made the following claim:
Which of the Imams used the term “Islamic medicine”?
🌸🔆🌷بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم🌷🔆🌸
# Response2386_FirstPage
🍀🔅🌷علیکم السلام🌷🔅🍀
🌷🔅🌱God was the first of all to speak of remedies and healing!
🌷🔅🌱Some people may think of medicine only in terms of chemical or herbal elements and compounds, but the scope of Islamic medicine is far broader and knows no bounds.
🌻🔅🌱الشعراء : 80 وَ إِذا مَرِضْتُ فَهُوَ يَشْفينِ
🌹And when I fall ill, He heals me.

🌻🔅🌱النحل : 69 ثُمَّ كُلي‏ مِنْ كُلِّ الثَّمَراتِ فَاسْلُكي‏ سُبُلَ رَبِّكِ ذُلُلاً يَخْرُجُ مِنْ بُطُونِها شَرابٌ مُخْتَلِفٌ أَلْوانُهُ فيهِ شِفاءٌ لِلنَّاسِ إِنَّ في‏ ذلِكَ لَآيَةً لِقَوْمٍ يَتَفَكَّرُون‏
🌹Then eat of all the fruits, and follow humbly and obediently the paths of your Lord, as He has inspired you, in transforming the raw materials into honey. As you travel between your dwelling and the place where the fruits grow, follow the paths God has inspired you to take, harming no one. From within them comes a drink of many different colours, in which there is healing for people. Surely in this—this art of preparing drinks and remedies, and the life-giving process behind it—there is a sign for those who reflect.

🌻🔅🌱الإسراء : 82 وَ نُنَزِّلُ مِنَ الْقُرْآنِ ما هُوَ شِفاءٌ وَ رَحْمَةٌ لِلْمُؤْمِنينَ وَ لا يَزيدُ الظَّالِمينَ إِلاَّ خَساراً
🌸We send down from the Qur’an that which is healing and mercy for the believers (healing from spiritual and social ills), but it only increases the wrongdoers in loss (spiritual and social).

🌻🔅🌱الشعراء : 80 وَ إِذا مَرِضْتُ فَهُوَ يَشْفينِ
🌸And when I fall ill, He heals me.
َ🌸🔅🌱قالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ ص: يَا عِبَادَ اللَّهِ- أَنْتُمْ كَالْمَرِيضِ «2» وَ اللَّهُ رَبُّ الْعَالَمِينَ كَالطَّبِيبِ فَصَلَاحُ الْمَرِيضِ فِيمَا يَعْلَمُهُ الطَّبِيبُ وَ يُدَبِّرُهُ بِهِ، لَا فِيمَا يَشْتَهِيهِ الْمَرِيضُ وَ يَقْتَرِحُهُ أَلَا فَسَلِّمُوا لِلَّهِ أَمْرَهُ تَكُونُوا «3» مِنَ الْفَائِزِينَ.
التفسير المنسوب إلى الإمام الحسن العسكري عليه السلام، ص: 495
🌸🔅🌱 فأَنْتُمُ الْمَرْضَى وَ اللَّهُ طَبِيبُكُمْ، فَإِنِ انْقَدْتُمْ لِدَوَائِهِ شَفَاكُمْ، وَ إِنْ تَمَرَّدْتُمْ عَلَيْهِ أَسْقَمَكُمْ،
التفسير المنسوب إلى الإمام الحسن العسكري عليه السلام، ص: 511
🌸🔅🌱 قالَ الْعِلْمُ عِلْمَانِ عِلْمُ الْأَدْيَانِ وَ عِلْمُ الْأَبْدَانِ‏
كنز الفوائد، ج‏2، ص: 108
🌸🔅🌱 قالَ الْأَصْبَغُ بْنُ نُبَاتَةَ سَمِعْتُ أَمِيرَ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ ع يَقُولُ لِابْنِهِ الْحَسَنِ ع يَا بُنَيَّ أَ لَا أُعَلِّمُكَ أَرْبَعَ كَلِمَاتٍ تَسْتَغْنِي بِهَا عَنِ الطِّبِّ فَقَالَ بَلَى يَا أَبَتِ قَالَ ع لَا تَجْلِسْ عَلَى الطَّعَامِ إِلَّا وَ أَنْتَ جَائِعٌ وَ لَا تَقُمْ عَنِ الطَّعَامِ إِلَّا وَ أَنْتَ تَشْتَهِيهِ وَ جَوِّدِ الْمَضْغَ وَ إِذَا نِمْتَ فَاعْرِضْ نَفْسَكَ عَلَى الْخَلَاءِ وَ إِذَا اسْتَعْمَلْتَ هَذَا اسْتَغْنَيْتَ عَنِ الطِّبِ‏
🌸🔅🌱فقَالَ ع أَمَا إِنَّ فِي الْقُرْآنِ لَآيَةً تَجْمَعُ الطِّبَّ كُلَّهُ- كُلُوا وَ اشْرَبُوا وَ لا تُسْرِفُوا
🌸🔅🌱ا أَمَّا اللَّيْلَ فَصَافُّونَ أَقْدَامَهُمْ تَالِينَ لِأَجْزَاءِ الْقُرْآنِ يُرَتِّلُونَهَا تَرْتِيلًا يُحَزِّنُونَ بِهِ أَنْفُسَهُمْ وَ يَسْتَثِيرُونَ بِهِ دَوَاءَ دَائِهِم‏
نهج البلاغه

