The phrase «کل یوم عاشورا و کل ارض کربلا» is not a hadith, but it offers a subtle insight into the events of Ashura.
The spirit of Ashura has so completely taken hold of the very life of the universe’s space and time that it is impossible to separate it from the life of the universe!
An unparalleled event that holds sway over every time and place!
An Ashura without equal, like the sun, continually rising over the horizon of time and space, shedding new and wondrous light!
The secret of Ashura is that it is alive, and the God who is «الحی القیوم» bestows new life upon the universe through it!
The mystery of Ashura has yet to be revealed; the Imam of time and space is the interpreter of this great Husayni epic!
That every day should be Ashura and every land Karbala is a small matter for Imam Husayn’s artistry. All the heavens are Husayniyahs for His Eminence Husayn! Karbala knows neither earth nor sky, and the realm of Ashura extends beyond ناسوت و ملکوت و جبروت و لاهوت!
⏬⏬⏬⏬⏬↖ ↖ ↖
⁉ ⁉ But one question⁉ ⁉: Can we use such beautiful words and phrases without the permission of the Infallible Imams—even when something contrary has been related from them that might call our words into question? Are we not followers of the Imams, their words and their example?⁉
Of course, as I have said, there is no room for doubt about the master’s points; they are entirely correct. But the issue is using the exact phrase «کل یوم عاشورا و کل ارض کربلا», which is in complete contradiction to «لایوم کیومک یا ابا عبدالله».
And if we accept this phrase, we might as well go on to say that everyone is Imam Husayn, and leave it at that—just like those gentlemen who loudly proclaim انا الحق.⁉ ⁉
With thanks to our dear master.