(Questions from little Mahya)
Sometimes I’ve heard people say when they’re praying, “God, if it’s best, make this happen,” or “Give me this thing”—because maybe what we’re asking for is bad. Praying is such a good thing, so why do people say “if it’s best”? (For example, in my prayers I say, “Dear God, give Mahya a duck.” A duck isn’t a bad thing, so why would I have to say, “If it’s best, give me a duck”?)
Why Do We Say “If It Is Best” in Our Prayers?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
When we say “if it is best” in our prayers, it is because we think we know what is best for us. In reality, however, only God knows what is truly best for us. Something that seems good and harmless to us may have unintended consequences that God knows about. That is why we pray with humility, leaving the matter to God’s will.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWe think we know what is best for us, but God surely knows what is best for us. For example, we may want a duck to be with us, but it might be separated from its family; we might not be able to care for it and it could die; we might catch an illness from it; or we might be unable to attend to some of our important responsibilities. There are countless other reasons, known to God but not to us.