Why is praying for polytheists forbidden? Given that many people may have some degree of shirk, particularly subtle shirk, what should they do? Must this shirk be recognizable?
Answer
Why Is Praying for Polytheists Forbidden?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Seeking forgiveness for polytheists is forbidden because it signifies friendship with an enemy of God. If a person’s shirk is subtle and they are unaware of it, this prohibition does not apply to them. But if they are aware of their subtle shirk and make no effort to remedy it, it is no longer subtle, and praying for them is not permissible. Knowledge of the truth is attained by holding fast to the Qur’an and the Ahl al-Bayt.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterSeeking forgiveness is an expression of deep love and a sign of compassion. A polytheist is an enemy of God, and befriending an enemy of God is a form of enmity toward God Himself.
Someone who falls into hidden shirk out of ignorance is not included in the foregoing emphasis.
But if someone knows that they are afflicted with hidden shirk and remains indifferent, taking no steps to overcome it, then their shirk is no longer hidden.
Someone afflicted with hidden shirk who seeks religious knowledge outside the realm of the Qur’an and the Ahl al-Bayt, and persists in their position, is still culpable for their hidden shirk and deserves no compassion.
Whoever keeps within the sanctuary of the Qur’an and the Ahl al-Bayt will have the truths made clear to them, and the ailments of their heart—including hidden and most hidden shirk—will be revealed to them.
Maryam: 47 قال سلام علیک سأستغفر لک ربی إنه کان بی حفیا
(Ibrahim) said, “Peace be upon you! I shall soon ask my Lord to forgive you. He has always been gracious to me.”
Al-Tawbah: 113 ما کان للنبی و الذین آمنوا أن یستغفروا للمشرکین و لو کانوا أولی قربى من بعد ما تبین لهم أنهم أصحاب الجحیم
It was not fitting for the Prophet and the believers to ask God to forgive the polytheists, even if they were close relatives, once it had become clear to them that these people were destined for Hell.
Al-Tawbah: 114 و ما کان استغفار إبراهیم لأبیه إلا عن موعده وعدها إیاه فلما تبین له أنه عدو لله تبرأ منه إن إبراهیم لأواه حلیم
Abraham’s prayer for forgiveness for his father [his uncle Azar] was only because of a promise he had made to him, hoping to draw him to faith. But when it became clear to Abraham that he was an enemy of God, he disavowed him. Abraham was indeed tenderhearted and forbearing.
All the questions have been raised in the Telegram group “Kahf Questions and Yaqut Answers,” and the answers are from Master Ali Saei.