Ali Saei (Mishkat-e Tawhid, [23.10.17 15:38]
[In reply to Maryam Jannat]
☘️🔅🌱 # Question 2387
سلام علیکم
People who deny Islamic medicine have raised the following question:
Why, when Lady Fatima (SA) fell ill at a young age, did Imam Ali (peace be upon him) not treat her? If he knew how and failed to do so, surely that would have been a sin. Why did he call a Jewish physician when he himself fell ill?
🌸🔆🌷بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم🌷🔆🌸
# Answer 2387
🍀🔅🌷وعليكم السلام🌷🔅🍀
🌷🔅🌱No physician can defer the time appointed by God. Lady Fatima, peace be upon her, willingly accepted God’s decree and answered the call of her beloved and loving Lord. Certainly, had the time to answer the call of the Truth not yet come, she herself or her master would have treated her.
|🌷🔅🌱Every illness has a cure except the illness of death; that is, the end of one’s life brings this worldly life to a close.
🌷🔅🌱Death is the only pain for which there is no cure.
🌸🔅🌱 أنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ ص قَالَ: تَدَاوَوْا فَمَا أَنْزَلَ اللَّهُ دَاءً إِلَّا أَنْزَلَ مَعَهُ دَوَاءً إِلَّا السَّامَ يَعْنِي الْمَوْتَ فَإِنَّهُ لَا دَوَاءَ لَهُ.
دعائم الإسلام، ج‏2، ص: 143
🌹The Messenger of God, may God’s blessings and peace be upon him and his family, said: “Seek treatment, for God has sent down a remedy for every ailment He has sent down, except سأم—that is, death.”
🌻🔅🌱العنكبوت : 5 مَنْ كانَ يَرْجُوا لِقاءَ اللَّهِ فَإِنَّ أَجَلَ اللَّهِ لَآتٍ وَ هُوَ السَّميعُ الْعَليمُ
🌹Whoever hopes to meet God (and be resurrected) should strive to obey His command! For the appointed time set by God will surely come, and He is All-Hearing, All-Knowing!
ا🌻🔅🌱الزمر : 42 اللَّهُ يَتَوَفَّى الْأَنْفُسَ حينَ مَوْتِها وَ الَّتي‏ لَمْ تَمُتْ في‏ مَنامِها فَيُمْسِكُ الَّتي‏ قَضى‏ عَلَيْهَا الْمَوْتَ وَ يُرْسِلُ الْأُخْرى‏ إِلى‏ أَجَلٍ مُسَمًّى إِنَّ في‏ ذلِكَ لَآياتٍ لِقَوْمٍ يَتَفَكَّرُونَ
🌹God takes the souls at the time of death, and those who have not died as well, during their sleep. He keeps the souls of those whose death He has decreed, and returns the others (who are to remain alive) until an appointed time. Surely, in this there are clear signs for those who reflect.
Ali Saei (Mishkat-e Tawhid, [13.01.17 00:39]
[In reply to Seeroos]
🍀🌷🌱سلام # Question 1710 The Prophet (SA) said that knowledge is of two kinds: knowledge of religions and knowledge of bodies. Please explain what is meant by knowledge of bodies.
🌸🔆❄️بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم❄️🔆🌸
# Answer 1710
🍀🔅🌟سلام علیکم🌟🔅🍀
🌻🍀🌱🌱🍀🌻
🔆🔅🌱
🌸🔅🌱و الْعِلْمُ عِلْمَانِ عِلْمُ الْأَبْدَانِ وَ عِلْمُ الْأَدْيَان‏
معدن الجواهر و رياضة الخواطر، ص: 25
🌷
🔆🔅🌱It may refer to medicine, the study of human beings, self-knowledge, and so on.

