Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2643 17 July 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

What Should You Do When a Long-Standing Prayer Remains Unanswered?

Primary reference: See the answer text 46 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2643

Question 60
Question asked:

What exactly should a person do when a need they have been asking God to fulfil for years remains unmet?

…I once read something about how when Prophet Joseph (peace be upon him) said, “My Lord, prison is better for me,” God decreed that he would go to prison. But when Prophet Moses said to God, “I am in need of whatever good You have in Your presence,” God had so much in store for him. So how should we ask God for what we need?

When years go by and someone’s need is still unmet, exactly how should they ask God?

Should they say, “God, if it is in my best interests, I ask You to grant me this,” and name what they are seeking? Or should they say, “I am in need of whatever good You have in Your presence,” without mentioning what they want?

Master Ali Saei’s response

Peace be upon you.

First, we should examine ourselves carefully: might there be some inward cause or obstacle preventing our prayers from being answered?

🌻🌱 One of the important reasons prayers may be withheld can be explained, in the words of our master, as follows:

A man stood up and, after praising the Commander of the Faithful, said, “I have a question about these words of God Most High: ‘Call upon Me; I will answer you.’ Why, then, do we pray but receive no answer?” Imam Ali (peace be upon him) replied:

“Your hearts have betrayed you in eight ways:

“First, you came to know God, yet you did not fulfil His due as He had commanded you to. So your knowledge did you no good.

“Second, you believed in His Messenger, but then opposed his way and abandoned his sacred law. What, then, was the fruit of your faith?

“Third, you read the Book He sent down to you, but did not act upon it. You said, ‘We hear and obey,’ yet went against it.

“Fourth, you said that you feared the Fire, but at every turn your sins and disobedience led you towards it. Where, then, was your fear?

“Fifth, you said that you longed for Paradise, yet at every turn you did what took you further from it. Where, then, was your longing for Paradise?

“Sixth, you enjoyed the blessings of your Lord, but did not give thanks for them.

“Seventh, God commanded you to oppose Satan and said, ‘Satan is your enemy, so take him as an enemy.’ Yet you opposed him only in words and befriended him through your actions.

“Eighth, you kept other people’s faults before your eyes and put your own behind your backs. You blame someone who is less deserving of blame than you are.

“With all this, what prayer of yours can be answered, when you have closed its doors and blocked its paths? So be mindful of God, set your affairs right, keep your intentions sincere, and enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong. Then your prayers will be answered.”

1. You came to know God, but did not fulfil His due as He had commanded you. So that knowledge did you no good.

2. You believed in God’s Prophet, then opposed his way and abandoned his sacred law. What, then, was the fruit of your faith?

3. You read the Book of God, sent down to you, but did not act upon it. You said, “We hear and accept,” yet went against it.

4. You said, “We fear the Fire of Hell,” but at every turn your sins and disobedience led you towards it. Where, then, was your fear of Hell?

5. You said, “We long for Paradise,” yet at every turn you did things that took you further from it. Where, then, was your longing for Paradise?

6. You enjoyed the blessings of your Lord, but did not give thanks for them.

7. God commanded you to oppose Satan and said, “Satan is your enemy, so take him as an enemy.” Yet you opposed him only in words and befriended him through your actions.

8. You kept other people’s faults before your eyes and put your own behind your backs, ignoring them. As a result, you blame someone who is less deserving of blame than you are.

Given all this, what prayer of yours can be answered, when you have closed the doors to prayer and blocked its paths? So be mindful of God, set your affairs right, enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong, and God will answer your prayers.

🌻🌱

🌸 Once we have made sure that the reason our prayer has not been answered does not lie within us, we can understand the delay as arising from one of the following:

1) Our Merciful God has a special love for our supplications!

2) The delay is in the supplicant’s best interests; waiting brings greater benefit than an immediate answer!

3) The delay is a kind of test, giving the supplicant the chance to prove the constancy of their love and devotion in worship!

4) The delay increases the supplicant’s reward and recompense!

5) Persisting in prayer is itself an ongoing act of worship. When that persistence is combined with a delayed answer, its benefits increase!

6) A delay in the answer does not mean that divine grace has ceased. Rather, God’s kindness and generosity reach the supplicant in other ways. If these were taken into account, their benefit might exceed that of the very thing being asked for, while the supplication itself remains in place!

7) A delay in the answer raises the supplicant’s standing in the sight of God Most High and among the inhabitants of the unseen realm!

8) What matters most is that the Lord continues to turn His attention towards us!

9) And much more…

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

A prayer may go unanswered because of inner obstacles, such as failing to fulfill one’s duties toward God, going against the Prophet’s Sunnah, not putting the Qur’an into practice, lacking fear of the Fire and longing for Paradise, failing to give thanks, showing enmity toward Satan, or finding fault with others. Otherwise, a delay in its answer may be for the person’s good: God loves their earnest supplication, the delay may benefit them, it may be a test, it may increase their reward, or divine grace may reach them in other ways.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Question 60

Question asked:

What exactly should one do when asking for something that has gone unfulfilled for years?

