Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 477 17 July 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

What is your view on the splitting of the moon in two as a miracle of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)?

Primary reference: See the answer text 46 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The splitting of the moon is mentioned in the Quran, in verse 1 of Surah al-Qamar, and in numerous narrations, which indicate that this miracle took place at the request of the Prophet’s opponents as proof of his truthfulness. NASA research has also identified fissures on the moon, which confirms that this great miracle occurred. The Quran was revealed through divine knowledge, and its scientific truths are consistent with modern science.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

(Part One)

The splitting of the moon is established by Quranic text and is among the self-evident truths!

القمر : 1 اقتربت الساعه و انشق القمر

The Hour has drawn near, and the moon has split in two!

يونس قال قال لی أبو عبد الله ع: اجتمعوا أربعه عشر رجلا أصحاب العقبه لیله أربع عشره من ذی الحجه، فقالوا للنبی ص: ما من نبی إلا و له آیه- فما آیتک فی لیلتک هذه فقال النبی ص ما الذی تریدون فقالوا إن یکن لک عند ربک قدر- فأمر القمر أن ینقطع قطعتین، فهبط جبرئیل ع و قال یا محمد إن الله یقرئک السلام و یقول لک: إنی قد أمرت کل شی‏ء بطاعتک، فرفع رأسه فأمر القمر أن ینقطع قطعتین، فانقطع قطعتین فسجد النبی ص شکرا لله- و سجد شیعتنا، ثم رفع النبی ص رأسه و رفعوا رءوسهم، ثم قالوا یعود کما کان فعاد کما کان، ثم قالوا ینشق رأسه فأمره فانشق- فسجد النبی ص شکرا لله و سجد شیعتنا، فقالوا یا محمد حین تقدم سفارنا من الشام و الیمن فنسألهم ما رأوا فی هذه اللیله- فإن یکونوا رأوا مثل ما رأینا علمنا أنه من ربک- و إن لم یروا مثل ما رأینا علمنا أنه سحر سحرتنا به، فأنزل الله اقتربت الساعه إلى آخر السوره.
تفسیر القمی، ج‏2، ص: 341

It is narrated from Imam al-Sadiq, peace be upon him and his family, that fourteen men from the Companions of al-‘Aqaba gathered on the night of the fourteenth of Dhu al-Hijja. They said to the Messenger of God, peace be upon him and his family: “Every prophet had a sign. What is your sign on this night?” The Prophet replied, “What would you like?” They said, “If you hold any rank before the Lord of the worlds, command this moon to split in two.” After this exchange, Gabriel, peace be upon him, descended and said, “O Muhammad, the Most Exalted and Glorified sends you His greetings and says: I have made all that exists in the heavens and on earth obedient to you. Command whatever you wish.” The Prophet then commanded the moon to split in two, and at his command the moon split in two over Yathrib and al-Batha. When the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him and his family, and our Shi‘a witnessed this extraordinary miracle that night, they fell in prostration to give thanks. When they rose from prostration, the hypocrites said, “Command the two halves to come together again.” The Prophet did so, and they reunited. Still out of obstinacy, they said, “Split the moon once more.” The Prophet again split it at their request. They then said, “Our companions have travelled to Syria and Yemen. When they return, we will ask them what they saw tonight. If they too saw what we saw, we will know that this is from God Most High. But if they did not, we will know that you have performed magic on us.” This is why God Most High says, “و انشق القمر و إن یروا آیه یعرضوا”—and when the hypocrites see a sign and miracle attesting to the truth of the Prophet of the End of Time, they turn away from it and say, “و یقولوا سحر مستمر”: “This is powerful magic, beyond all other magic,” or, “This is magic that Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him and his family, keeps performing.” “و کذبوا” means they denied the miracle, “و اتبعوا أهواءهم” means they followed their own desires. Ali ibn Ibrahim says: “یعملون برأیهم و یکذبون انبیائهم.” From his words, it may be inferred that, in meaning, اتبعوا اهواءهم comes before کذبوا; and every matter has its appointed end.

Tafsir Sharif-e Lahiji, vol. 4, p. 311

#Response477 (Part Two)

Scientific Miracles of the Quran

Center for Shia-Sunni Unity. NASA research confirms the miracle of the splitting of the moon. The opening verses of Surah al-Qamar indicate that, in the past, the moon was greatly cleft and split in two. Photographs of the lunar surface taken by NASA astronauts show fissures on the moon, proving that this great miracle took place.

According to the Iranian Quranic News Agency (IQNA), the passage above is part of the remarks made by Ayatollah Bi-Azar Shirazi at a gathering titled “The Splitting of the Moon: A Miracle of the Greatest Prophet (PBUH), in Light of NASA Research.” The event was organized by the Cultural Affairs Office of the Islamic Azad University (Center for Research and Quranic and Ahl al-Bayt Activities) and held on 12 Mehr at the International Quran Exhibition. ...

