According to the following hadith, given that the Infallibles (AS) are fully aware of all things and that there is no difference between their life and the period after their martyrdom, why does Imam Ali (AS) say that the Messenger of God (PBUH) should ask his daughter, Fatima al-Zahra (SA), about what had happened? Was Imam Ali himself unaware?
Imam Ali (AS), as Fatima (SA) was being laid to rest, said:
قل یا رسول الله عن صفیتک صبری، ورق عنها تجلدی ... وستنبئک ابنتک بتضافر أمتک على هضمها فأحفها السؤال واستخبرها الحال. هذا ولم یطل العهد ولم یخل منک الذکر.
“O Messenger of God, my patience at being parted from your beloved daughter is spent, and my strength to endure has failed ... Soon your daughter will tell you of the wrongs and violations of her rights that your community, united in its purpose, inflicted upon her. Ask her about every detail; inquire into her circumstances. These things happened so soon after your departure, while your memory had not yet faded.”
Nahj al-Balagha, Sermon 202; Selected Mizan al-Hikmah, p. 96
Why Did Imam Ali (AS) Ask Lady Fatima (SA) About What Had Happened?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Imam Ali’s (AS) words at Lady Fatima’s (SA) grave are not intended as a factual report. They are a lament and an appeal against injustice, giving fuller expression to the anguish in his heart. His words point to calamities that should never have occurred; in effect, they are a plea for justice—just as God speaks through the Prophet (PBUH) of the wrongs inflicted on him by his people.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe words spoken by Mawla Amir al-Mu'minin, peace be upon him, at the resting place of the Noble Messenger of God, blessings and peace be upon him and his family, are not simple statements of fact; rather, they are expressions of lament. In reality, these words constitute a lament for him, articulated in this particular form.
This kind of intimate outpouring in elegy is distinctive and exceptional: it reveals the burning of the heart all the more intensely.
When he says, “It will inform you ...,” this alludes, in a sense, to a plea for justice, a demand for redress, and a complaint. It also points to calamities that ought never to have occurred. Indeed, it is exceedingly difficult and almost beyond belief that the beloved daughter of the Messenger of God, blessings and peace be upon him and his family, should have suffered such grievous torment at the hands of the community of that Messenger.
Just as the Messenger of God, blessings and peace be upon him and his family, hears the intimate lament of Mawla Amir al-Mu'minin, so, through God's power and grace, he is also able to know of all that has taken place.
Of course, this manner of speaking is also a distinctive way of cultivating intimacy. For example, although the All-Knowing God is aware of every matter, the Prophet of God informs Him of the wrongs committed by his people:
الفرقان : 30 و قال الرسول یا رب إن قومی اتخذوا هذا القرآن مهجورا
And the Messenger said: “My Lord, my people have abandoned this Qur'an.”
قال رب إنى دعوت قومى لیلا و نهارا(5)
فلم یزدهم دعاءى إلا فرارا(6)
و إنى کلما دعوتهم لتغفر لهم جعلوا أصابعهم فى ءاذانهم و استغشوا ثیابهم و أصروا و استکبروا استکبارا(7)
ثم إنى دعوتهم جهارا(8)
(Noah) said: “My Lord, I called my people by night and by day, (5)
but my call only increased them in their flight from the truth. (6)
Whenever I called them so that You might forgive them, they thrust their fingers into their ears, wrapped their garments around themselves, persisted in their opposition, and displayed great arrogance. (7)
Then I called them aloud to obey Your command, (8)
then I proclaimed the truth of Divine Oneness and faith to them both openly and secretly. (9)”