…I read somewhere that when Prophet Joseph, peace be upon him, said, “My Lord, prison is better for me,” God decreed prison for him. But when Prophet Moses said to God, “I am in need of the good that is with You,” God had all sorts of things in store for him. So how should we ask God for what we need?

What should we do when years pass and our need is still unmet? How exactly should we ask God?

Should I say, “God, if it is good for me, I ask You to make this happen”?

Or should I say, “I am in need of the good that is with You,” without mentioning what I have in mind?

Master Ali Saei’s answer

Peace be upon you.

First, we should take account of ourselves and consider whether the reason our prayers are not answered lies in some inner obstacle.

🌻🌱Drawing on the words of our master, we can describe the main reasons why prayers are held back as follows:

A man stood up and, after praising the Commander of the Faithful, said, “I have a question about these words of God Most High: ‘ادعوني استجب لكم’—‘Call upon Me, and I will answer you.’ Why, then, do we pray without receiving an answer?” Imam Ali, peace be upon him, replied:

“ان قلوبكم خان بثمان خصال . يعني : دل هاي شما در هشت مورد خيانت و بي وفايي كرد :
اولهما : انكم عرفتم الله فلم تو دوا حقه كما اوجب عليكم فما اغنت عنكم معرفتكم شييا .
و الثانيه : انكم آمنتم برسوله ثم خالفتم سنته و امتم شريعته فاين ثمره ايمانكم ؟
و الثالثه : انكم قراءتم كتابه المنزل عليكم فلم تعملوابه ، و قلتم سمعنا و اطعنا ثم خالفتم ؟
و الرابعه : انكم قلتم تخافون من النار و انتم في كل وقت تقدمون اليها بمعا صيكم فاين خوفكم ؟
و الخامسه : انكم قلتم ترغبون في الجنه و انتم في كل وقت تفعلون ما يباعد كم منها فاين رغبتكم فيما ؟
السادسه : انكم اكلتم نعمه الله المولي فلم تشكروا عليها ؟
السابعه : ان الله امركم بعد اوه الشيطان و قال ان الشيطان لكم عدو فاتخذوا عدوا فعاديتموه بلاقول و اليتموه بلا مخالفه .
الثامنه : انكم جعلتم عيوب الناس تصب اعينكم و عيوبكم و راء ظهور كم تلومون من انتم احق باللوم منه فاي دعاء يستجاب لكم مع هذا و قد سددتم ابوابه و طرقه ؟
فاتقوا الله و اصلحوا اعمالكم و اخلصوا سراير كم و اءمر و ابالمعروف و انهوا عن المنكر فيستجيب لكم دعايكم .”

1. You came to know God, but did not fulfil His rights as you were commanded to; so your knowledge did you no good.

2. You believed in God’s Messenger, then went against his way and set aside his law. What, then, became of the fruit of your faith?

3. You read the Book God sent down to you, but did not act upon it. You said, “We hear and obey,” yet you went against it.

4. You said, “We fear the Fire,” but by your sins and disobedience you are constantly moving towards it. Where, then, is your fear of the Fire?

5. You said, “We long for Paradise,” yet at all times you do things that take you farther from it. Where, then, is your longing and desire for Paradise?

6. You partook of the blessings of your Lord, but did not give thanks for them.

7. God commanded you to oppose Satan and said, “ان الشيطان لكم عدو فاتخذوا عدوا”—“Satan is your enemy, so take him as an enemy.” Yet you opposed him only in words; through your actions, you befriended him.

8. You kept other people’s faults before your eyes while ignoring your own. You blame those who are less deserving of blame than you are.

Given all this, what prayer of yours could be answered, when you have closed its doors and barred its paths? So be mindful of God, set your affairs right, enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong, and He will answer your prayers.”

🌻🌱

🌸Once we have considered this and found that the reason our prayers go unanswered does not lie in an inner obstacle, we can understand the delay in one of the following ways:

1. Our merciful God loves our intimate supplications!

2. The delay is in the supplicant’s best interests; the benefit of a delayed answer is greater than that of an immediate one!

3. The delay is a kind of test, allowing the supplicant to prove the steadfastness of their love and devotion in worship!

4. The delay increases the supplicant’s reward and recompense!

5. Persisting in prayer is itself an ongoing act of worship. When joined with a delayed answer, its benefits grow!

6. A delay in answering prayer does not mean that divine care has ceased. Rather, God’s grace and generosity reach the supplicant in other ways; when these are taken into account, their benefit may exceed that of the specific answer, while the supplicant’s prayer remains in place!

7. A delay in answering prayer raises the supplicant’s standing before God, the Exalted, and among the heavenly beings!

8. What matters most is that the Lord’s attention remains upon us and is never withdrawn!

9. And more besides…

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022