Dr. Abdolkarim Bi-Azar Shirazi recited the verse «اقتربت الساعه وانشق القمر» and said: “As you know, the Quran contains a surah called ‘The Moon’ [al-Qamar]. Its opening verses concern a great miracle performed by the Prophet (PBUH) for the people of Mecca. The point is that, like other peoples of earlier times, when the people of Mecca encountered miracles involving the natural world, they dismissed them as sorcery. Eventually, they asked: ‘How are we to know that he is a prophet? Whatever he does, you say it is magic.’”

He said: “In this connection, the Quraysh leaders said that magic does not work in the heavens. ‘Let us ask the Prophet (PBUH) for a heavenly miracle.’ They went to the Messenger of God (PBUH) and said, ‘If you really are God’s Prophet, and what you do is not magic, split the moon in two.’ The Prophet (PBUH) replied, ‘If I ask God and He does this, will you truly become Muslims?’ They answered, ‘Yes.’”

He continued: “The moon was full when the Prophet (PBUH) went out into the open with the Quraysh leaders. There, the Prophet asked Almighty God to split the moon so that the people could witness this miracle.”

At this prayer, the moon split, and they could see Mount Hira between its two halves. When they saw this sight, Abu Jahl, who was hostile to the Prophet (PBUH), said, “We cannot be sure this is not magic. Let us wait for the people returning from the desert and ask them whether they saw it.” After a while, some people returned from the desert and were asked about it. They replied, “Yes, we saw the moon split in two.” Even so, some persisted in their hostility.

Continuing his remarks, he said: “The opening verses of Surah al-Qamar were revealed in connection with this event. What these verses say is that the moon was greatly cleft in the past and split in two; they state this explicitly: «وانشق القمر». Second, the cleft was so immense that it is described as a sign of God, or a divine miracle: «و إن یروا آیه» if they see this sign and divine miracle. Third, some people witnessed the moon splitting, yet attributed it once again to sorcery: «و یقولوا سحر مستمر». Some denied this miracle: «و کذبوا بآیاتنا». And many interpreted the past-tense verb «انشق» as a future-tense verb, understanding the splitting in two as one of the signs of the appearance.”

He said: “Yet this miracle, like the miracle of the Quran, has become an enduring miracle. The greatest distinction of Islam is that it possesses a miracle. If you ask a Jew or a Christian whether they have a miracle at hand to show that their religion is true, they will say, ‘We do not have Moses’ staff to show you how it turns into a dragon.’ Christians, too, will say, ‘We do not have Jesus (AS) here to bring the dead back to life or heal the sick, so that you may understand.’”

He continued: “But if someone asks a Muslim, ‘Do you have proof that your religion is true?’ the answer is: ‘I have a miracle that endures, and it speaks of many different things across a range of fields that scholars can observe today.’ Another of the Prophet’s (PBUH) miracles, and its traces, was witnessed by astronauts who travelled to the moon aboard Apollo. They studied and researched it for years; that is what we are discussing tonight.”

He said: “In this regard, a figure named Dr. ‘David Pidcock,’ who is currently chairman of the Islamic Party of Britain, says: ‘I became Muslim through the verse «اقتربت الساعه وانشق القمر».’”

He says: “I was interested in studying comparative religions. I studied all religions and came to Islam. I had a Muslim friend, and I told him I wanted to research Islam. He gave me a Quran with an English translation, and I was delighted. That night, as I turned the pages of the Quran, Surah al-Qamar caught my attention. I opened it to see what the Quran said about the moon, and found that it said «اقتربت الساعه وانشق القمر». I was so lost in thought that I asked God: supposing the moon had split, how did it return to its original state? No matter how much I thought about it, I could not make sense of it. I became so repelled by the Quran that I put it aside, and this verse turned me away from reading it.”

He continues: “Because my work was sincere. A few nights later, I watched a television programme featuring three astronauts presenting their research on the moon. The host asked them, ‘You spent an enormous amount of money travelling to the moon, while so many people on Earth are in need. Wouldn’t it have been better to spend that money on them?’

“The astronauts replied, ‘The money we spent on these missions was not wasted. We made discoveries of such significance that they would have been worth it even if we had spent several times as much.’

“The host asked, ‘What was this discovery that made it all worthwhile?’

“They said, ‘By observing the moon, we had previously seen fissures on its surface, but we could not make any definite statements about them. Then we travelled to the moon and took photographs with Apollo 10. From a distance of 14 kilometres, we saw images that clearly showed that the moon had split apart on a vast scale in the past. When we landed on its surface with Apollo 11, we saw these fissures at close range.’

“They went on: ‘If we had tried to tell people about this, no one would have believed us. It took these repeated missions for us to make such an important discovery.’

