Why does the Qur’an mention a mistake or error for most of the prophets whose stories it relates? For example, in Surah *Ṣād*, an error is mentioned for each of the prophets. Why does the Qur’an place so much emphasis on the prophets’ mistakes? And how does this relate to their infallibility? The explanations given for these mistakes are somewhat difficult to understand.
Why Does the Qur’an Emphasize the Prophets’ Mistakes, and How Does This Relate to Their Infallibility?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
No prophet errs in carrying out the duties of prophethood. The prophetic office is bestowed upon those who meet the necessary qualifications, and God safeguards them as they convey His message. The divine admonitions and rebukes in the Qur’an did not diminish their prophethood; rather, they raised their rank. These were special trials through which they attained higher stations.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterNo prophet ever commits an error in carrying out the duties of his mission. Their sole role is to convey the divine command, and the Creator Himself safeguards them in its transmission and execution.
The office of messenger is conferred only after a person has become qualified for it. Throughout his mission, every messenger retains the distinction of his office; otherwise, he would not have been raised to prophethood. And even if, for the sake of argument, we set this point aside, we can say with certainty that he would not have been permitted to continue his mission in such a state.
The rebukes and reprimands addressed to certain messengers in the word of God did not prevent them from fulfilling their prophetic mission, nor did they strip them of the distinction of messengership. Rather, had they not committed these errors, they would have been raised to still higher ranks.
What are called the errors of the messengers were in fact special tests for the prophets, through which they could advance to higher stations. Some did not succeed at first, but later attained success. In other words, some did not pass the first round of the test, but in subsequent stages attained the rank and distinction they deserved.
Although some of the great prophets committed certain errors before being raised to the office of messenger, they attained prophethood only after repenting and turning back to God, receiving His forgiveness, and being completely purified.
The great prophets, too, take part in the race of servitude to God and the ascent to higher ranks. On the path of servitude, there is an initial threshold for attaining prophethood; beyond it, the way remains open to all of them to rise to ever higher degrees.
البقره : 253 تلک الرسل فضلنا بعضهم على بعض منهم من کلم الله و رفع بعضهم درجات و آتینا عیسى ابن مریم البینات و أیدناه بروح القدس و لو شاء الله ما اقتتل الذین من بعدهم من بعد ما جاءتهم البینات و لکن اختلفوا فمنهم من آمن و منهم من کفر و لو شاء الله ما اقتتلوا و لکن الله یفعل ما یرید
We gave some of those messengers precedence over others. To some of them God spoke directly, and He raised others by degrees. We gave Jesus son of Mary clear signs and strengthened him with the Holy Spirit …
الأنعام : 83 و تلک حجتنا آتیناها إبراهیم على قومه نرفع درجات من نشاء إن ربک حکیم علیم
These were the arguments We gave Abraham against his people. We raise in rank whomever We will. Your Lord is All-Wise, All-Knowing.