🌷🔅🌱سلام # Question 1985 Please explain the difference between Islamic medicine and traditional medicine. Also, is Dr. Kheirandish’s definition correct?
🌸🔆🌷بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم🌷🔆🌸
# Answer 1985
🍀🔅🌷وعليكم السلام🌷🔅🍀
🌻🍀🌱🌱🍀🌻
🌷🔅🌱Comparing any form of medicine with Islamic medicine is a manifest injustice to the latter. Islamic medicine is the source and foundation of medical practice; any form of medicine that bears fruit shows signs of having benefited from Islamic medicine. Islamic medicine is medicine at its deepest and most fundamental, treating the human being in their entirety.
🌷🔅🌱Islamic medicine is the sky of medical practice, while other forms of medicine are lands beneath that vast sky. Those worthy of it receive its healing rain and flourish.
🌷🔅🌱Dr. Kheirandish merely offers glimpses of the grandeur of Islamic medicine!

Ali Saei (Mishkat-e Tawhid, [16.10.17 00:28]
[In reply to Maryam Jannat]
☘️🔅🌱# Question 2357
سلام علیکم
Recently, a well-known preacher stated that there is no such thing as Islamic medicine, and that Imam al-Rida’s (AS) Risala al-Dhahabiyya, a lengthy medical text, has no reliable chain of transmission❗️
Please advise us on this matter.🌱
🌸🔆🌷بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم🌷🔆🌸
# Answer 2357
🍀🔅🌷علیکم السلام🌷🔅🍀
🌷🔅🌱The university’s books Dard va Darman, Tibb-e Munajat, Mishkat al-Shifa, and Misbah al-Shifa are just a few small examples of Islamic medicine. Each of the therapeutic approaches offered by Islamic medicine is, in itself, a complete system of medicine.
🌷🔅🌱Despite being framed as a set of specific recommendations, the Risala al-Dhahabiyya, with all its richness, offers a complete course in maintaining health and treating illness. A hadith’s chain of transmission is not the sole criterion for establishing its authenticity; multiple indications can be used to authenticate or weaken a hadith.
🌷🔅🌱Islamic medicine, its prescriptions and recommendations, is a multilayered, parallel system of medicine that treats every hidden and visible layer and aspect of the human being. It also helps the human being grow and develop. Most importantly, Islamic medicine is a distinctive path of worship and servitude to God.
🌷🔅🌱Islamic medicine is the only medicine with no side effects; rather, it enhances health and well-being!
🌷🔅🌱Islamic medicine is so powerful that it can turn anything into a remedy and a cure.
🌷🔅🌱Only devils are worried about the spread of Islamic medicine, because in addition to treating illness, it deepens faith and piety.
🌷🔅🌱Those who wage war on Islamic medicine have a mouse-based medicine: helpless laboratory mice are their experts in treatment. However much their medicine cures one ailment, it produces even more ailments in its place. Many emerging diseases are the fruits of modern medicine. This medicine not only fails to eradicate the roots of disease, but also creates a heightened sensitivity to illness. Diseases that had been eradicated are now reappearing with greater severity and force.
🌷🔅🌱This alone is enough to attest to the standing of Islamic medicine: a pure heart can itself prepare medicine, and do so with just one beautiful invocation, while an ocean of invocations is a gift from God, the Healer.
🌸🔅🌱 يا مَنِ اسْمُهُ دَوَاءٌ وَ ذِكْرُهُ شِفَاءٌ وَ طَاعَتُهُ غَنَاء
🌷🔅🌱They do not understand that God is the Healer!
🌻🔅🌱الشعراء : 80 وَ إِذا مَرِضْتُ فَهُوَ يَشْفينِ
🌹And when I fall ill, He heals me.
🌸🔅🌱
🌷🔅🌱Islamic medicine will be defined in the course of the questions that follow.
Ali Saei (Mishkat-e Tawhid, [17.10.17 22:47]
[In reply to Maryam Jannat]
☘️🔅🌱# Question 2361
سلام علیکم
Those who do not consider the Golden Treatise to have been written by Imam Reza have argued that its narrator is Muhammad ibn Ja‘far, who is not regarded as reliable by scholars of rijal.
Is this claim correct?
🌸🔆🌷بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم🌷🔆🌸
# Answer 2361
🍀🔅🌷علیکم السلام🌷🔅🍀
🌷🔅🌱The hadith’s chain of transmission is not the sole and final criterion for declaring it authentic or weak. If a building has flaws in its outward appearance, one does not demolish the entire structure. Rather, after the necessary investigation and expert assessment of its foundations and structure, one determines whether it is fit to live in. By the same token, a building’s sound and beautiful appearance does not prove that it is fit to live in.