“The astronauts said that NASA had studied and researched the subject for years and had published many papers on it. Photographs show numerous fissures on the moon’s surface, of three kinds: first, spiral fissures; second, circular ones, which can sometimes reach a thousand kilometres in diameter; and finally, straight fissures that encircle the moon like a belt. Scientists believe that the circular fissures were caused by meteorites striking the moon. But the belt-like fissures that encircle it cannot have been formed by meteorite impacts.

“They continued: ‘The images provided by the astronauts made it completely clear how the two hemispheres, after separating, had fused back together.’

“He continued: ‘Dr David P. Cook added that fissures and subsequent fusion also occur on Earth. Vast rifts form beneath the oceans and then fuse together through molten material, sometimes giving rise to enormous underwater mountains. A German scientist discovered that Earth’s continents were once joined together: all these landmasses were once one. If we bring the continental pieces together, they fit and form a single continent. This is the result of a rift that formed beneath the ocean. The continents extend farther apart day by day, and the distance between them continues to grow—by several hundredths of a centimetre each year. This is one of the miracles of the Holy Quran, which says: «والأرض مددناها»—that is, “We stretched out the land.” It may also be one of the remarkable points in the Holy Quran that modern science and scientists have discovered.’

“Bi-Azar Shirazi then raised a question: ‘One issue here is that, if the splitting of the moon took place in the time of the Prophet (PBUH), how was it not seen elsewhere, and why was it observed only in Arabia?’

“In response, he said: ‘There is evidence indicating that this miracle was not seen only in Arabia, but in other countries as well. One Indian manuscript held at the British Museum in London recounts the sighting of شق‌القمر fourteen centuries ago. A Muslim scholar, Dr Muhammad Hamidullah, cites it in his book about the life of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).

“Hujjat al-Islam Bi-Azar Shirazi continued: ‘He says that a king in southwestern India witnessed this splitting in his own time, and people passed on what they had seen. Later, when a group of Muslim merchants travelled to India and arrived in that city, they heard the account of شق‌القمر. They said, “We witnessed this event in India.” The merchants confirmed that what they said was true, explaining that it was a miracle of Islam (PBUH). The king of India sent his son to Arabia to investigate. When he learned that it was a miracle of the Prophet (PBUH), he became Muslim.’

“David P. Cook says: ‘Watching this programme brought about a revolution in me. What an extraordinary miracle God presented through His Prophet fourteen centuries ago—and today these astronauts have observed it with ease and made it known to us.’

“Explaining how students of Quranic and Hadith studies could enter the field of scientific exegesis, Bi-Azar Shirazi said: ‘In the past, some people compared and examined Quranic verses alongside the views of scientists. They were then criticised on the grounds that hypotheses and theories change, whereas the Quran is constant. If we try to make the Quran conform to scientific theories, then when those theories change, the Quran’s credibility is undermined.’”

He added: “But I believe we should take what the Qur’an says as our starting point, and draw on what contemporary science says when it is in agreement. It was never a matter of forcing the Qur’an to fit the theories of scientists; the reverse was the case. Today, the situation is entirely different. We can actually see certain things with our own eyes, such as the miracle of the splitting of the moon, which Western scientists have directly observed, explained and elucidated. This is not some scientist’s hypothesis or theory that might later be revised. For example, the earth’s being spherical was once only a hypothesis. Even as late as the time of the late Ṣāḥib al-Ḥadāʾiq, people said that the earth was flat. Today, however, we have observed and photographed its spherical shape.”

Continuing his remarks, he said: “Many of the Qur’an’s scientific truths have also been observed in our own time. Yet, as the Qur’an itself says of its scientific subject matter, «قل أنزله الذی یعلم»: God sent down this Qur’an with His own knowledge, not with human knowledge. It is a vast knowledge that encompasses God, the Hereafter, nature and the supernatural, unlike human knowledge, which is very limited. The Qur’an itself promises: «سنریهم آیاتنا فی الآفاق وفی أنفسهم حتى یتبین لهم أنه الحق»—We will soon show people Our signs throughout the cosmos and in the creation of the human being, until it becomes clear to them that God is the Truth.”

At the end of his remarks, Bi-Azar Shirazi said: “The Qur’an is the truth, as it says: «ویرى الذین أوتوا العلم الذی أنزل إلیک من ربک هو الحق»—Those who possess knowledge recognise that what has been sent down to you from your Lord is the truth. Today, many great scholars in America and Europe, upon seeing these verses about the cosmos and the creation of humanity—verses of such immense grandeur—become Muslims. Unfortunately, however, we take a very superficial view of the Qur’anic verses and simply recite them: «وکأین من آیه فی السماوات والأرض یمرون علیها وهم عنها معرضون»—How many signs there are in the heavens and the earth, yet people pass them by and turn away.”

Sources:

http://www.tebyan.net

http://www.pa.msu.edu/people/frenchj/moon/index2.html

All the questions have been posted in the Telegram group “Cave of Questions and Ruby of Answers,” and the answers are by Master Ali Saei.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022