Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2488 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

A Critique of Scholars’ Arguments for Permitting People to Seek Their Needs from the Imams

Primary reference: See the answer text 38 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2488

The esteemed Professor Dr. Hasan-Zadeh has presented a study on why scholars permit people to ask the Imams for help in meeting their needs. I am forwarding it to you; if you have any criticisms of these points, we would be grateful to benefit from your insight.

**Why scholars permit asking the Imams for help in meeting one’s needs:**

1. The first reason is partisanship. They feel that distancing themselves from this deviation would be seen as retreating from Shi‘i principles in the face of the Wahhabis.

2. Another reason is that, in discussions among Wahhabi scholars and our own scholars, asking someone other than God for help in meeting one’s needs has been divided into two categories: polytheistic and permissible. Any act that is not shirk has therefore been deemed permissible. For this reason, Shi‘i scholars have sought to establish that such an act is not shirk, and thus to prove that it is permissible. Yet there is a third category: an act may not be shirk and still be forbidden, as in the case of lying.

Thus, showing that a particular form of seeking intercession is not shirk does not establish that it is permissible. Its being forbidden must also be ruled out. That would require proof that the Lawgiver has authorized this form of seeking intercession—asking someone other than God for help in meeting one’s needs—but no such authorization has been established; rather, it has been prohibited.

3. Another reason is that our scholars have assumed that shirk necessarily involves an intention to act independently, and that if someone asking another than God for help in meeting a need does not intend that person to act independently, no shirk occurs. Yet, first, verse 3 of Surah al-Zumar makes clear that the pagan Arabs of the Hijaz did not intend their idols to act independently when they worshipped them, even though the Qur’an condemns their practice. If the intention to act independently were what made an act shirk, the Qur’an could have told the polytheists, “You may call upon God’s friends to bring you closer to God,” instead of prohibiting, without qualification, calling upon anyone other than God.

Second, in some verses and hadith, the act itself is described as shirk, with no intention to act independently being identified as the criterion. For example, in verses in Surah al-An‘am, making a sacrifice in the name of idols and at their feet is called shirk, without any discussion of the intention behind it.

4. Another reason is that our scholars have not regarded asking someone other than God for help in meeting one’s needs as supplication—and, by extension, as worship. This stems from their definition of supplication: they define it as “asking God.” But in Islam, God’s being the one invoked is a condition for supplication to be valid; Islam has not narrowed the meaning of the word itself. This brings us to the question of *haqiqa shar‘iyya*: did supplication acquire a new meaning in Islam, or did it retain its customary meaning—the meaning it has in the religious traditions—as invocation, with its validity and legitimacy restricted only by the condition that God be the one invoked?

Setting aside the many Qur’anic and hadith proofs that supplication retained its customary meaning in Islam as well—for example, the expression “دعاء الکافرین” in the Qur’an, and the fact that the Qur’an calls the pagans of the Hijaz’s invocation of idols supplication—establishing that supplication acquired a new technical meaning in Islamic law requires evidence; it cannot simply be assumed otherwise.

Therefore, once asking for help in meeting one’s needs is considered supplication and worship, the default ruling is that it is forbidden and impermissible, and its permissibility requires religious proof. But because our scholars have generally not regarded such requests as supplication, they have taken permissibility as the default and have felt no need for religious authorization.

5. Another reason is that our scholars have treated *tawassul* as a single, undifferentiated category, without dividing it into sound and unsound, or permissible and impermissible, forms. Yet tawassul in general is one question, while the permissibility of particular forms is another. Our scholars have not addressed this second question. This is because they have used the phrase from the noble verse, «و ابتغوا الیه الوسیله», as a stock argument for permitting every form of tawassul, overlooking the fact that tawassul is permissible within the framework of tawhid, not beyond it...

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Scholars have permitted people to seek their needs from the Imams on the basis of partisanship, a flawed distinction between shirk and what is permissible, the assumption that shirk necessarily involves attributing independent power, and the view that asking the Imams for help is not a form of supplication. Yet the idolaters of the Hijaz, too, did not intend to attribute independent power, and the outward form of their act was still deemed shirk. Seeking an intermediary’s help is permissible only within the bounds of tawhid.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Just as someone who devotes himself to worshipping God’s creatures becomes a polytheist, so too does a worshipper who worships only his Creator, yet whose worship rises no higher than the humility he shows toward created beings. His worship is no less than an act of polytheism, for he has lowered his Creator to the level of creation.

Worship can be attained only through knowledge. Worship without knowledge is no worship at all—indeed, it is worse, for without knowledge it is nothing but an insult, an act of insolence and contempt.

The secret of the prayer for this age is that it unravels the mystery of monotheism and polytheism.

اللهم عرفنی نفسک

O God, make Yourself known to me.

Whoever does not know God will see no difference between worshipping the One and Incomparable God and worshipping stone or wood, because their knowledge extends no further than stone and wood.

فإنک إن لم تعرفنی نفسک لم أعرف نبیک‏

For if You do not make Yourself known to me, I will not know Your Prophet.

This passage of the prayer reminds us of a very subtle point: God is the best known of all that is known.

اللهم عرفنی رسولک فإنک إن لم تعرفنی رسولک لم أعرف حجتک اللهم عرفنی حجتک فإنک إن لم تعرفنی حجتک ضللت عن دینی‏

In the prayer’s continuation, we ask God to grant us knowledge of His Messenger and His wali. If we do not attain a full understanding of the Messenger and those who succeed him, we will mistake the means for God. All errors in seeking help and having our needs met stem from a failure to know God rightly, and from failing to recognise the Messenger and the friends of God as they ought to be recognised—as signs of God.

Thus, in any relationship with created beings through which we seek to meet our needs, whatever form it may take, if we fail to recognise their place as servants and creatures—overpowered and sustained by God—we will fall into polytheism.

Knowing the proper place of a means guides us to use it rightly. The Creator made the means known to us so that, through it, we might worship and serve Him as we ought.

If the Creator has prescribed tawassul, then practising it correctly is a form of worship and servitude to Him.

Although the idol-worshippers of the Hijaz did not believe that their idols acted independently, in practice they worshipped them as objects of devotion. The polytheists of the Hijaz insisted on worshipping idols, as the noble verse makes abundantly clear. But someone who practises tawassul has no intention whatsoever of worshipping the means through which they seek nearness to God.

الزمر : 3 ألا لله الدین الخالص و الذین اتخذوا من دونه أولیاء ما نعبدهم إلا لیقربونا إلى الله زلفى‏ إن الله یحکم بینهم فی‏ ما هم فیه یختلفون إن الله لا یهدی من هو کاذب کفار

Behold, sincere devotion belongs to God alone. As for those who take protectors besides Him, they say, “We worship them only so that they may bring us nearer to God.” God will judge between them concerning that over which they differ. God does not guide anyone who is a liar and ungrateful.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022