The Relationship between Intellect and Ignorance (for reflection and discussion)
Assuming that the kinds of opposition are limited to those presented in Muzaffar’s logic, the following is a brief summary of my reflections on the hadith about the hosts of intellect and ignorance. I hope you will offer your critiques:
1. The opposition between the two is neither contradiction nor privation nor correlation; it is opposition between contraries.
2. Given the way they act and react upon one another, contraries also stand in a relationship of pairing. (Dialectical opposition.)
3. Intellect was created first. Therefore, what remains in the end and prevails in this contest of opposites is intellect.
4. If intellect had no opposite and counterpart, it would become static. Such eternal stillness and immobility belong only to the attributes of God Most High. And there is nothing in the world that does not have a counterpart.
5. According to the principle of dialectical opposition, ignorance was created from intellect itself. Likewise, the wife of Adam, peace be upon him, was created from his left rib as a symbolic representation of this same truth. It was at this point, at the beginning of the creation of intellect and ignorance, that the nature of intellect and the nature of ignorance became mingled in many respects. The light of believers and unbelievers became intermixed, and the Verse of Purification also alludes to the purification of the Imams from this very admixture.
6. Point 4 astonishes me and is open to question. Yet it follows from the arguments I have learned so far. It seems to me that the divine attributes differ from the Most Beautiful Names. The attributes belong to a level above the names (the difference lies in the observer’s point of view).
7. These reflections should be applied to the goodly tree and the evil tree in the Noble Quran.
I ask the respected scholars in this group to critique these points—especially their underlying assumptions—in light of the Quranic verses and hadiths.