Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 835 4 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Why Were the Children of Israel Called Jews?

Primary reference: See the answer text 140 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-835

Why is the Children of Israel called “Jewish,” after one of the brothers of Prophet Joseph, when Joseph himself was a prophet?

#Answer853

One explanation for why the Jews are called Jews:

... قال المفضل یا مولای و سیدی لم سمی قوم موسى الیهود قال ع لقول الله عز و جل إنا هدنا إلیک «7» أی اهتدینا إلیک قال فالنصارى قال ع لقول عیسى ع من أنصاری إلى الله و تلا الآیه «8» إلى آخرها فسموا النصارى لنصره دین الله‏

Bihar al-Anwar (Beirut edition), vol. 53, p. 5

Mufaddal asked: “My master, why are the people of Moses called Jews?” He replied: “Because God relates that they said: إنا هدنا إلیک—that is, ‘We have turned back to You.’” I asked: “Why are the Christians called Nasara?” He replied: “Because of the verse in which they said to Jesus: نحن أنصار الله—we are God’s helpers—and we support God’s religion.”

Mahdi the Promised (translation of vol. 51 of Bihar al-Anwar), text, p. 1151

A second explanation:

It is because the name refers to Judah. The names of Jacob’s sons are Joseph, Benjamin (Ibn Yamin), Reuben, Judah (Yehudah), Simeon, Levi, Dan (Dan–Zebulun), Qahab, Issachar, Naphtali, Gad, and Asher (Ashir).

ʿIlal al-Shara’iʿ / translated by Mostarahmi, text, p. 130

Further explanation

Why are the Children of Israel called Jews? Why aren’t they called Jacobites or Josephites?

Greetings and respects. Israel is another name for Prophet Jacob. Israel was a title that may have been given to him because of his many journeys (=travelling), or because he served in the House of God, Bayt al-Maqdis (=servant of God).[1] The prophethood of Prophet Jacob began about 3,483 years after Prophet Adam (AS) descended to earth, and approximately 3,575 years ago.[2] Another source reports that he migrated from Canaan (Palestine) to Egypt around 3,750 years ago (1740 BCE).[3]

Prophet Jacob (AS) was the son of Prophet Isaac (AS). He had twelve sons, and his fourth son was Judah. The twelve sons of Prophet Jacob (Israel) were, in order:

1. Reuben (Ruben); 2. Simeon; 3. Levi; 4. Judah (Juda); 5. Issachar (Yissachar); 6. Zebulun (Zebulon); 7. Dan; 8. Naphtali (Naphtiel); 9. Gad; 10. Asher; 11. Benjamin (Ben-Yamin); 12. Joseph.

Judah and his brothers lived with their father, Jacob (AS), in Canaan (Palestine). After the well-known events concerning Prophet Joseph, they migrated to Egypt; Judah was among them. This migration probably took place around 1740 BCE, when Prophet Jacob (AS) and all his household left Canaan for Egypt. Jews of later times are referred to as the Children of Israel, Jews, and Judeans.[4]

About 265 years after Prophet Jacob (AS), Prophet Moses (AS) was called to prophethood.[5] After him, Prophets Job (AS), Samuel (AS), David (AS), Solomon (AS), John (AS), Zechariah (AS), Jesus (AS), and other prophets descended from Isaac, son of Abraham (AS), were sent. About 1,565 years separate Prophet Jacob (AS) from Prophet Jesus (AS).

The people may have come to be called Jews because Judah (Juda) became their leader and a prominent figure. This does not mean that all Jews today are descended from Judah, since later prophets among them were born into the lineages of devout monotheists. Judah’s rise to prominence also had political significance. After Prophet Joseph’s death, a man named “Horemheb” served as Pharaoh’s commander in Egypt. He made great efforts to restore the worship of “Amun” and eradicate the signs of the monotheistic worship of “Aten.” He also launched an extensive campaign claiming that they had been afflicted by “Amun’s” curse. He bore no goodwill toward Prophet Joseph (AS) or monotheism, and removed all traces of monotheism and the name of Prophet Joseph (AS) from inscriptions and from among the Children of Israel.[6] These efforts coincided with Judah’s ambitions. As a result, little information about Prophet Joseph (AS) was known until the time of the Prophet of Islam (PBUH). With the advent of the Qur’an and its account of this story, the missing links were joined once more, and people became acquainted with the life of such an important prophet. The Qur’an says: «ذلک من أنباء الغیب نوحیه إلیک و ما کنت لدیهم إذ أجمعوا أمرهم و هم یمکرون» (Yusuf, 103) “This is part of the unseen news that We reveal to you. You were not with Joseph’s brothers when they made their decision and plotted.”

