If the Prophet was protected from error even in worldly matters, why did he need to consult the people? Why does God instruct him to consult them?
Why Does God Instruct the Prophet to Consult the People?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The instruction for the Prophet of Islam to consult the people was intended to establish a tradition of consultation, foster greater closeness, and show that they were valued. This consultation concerned people’s ordinary affairs, not religious matters, in which the Prophet conveyed divine laws and had no need to consult others. In fact, the Prophet’s consultation laid the foundation for a consultative council on the people’s ordinary affairs, so that they could deliberate together about their day-to-day concerns.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIt is entirely clear that anyone who is directly connected with the Creator has no need to consult people, since he can receive the correct decision from the All-Knowing God.
The noble verse is, in fact, establishing the tradition of consultation. It also creates a closer relationship between Muslims and affirms their value.
In consultation, minds are brought together so that, through the greater intellectual capacity thus achieved, a better outcome may be reached in carrying out affairs. Since we know that the sacred being of the Messenger of Islam was pure intellect (in accordance with the principle that he was the first thing created by God), then, in a council attended by the Messenger of Islam and the Immaculate Imams, those around them should derive light and illumination from the realm of intellect; the sun of intellect should not derive its light and illumination from moons and other celestial bodies.
Among the effects of consultation—and, in particular, among the meanings conveyed by the “verse of consultation”—is the practical introduction of the superior and discerning individual.
The Messenger of Islam never consulted anyone concerning religious or divine matters or the formulation of laws, because he was the bearer of divine laws from the divine realm, and consultation has no basis or place in such matters. Indeed, even in ordinary matters, he had no need to consult others. The Prophet’s consultation was, in reality, the foundation for establishing a consultative assembly regarding matters connected with people’s ordinary affairs, so that the community might consult one another in their everyday concerns. This is what is referred to in verse 38 of al-Shura:
الشورى : 38 و الذین استجابوا لربهم و أقاموا الصلاه و أمرهم شورى بینهم و مما رزقناهم ینفقون
And those who respond to their Lord, establish prayer, conduct their affairs by mutual consultation, and spend from what We have provided for them,
When people are instructed to consult one another in their ordinary affairs, then, all the more so, in religious matters they must obtain their obligations from the source of religion. This verse implicitly establishes the position of the Messenger and the divinely appointed spiritual leaders as the primary source from which religious and doctrinal matters are to be received.
الحشر : 7 ... و ما آتاکم الرسول فخذوه و ما نهاکم عنه فانتهوا و اتقوا الله إن الله شدید العقاب
... Whatever the Messenger gives you, accept it, and whatever he forbids you, abstain from it. And fear God; indeed, God is severe in punishment.
النساء : 59 یا أیها الذین آمنوا أطیعوا الله و أطیعوا الرسول و أولی الأمر منکم فإن تنازعتم فی شیء فردوه إلى الله و الرسول إن کنتم تؤمنون بالله و الیوم الآخر ذلک خیر و أحسن تأویلا
O you who believe, obey God, obey the Messenger, and those vested with authority among you [the Prophet’s successors]. Then, if you differ over anything, refer it to God and the Messenger, if you believe in God and the Last Day. That is better for you and fairest in outcome.
If we pay close attention to the continuation of verse 159 of Āl ʿImrān, we find the words “فإذا عزمت”—“when you have decided.” It does not say, “when you have decided” in the plural. Therefore, the Messenger’s consultation was purely a matter of honouring others and served other specific interests.
آلعمران : 159 فبما رحمه من الله لنت لهم و لو کنت فظا غلیظ القلب لانفضوا من حولک فاعف عنهم و استغفر لهم و شاورهم فی الأمر فإذا عزمت فتوکل على الله إن الله یحب المتوکلین
It was by the mercy of God that you were gentle with them. Had you been harsh and hard-hearted, they would have dispersed from around you. So pardon them, seek forgiveness for them, and consult them in the matter. Then, when you have made a decision, place your trust in God. Indeed, God loves those who place their trust in Him.
The View of the Author of Majmaʿ al-Bayān
God then explains that the Prophet’s leniency toward them and his overlooking their sins were a mercy from God, through which He made him gentle-natured, compassionate, and gracious.
“فبما رحمه”—that is, by means of mercy.
“من الله لنت لهم”—that is, your gentleness toward them is among the qualities that lead them to enter the religion, because, through the noble attributes, fine character, and virtuous qualities you possess, you present them with proof and evidence.
“و لو کنت”—O Muhammad, had you been—
“فظا”—harsh, discourteous, and ill-tempered—
“غلیظ القلب”—hard-hearted, lacking tenderness and compassion.
“لانفضوا من حولک”—that is, your companions would have dispersed from around you and fled from you.
As for bringing together fظاظه and غلظت, despite their being close in meaning, this is because *fظاظت* means harshness in speech. Thus, both verbal harshness and the cruelty and hardness of the heart have been negated in him.
“فاعف عنهم”—Pardon whatever grievances exist between you and them.
“واستغفر لهم”—And ask forgiveness for whatever lies between Me and them.
It has also been said that this means: Pardon them for their fleeing at Uhud, and ask forgiveness for these sins.
“وشاورهم فی الأمر”—That is, draw out their opinions and learn what they have to offer.
There is disagreement concerning the benefit of the Prophet’s consulting his Companions, despite his having no need of consultation, since through God’s revelation he always knew the right course and had no need to discover the sound opinion through the thoughts of God’s servants, whose judgments are often mistaken whereas revelation is free from error. Several views have been reported:
1. This was intended to purify their souls, foster affection, remove resentment and anxiety, and let them know that the Prophet relied on their words and sought their opinions. This view is attributed to Qatadah, al-Rabiʿ and Ibn Ishaq.
2. It was so that the community would follow his example in consulting others and would not regard consultation as a deficiency or disgrace. This view is attributed to Sufyan ibn ʿUyaynah.
3. It was intended to honour the Companions. This view is attributed to al-Hasan and al-Dahhak.
4. It was a test for them, so that through consultation he could distinguish the sincere adviser from the ill-intentioned one.
5. This consultation concerned worldly matters, military strategies and how to confront the enemy; in such matters, it is permissible to seek assistance from their judgment. This view is attributed to Abu ʿAli al-Jubbaʾi.
Translation of *Majmaʿ al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Qurʾan*, vol. 4, p. 315.