Those who reject Islamic medicine have asked: Why, when Lady Fatima (SA) fell ill at a young age, did Imam Ali (AS) not treat her? If he knew how to treat her but did not, wouldn’t that have been a sin? And why did he call a Jewish physician when he himself fell ill?
Why Did Imam Ali (AS) Not Treat Lady Fatima (SA) During Her Illness?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Death is the only illness that cannot be cured, and no physician can postpone the divinely appointed time of death. Lady Fatima (SA), accepting God’s decree, answered the divine summons. Had the time to answer that summons not yet come, she herself or Imam Ali (AS) would have treated her. The Messenger of God (PBUH) said: “Seek treatment, for God has sent down a remedy for every illness He has sent down—except death.”
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterNo physician can delay the divinely appointed time of death! Lady Fatima Zahra, سلام الله علیها, answered the call of God, the Beloved and Most Loving, accepting His decree. Surely, had the time to answer the call of the Truth not yet come, the Lady herself—or the Master—would have administered treatment.
Every illness has a cure except the illness of death. In other words, life’s appointed end is the end of one’s life in this world. Death is the only pain for which there is no cure.
أن رسول الله ص قال: تداووا فما أنزل الله داء إلا أنزل معه دواء إلا السام يعني الموت فإنه لا دواء له.
دعائم الإسلام، ج2، ص: 143
The Messenger of God, صلی الله علیه و آله و سلم, said: “Seek treatment, for God has not sent down any illness without also sending down its remedy—except al-sām, which is death, for it has no cure.”
Al-‘Ankabut: 5
من کان یرجوا لقاء الله فإن أجل الله لآت و هو السمیع العلیم
Whoever hopes to meet God (and be raised again) should strive to obey Him, for the time appointed by God will surely come. He is the All-Hearing, the All-Knowing.
Al-Zumar: 42
الله یتوفى الأنفس حین موتها و التی لم تمت فی منامها فیمسک التی قضى علیها الموت و یرسل الأخرى إلى أجل مسمى إن فی ذلک لآیات لقوم یتفکرون
God takes the souls at the time of their death, and those that have not died during their sleep. He keeps those for whom He has decreed death and returns the others, that they may live until an appointed time. Surely, in this are clear signs for people who reflect.