What we have presented is our analysis of the available evidence and may not be accurate. Jews today do not accept these claims. They say that the story of Prophet Joseph (AS) had been recorded from the beginning, and that the Torah as it exists today (the Old Testament) contains an extensive account of him. However, in view of the points mentioned above, these sections of the Old Testament were most likely brought together after the coming of the Seal of the Prophets, forming a connected and complementary account. God knows best.

One day, while travelling through the desert, the Prophet of Islam صلى الله عليه وآله came upon a Bedouin living in a tent. The man recognised him and treated him with great hospitality. As they were saying farewell, the Messenger of God صلى الله عليه وآله said to him, “Whenever you ask something of us, we shall ask God to grant it to you.” The man replied, “Ask God to give me a camel on which I can load my belongings when I travel, and a few sheep that I can graze in this desert and benefit from their milk.” The Prophet asked God to grant his requests, and God granted them. Then the Messenger of God صلى الله عليه وآله turned to his companions and said, “If only this man had set his sights higher and, like the old woman of the Children of Israel, asked us for the good of this world and the Hereafter. I would have asked God for it, and He would have granted it to him.” The companions asked him to tell them the story of “the old woman of the Children of Israel,” and the Prophet recounted it to them in full.

“Prophet Joseph عليه السلام had become so beloved and so highly esteemed by the people of Egypt that, after his death, they quarrelled over where he should be buried. Each group wanted Joseph’s body buried in its own district, so that his grave might bring blessings to their lives. At last, it was decided that he should be buried in the Nile, since the river water flowing over his grave would be used by everyone, allowing all people to benefit from the blessings of the pure presence of Prophet Joseph عليه السلام. [7]

The heavens’ aged father must endure for many years
before the world’s mother bears a child like you again.

Prophet Joseph’s body was buried in the Nile and remained there until Prophet Moses عليه السلام was preparing to leave Egypt with the Children of Israel. At that time, for a while, the moon did not appear over them because of dense clouds, and the nights were very dark. When the Children of Israel wanted to travel from Egypt toward Syria, they needed moonlight, or they would lose their way. It was revealed to Prophet Moses عليه السلام that he should take Joseph’s bones from the grave so that Joseph’s will might be fulfilled and he could be buried in Palestine. If he did so, God would cause the moon to shine for them.

Moses عليه السلام asked who knew where Joseph’s grave was. They told him that an old woman knew. Moses علیه السلام ordered that the old woman, worn down by age and blind, be brought before him. He asked her, “Do you know where Joseph’s grave is?” She replied, “Yes.”

Moses علیه السلام said, “Show us where it is.”

She said, “I will not show you unless you grant me four wishes. First, heal my legs. Second, restore my youth. Third, give me back my sight. Fourth, take me with you to Paradise.”

This weighed heavily on Moses علیه السلام. Then God revealed to him that he should grant her wishes. The old woman’s wishes were fulfilled, and she then showed him the location of Joseph’s grave.[8]

Moses علیه السلام recovered Joseph’s body from the Nile, where it lay in a marble coffin, and took it toward Syria. Then the moon rose.[9] Joseph’s body was buried, as is widely believed, beside the graves of his forefathers. Today, six farsakhs from Jerusalem, there is a place called “Quds Khalil,” where Joseph’s grave is said to be.[10]

[1] Masoumeh Begum Azarmi, *Stories of the Quran and the History of the Prophets*, Tahzib Publications, 2nd ed., spring 1388, Qom, p. 199.

[2] Ibid., p. 200.

[3] Sayyid Mohammad Shirazi, *The World and the Jews*, Forugh-e Danesh edition, Amin Publications, p. 3.

[4] Ibid., p. 10.

[5] Another account gives the interval between Prophet Jacob (AS) and Prophet Moses (AS) as approximately 400 years.

[6] Mika Waltari, *Sinuhe*, translated by Davoud Nematollahi, 1st ed., 1391, Tehran, p. 500.

[7] This section was taken from the Tebyan website.

[8] *Bihar*, vol. 18, p. 325.

[9] *ʿIlal al-Sharaʾiʿ*, p. 107; *Bihar*, vol. 13, p. 127.

[10] This section was adapted from the Andisheh Qom website.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The Children of Israel were called Jews because of their association with Judah, one of the twelve sons of the Prophet Jacob (AS). The name is also said to derive from the phrase «إنا هدنا إلیک», meaning “We have turned to You.” Yet the Prophet Joseph (AS) was also a prophet, while the name of the people came from one of his brothers.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Question 835:

Why is the Children of Israel called “Jews,” after one of Prophet Joseph’s brothers, when Prophet Joseph himself was a prophet?