Hadith experts assess a report’s authenticity or weakness on the basis of particular indicators. Certainly, not everyone has the expertise to do this—just as in medicine, one doctor may give up on a patient, while another, through an accurate diagnosis and an exceptional course of treatment, undertakes to care for them.

🌷🔅🌱The late Allameh Askari, a renowned architect of the field of hadith studies, holds a favorable view of attributing the Golden Treatise to Imam Reza علیه السلام:

☘️“In Ayatollah Askari’s library in Samarra, there was a manuscript copy of this treatise, transmitted by Abu Muhammad Hasan ibn Muhammad Nawfali. This was Hasan ibn Fadl ibn Ya‘qub ibn Sa‘id ibn Nawfal ibn Harith ibn Abd al-Muttalib, about whom Najashi says: ‘He was a learned man, held in high esteem, and considered trustworthy. He transmitted a copy of the treatise from Imam Reza علیه‌السلام, and also transmitted from Abu Abdillah and from Abu al-Hasan (Musa), الخ.’” (Tibb al-Rida علیه‌السلام, p. 94, by Allameh Askari)

🌷🔅🌱Of course, we must not forget the truth that it is not correct to claim that this treatise reflects one hundred per cent of the noble statements of Imam رضا, peace be upon him. It may have suffered damage over the course of history and in the process of transmission; this is possible with any hadith.

🌷🔅🌱It seems that some inauthentic material has made its way into the text of this treatise. It therefore requires rigorous scholarly judgement to prevent incorrect and improper statements from being attributed to the sacred person of Imam رضا, peace be upon him.

🌷🔅🌱Even if the Golden Treatise did not come from His Eminence, that is no reason to doubt Islamic medicine.

🌷🔅🌱Just as we must take care when attributing this treatise to His Eminence, we must also present strong evidence before doubting the authenticity of that attribution.

🌷🔅🌱This treatise is like a pool into which jewels from His Eminence have fallen. We must be jewel-seekers, gathering its treasures and discarding its refuse.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Islamic medicine encompasses a broad field and should not be compared with modern medicine, since it is the foundation and root of medical practice. Healing comes from God, and the Quran and Sunnah stress the importance of treatment. The Imams did not use the term “Islamic medicine,” but God Himself speaks of remedies and treatment.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

#Answer2387 #Answer2386_First_Page

Ali Saei (Mishkat-e Tawhid, [23.10.17 14:59]
[In reply to Maryam Jannat]

In statements made by people who deny Islamic medicine, it has been said:
Which of the Imams used the term “Islamic medicine”?

#Answer2386_First_Page

God was the first of all to speak of medicine and healing!
Some may expect medicine to concern chemical or herbal elements and compounds, but the scope of Islamic medicine is far broader and knows no boundaries.
الشعراء : 80 و إذا مرضت فهو یشفین
And when I fall ill, He heals me.

النحل : 69 ثم کلی‏ من کل الثمرات فاسلکی‏ سبل ربک ذللا یخرج من بطونها شراب مختلف ألوانه فیه شفاء للناس إن فی‏ ذلک لآیه لقوم یتفکرون‏
Then eat of every kind of fruit, and follow the paths of your Lord, made easy for you (in transforming raw materials into honey). Travel back and forth between your home and the place where the fruit grows, following the paths God has inspired you to take, without harming anyone. From their bellies comes a drink of varying colours, in which there is healing for people. Truly, in this (art of preparing drinks and medicines, and in the way of life that gives rise to it) is a sign for people who reflect.

