Given the tragic events—earthquakes, fires and so on—that have occurred in our country over the past year, can we say that we are experiencing a divine punishment?
Are Recent Events in the Country a Divine Punishment?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The occurrence of tragic events in the country does not necessarily mean that they are a divine punishment. Although communities may deserve punishment because of sin and ingratitude, it is not for us to attribute these events directly to divine retribution. We should also be mindful of the economic, moral and social calamities we often overlook, for God’s power is infinite; if He were to punish us, no one would be able to escape.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterCertainly, given the prevalence of transgression, disobedience, ingratitude, denial, heedlessness, and the like, communities deserve every kind of punishment, calamity, and torment. Yet it is not for us to attribute recent events to divine punishment.
An important matter is being overlooked: our failure to notice the economic, moral, social, familial, cultural, scientific, public-health, and other earthquakes. What evil and satanic fault lines have been set in motion, adding ruin upon ruin, while we remain heedless of them!
In the view of those with expertise and discernment, if Almighty God wished to discipline His sinful servants, how many points on the Richter scale of His might would He reveal? Does God’s power have any limit?!
If the All-Powerful, All-Compelling God wished to punish servants tainted by the filth of sin with an earthquake, would anyone be able to escape? Could earthquake-resistant buildings withstand it?