🌸🔆❄️بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم❄️🔆🌸
#Answer853
🍀🔅🌟سلام علیکم🌟🔅🍀

🔆🔅🌱One reason the Jews are called Jews:

🌸🔅🌱 … قَالَ الْمُفَضَّلُ يَا مَوْلَايَ وَ سَيِّدِي لِمَ سُمِّيَ قَوْمُ مُوسَى الْيَهُودَ قَالَ ع لِقَوْلِ اللَّهِ عَزَّ وَ جَلَّ إِنَّا هُدْنا إِلَيْكَ «7» أَيِ اهْتَدَيْنَا إِلَيْكَ قَالَ فَالنَّصَارَى قَالَ ع لِقَوْلِ عِيسَى ع مَنْ أَنْصارِي إِلَى اللَّهِ وَ تَلَا الْآيَةَ «8» إِلَى آخِرِهَا فَسُمُّوا النَّصَارَى لِنُصْرَةِ دِينِ اللَّه‏
بحار الأنوار (Beirut edition), vol. 53, p. 5

🌸🔅🌱Mufaddal said, “Master, why are the people of Moses called Jews?” He replied, “Because God relates that they said: إِنَّا هُدْنا إِلَيْكَ‏that is, ‘We have turned back to You.’” I asked, “Why are the Christians called Nasrani?” He replied, “Because of this verse: they said to Jesus: نَحْنُ أَنْصارُ اللَّهِ ‘We are God’s helpers, and we support God’s religion.’”

المهدي الموعود (translation of volume 51 of بحار الأنوار), text, p. 1151

🍀Second view

🌸🔅🌱It is because the name refers to Judah. The names of Jacob’s children were Joseph, Benjamin (son of Yamin), Reuben, Judah (Yehuda), Simeon, Levi, Dan (Dan–Zebulun), Qahab, Yashjar, Naphtali, Gad, Asher.

علل الشرائع / translated by Mustarhami, text, p. 130

🍀Further explanation👇

Why are the Children of Israel called Jews? Why not Jacobites or Josephites?

Greetings and respects. Israel is another name for Prophet Jacob. Israel was a title given to him, possibly because he travelled frequently (=journeying and travelling), or because he served in the House of God in Jerusalem (=servant of God).[1] Prophet Jacob’s prophethood began approximately 3,483 years after Prophet Adam’s descent to earth (AS), and about 3,575 years ago.[2] Another source, however, places his migration from Canaan (Palestine) to Egypt about 3,750 years ago (1,740 years before the birth of Jesus Christ (AS)).[3]

Jacob (AS) was the son of Isaac (AS) and had twelve children. His fourth son was Judah. The twelve children of Jacob (Israel) were, in order:

1. Reuben (Ruben)
2. Simeon
3. Levi
4. Judah (Juda)
5. Issachar (Yashhar, Issachar)
6. Zebulun (Zebulon, Zialon)
7. Dan (Don)
8. Naphtali (Naphtail)
9. Gad
10. Asher (Ashar, Asar)
11. Benjamin (Ibn-Yamin, Benjamin)
12. Joseph

Judah and his brothers lived with their father Jacob (AS) in Canaan (Palestine). After the well-known events involving Joseph, they migrated to Egypt, and Judah was among them. This migration probably took place around 1740 BC, when Jacob (AS) and all his household left Canaan for Egypt. The Jews of today are also referred to as the Children of Israel, Jews, and Judahites.[4]

About 265 years after Jacob (AS), Moses (AS) was commissioned as a prophet.[5] After him, Job (AS), Samuel (AS), David (AS), Solomon (AS), John (AS), Zechariah (AS), Jesus (AS), and other prophets from the lineage of Isaac, son of Abraham (AS), were sent as prophets. About 1,565 years separate Jacob (AS) and Jesus (AS).

The people may have come to be called Jews because Judah (Juda) became their leader and a prominent figure. This does not mean that all Jews today are descended from Judah, since their later prophets were born of people who were devoted to the oneness of God and of pure faith. Making Judah prominent and bringing him to public attention may also have served a political purpose. After Joseph’s death, a man named “Horemheb” was the Pharaoh’s commander in Egypt. He made great efforts to revive the worship of Amun and eradicate the signs of Aten, the worship of one God. He also launched an extensive campaign claiming that they had been afflicted by Amun’s curse. He was no friend to Joseph (AS) or to belief in one God, and he removed every sign of monotheism, as well as Joseph’s name, from inscriptions and from the history of the Children of Israel.[6] These efforts coincided with Judah’s ambitions. As a result, little information about Joseph (AS) was known until the time of the Prophet of Islam (PBUH). With the revelation of the Qur’an and its account of this story, the missing links were joined together again, and people became acquainted with the life of this important prophet. The Qur’an says: «ذلِكَ مِنْ أَنْباءِ الْغَیبِ نُوحِیهِ إِلَیكَ وَ ما كُنْتَ لَدَیهِمْ إِذْ أَجْمَعُوا أَمْرَهُمْ وَ هُمْ یمْكُرُونَ» (Yusuf, 103): “This is news of the unseen that We reveal to you. You were not with Joseph’s brothers when they made their plans and devised their plot.”