الإسراء : 82 و ننزل من القرآن ما هو شفاء و رحمه للمؤمنین و لا یزید الظالمین إلا خسارا
And We send down from the Quran that which is a healing and a mercy for the believers (healing spiritual and social ailments); but it increases the wrongdoers in nothing but loss (spiritual and social).
الشعراء : 80 و إذا مرضت فهو یشفین
And when I fall ill, He heals me.
قال رسول الله ص: یا عباد الله- أنتم کالمریض «2» و الله رب العالمین کالطبیب فصلاح المریض فیما یعلمه الطبیب و یدبره به، لا فیما یشتهیه المریض و یقترحه ألا فسلموا لله أمره تکونوا «3» من الفائزین.
التفسیر المنسوب إلى الإمام الحسن العسکری علیه السلام، ص: 495
فأنتم المرضى و الله طبیبکم، فإن انقدتم لدوائه شفاکم، و إن تمردتم علیه أسقمکم،
التفسیر المنسوب إلى الإمام الحسن العسکری علیه السلام، ص: 511
قال العلم علمان علم الأدیان و علم الأبدان‏
کنز الفوائد، ج‏2، ص: 108
قال الأصبغ بن نباته سمعت أمیر المؤمنین ع یقول لابنه الحسن ع یا بنی أ لا أعلمک أربع کلمات تستغنی بها عن الطب فقال بلى یا أبت قال ع لا تجلس على الطعام إلا و أنت جائع و لا تقم عن الطعام إلا و أنت تشتهیه و جود المضغ و إذا نمت فاعرض نفسک على الخلاء و إذا استعملت هذا استغنیت عن الطب‏
فقال ع أما إن فی القرآن لآیه تجمع الطب کله- کلوا و اشربوا و لا تسرفوا
ا أما اللیل فصافون أقدامهم تالین لأجزاء القرآن یرتلونها ترتیلا یحزنون به أنفسهم و یستثیرون به دواء دائهم‏
نهج البلاغه

Ali Saei (Mishkat-e Tawhid, [23.10.17 15:38]
[In reply to Maryam Jannat]

In statements made by people who deny Islamic medicine, it has been said:
Why, when Lady Fatima (SA) fell ill in her youth, did Imam Ali (SA) not treat her? If he knew how to treat her and did not, would that not have been a sin? And why did he summon a Jewish physician when he himself was ill?

#Answer2387

No physician can delay the divinely appointed time of death! Lady Fatima (SA), accepting the decree of God, answered the call of God, the Beloved and the All-Loving. Surely, had the time to answer the call of Truth not yet come, the Lady herself or the Master would have treated her.
| Every illness has a cure, except the illness of death! That is, the end of life is the termination of earthly existence.
Death is the only pain for which there is no remedy.
أن رسول الله ص قال: تداووا فما أنزل الله داء إلا أنزل معه دواء إلا السام یعنی الموت فإنه لا دواء له.
دعائم الإسلام، ج‏2، ص: 143
The Messenger of God (SA) said: “Seek treatment, for God has sent down no illness without also sending down its remedy, except for sāʾam—that is, death—for it has no remedy.”
العنکبوت : 5 من کان یرجوا لقاء الله فإن أجل الله لآت و هو السمیع العلیم
Whoever hopes to meet God (and be resurrected) should strive to obey His command, for the appointed time set by God will surely come. He is the All-Hearing, All-Knowing!
ا لزمر : 42 الله یتوفى الأنفس حین موتها و التی‏ لم تمت فی‏ منامها فیمسک التی‏ قضى‏ علیها الموت و یرسل الأخرى‏ إلى‏ أجل مسمى إن فی‏ ذلک لآیات لقوم یتفکرون
God takes the souls at the time of their death, and those that have not died during their sleep. He keeps those whose death He has decreed and sends the others back until an appointed time. Surely, in this are clear signs for people who reflect.

Ali Saei (Mishkat-e Tawhid, [13.01.17 00:39]
[In reply to Seeroos]
Hello. #Question1710 The Prophet (SA) said that knowledge is of two kinds: knowledge of religions and knowledge of bodies. Could you explain what is meant by knowledge of bodies?

#Answer1710

و العلم علمان علم الأبدان و علم الأدیان‏
معدن الجواهر و ریاضه الخواطر، ص: 25

It could refer to medicine, the study of human beings, knowledge of the self, and so on.

Hello.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022