Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2751 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

A Critique of the Theory of “Fundamental Problems in the Domain of Hadiths, Reports, and Historical Narrations”

Primary reference: See the answer text 36 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2751

Please critique the following theory:

**Fundamental problems concerning hadith, reports, and historical accounts:**

1. No historical report or account can be regarded as certain; all are probabilistic in meaning, since there is no scientific method for establishing their certainty.

2. The reliability of a report about an historical event depends on the number of witnesses who saw the event, not on the number of people who transmitted the report.

3. The principles of *ʿilm al-rijāl* can expose fabrications, interpolations, and lies, but there is generally no way to assess a narrator’s lapses, mistakes, ignorance, or lack of knowledge.

4. Qualities such as reason, accuracy, integrity, and being Muslim or Shiʿi may be necessary conditions for a narrator, but they are not sufficient ones. Moreover, there is no consistent standard for precisely measuring these qualities, or a narrator’s tastes and inclinations.

5. The reasons people lie are not limited to personal interests, ulterior motives, love, or hatred—things that the requirement of integrity might guard against.

6. A narrator’s being Muslim or a Twelver Shiʿi means that the principle of impartiality is not always observed in the transmission of reports.

7. Another fundamental problem with the transmission of reports and hadiths is that accounts of the historical and cultural circumstances surrounding a text and the utterance of a statement are almost always absent. This makes it seriously difficult to draw on them in the present day.

8. The number of reports considered *mutawātir*—whose reliability is particularly strongly affirmed—is very small. According to Shahīd al-Thānī in *al-Dirāya* and Shaykh Ḥasan ibn Zayn al-Dīn in *Maʿālim al-Dīn*, it amounts to no more than the fingers of one hand.

9. The fact that some jurists are lenient about the reliability of hadiths and reports, while others are very strict, shows that religious scholars do not follow a systematic, scientific method when examining historical reports.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The theory of fundamental problems in hadiths, reports, and historical narrations is critiqued on the grounds that sound reason and the discernment of the researcher establish the authenticity of reports, and that the science of rijal is a tool for discovering the truth. The multiplicity of narrators and the context in which hadith was issued also bear upon the reliability of narrations, and differences of opinion among researchers are no proof that the field lacks discipline.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

1. Sound reason and refined discernment establish whether reports are authentic or weak, and whether a matter is credible or dubious. This is not confined to the field of traditions: all disciplines, such as mathematics, physics, chemistry and medicine, are accepted as reliable in the same way. Otherwise, all knowledge and the sciences would collapse.

2. The number of transmitters reporting a historical event is one way to establish its authenticity. But a historian’s discernment in assessing the reliability of events is not limited to this method; it also draws on other, more specialised approaches. Consider, for example, how we learn about the Ice Age and dinosaurs: we infer them from particular signs that are not apparent to everyone. Hidden signs, or ones that may seem insignificant, can be valuable tools for a historically discerning scholar seeking to uncover the truth.

3. The science of rijāl examines chains of transmission, not the content of reports; it is a tool researchers use to uncover the truth. Just as a person’s blood sample can reveal many of their characteristics in a laboratory, a specialist in rijāl can identify individuals by examining their distinctive traits.

4. The necessary conditions for establishing reliability are a means to that end, but the ultimate aim is to ascertain reliability. A rational researcher draws on every available means of reaching the truth. No sensible researcher disregards necessary conditions because they are insufficient on their own, nor does a researcher confine their inquiry to those conditions.

5. Sound and reliable sources for discovering the truth do not reduce the causes of lying solely to self-interest, ulterior motives, affection or hostility; yet neither do they overlook these factors.

6. A transmitter’s being Muslim, Shiʿi and so on has a significant bearing on the classification of hadith, but hadith studies are not limited to this consideration.

7. The circumstances in which a hadith was uttered have always received attention from Shiʿi hadith scholars, and various works have been written on the subject.

8. Although mutawātir hadiths are few compared with solitary reports, even this small number affirms the fundamental principles of human belief. Moreover, while verbally mutawātir reports are rare, reports that are mutawātir in meaning are considerable.

9. Differences among researchers’ views do not show that historical reports lack rigorous standards. Rather, researchers follow different approaches to establishing the authenticity of historical reports. Those who practise excessive laxity, however, are not counted among genuine researchers.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022