What we have presented is our analysis of the available evidence, and it may not be entirely accurate. Jews today do not accept these accounts, and say that the story of Joseph (AS) had been recorded for them from the beginning, and that the Torah as it exists today (the Old Testament) contains an extensive account of Joseph (AS). However, in light of the points noted above, it is quite likely that these sections of the Old Testament were joined together after the coming of the Seal of the Prophets, forming a more complete chain of accounts. God knows best.

One day, while travelling through the desert, the Prophet of Islam ـ صلّی الله علیه و آله ـ came upon a Bedouin living in a tent. The man recognised the Prophet and showed him great hospitality. As they were taking their leave, the Messenger of God ـ صلّی الله علیه و آله ـ said to him, “Whenever you need anything from us, we will ask God to grant it to you.” The man replied, “Ask God to give me a camel to carry my belongings when I travel, and a few sheep to graze here in the desert, so I can make use of their milk.” The Prophet asked God for these things, and God granted his request. Then the Messenger of God ـ صلّی الله علیه و آله ـ turned to his companions and said, “I wish this man had set his sights higher and asked us for the good of this world and the next, as the old woman of the Children of Israel did. I would have asked God for it, and He would have granted it to him.” The companions asked him to tell them the story of the old woman of the Children of Israel, and the Prophet related it to them in detail.

“Joseph (AS) had become so beloved by the people and held in such extraordinary esteem in Egypt that, after his death, they quarrelled over where to bury him. Each group wanted Joseph’s body buried in its own district, so that his tomb might bring blessings to their lives. In the end, they decided to bury Joseph’s body in the Nile, since everyone made use of the river’s waters as they flowed over his grave. In this way, all the people would receive the blessings of Joseph’s pure presence.” [7]

The heavens’ old father must endure such trials
Before the world’s mother gives birth to another child like you.

They buried Joseph’s body in the Nile, where it remained until Moses (AS) was about to lead the Children of Israel out of Egypt. At that time, the moon failed to appear for a while because of dense clouds, and the nights were very dark. The Children of Israel needed moonlight to travel from Egypt toward Syria; otherwise, they would lose their way. Moses (AS) was then told through revelation to take Joseph’s bones from his tomb so that Joseph’s final wish might be fulfilled and he could be buried in Palestine. If he did so, the moon would rise for them.
Moses ـ علیه السلام ـ asked who knew where Joseph’s grave was. He was told that an old woman knew. Moses ـ علیه السلام ـ ordered that she be brought to him. She had grown frail with age and had become blind. Moses ـ علیه السلام ـ said to her, “Do you know where Joseph’s grave is?” The old woman replied, “Yes.”

Moses ـ علیه السلام ـ said, “Then tell us where it is.”

She said, “I will not tell you unless you grant me four requests: first, heal my legs; second, restore my youth; third, give me back my sight; and fourth, take me with you to Paradise.”

This weighed heavily on Moses ـ علیه السلام ـ. Then God revealed to Moses ـ علیه السلام ـ that he should grant her requests. The old woman’s requests were fulfilled, and she then showed him the site of Joseph’s grave.[8]

Moses ـ علیه السلام ـ recovered Joseph’s body from the Nile, where it lay in a marble coffin, and carried it to Syria. Then the moon rose.[9] Joseph’s body was buried (according to the well-known account) beside the graves of his forefathers. Today, six farsakhs from Jerusalem, there is a place called Quds-e Khalil, where Joseph’s grave is said to be.[10]

[1] Masoumeh Begum Azarmi, *Stories of the Qur’an and the History of the Prophets*, Tahdhib Publications, 2nd ed., spring 1388, Qom, p. 199.

[2] Ibid., p. 200.

[3] Sayyid Muhammad Shirazi, *The World and the Jews*, Forugh-e Danesh printing, Amin Publications, p. 3.

[4] Ibid., p. 10.

[5] Another narration gives the interval between Prophet Jacob (AS) and Prophet Moses (AS) as approximately 400 years.

[6] Mika Waltari, *Sinuhe*, trans. Davud Nematollahi, 1st ed., 1391, Tehran, p. 500.

[7] This section is taken from the Tebyan website.

[8] *Bihar*, vol. 18, p. 325.

[9] *ʿIlal al-sharāʾiʿ*, p. 107; *Bihar*, vol. 13, p. 127.

[10] This section is adapted from the Andisheh Qom website.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022