Can we say that Paradise and Hell exist here in this world, at every moment, and are continually coming to pass? Or is it correct to understand them as separate realms that will become real after this world, on the Day of Resurrection? (I’m not taking the realm of the barzakh into account.)
Please forgive me, teacher. It seems all my questions come down to the same point and have the same answer.
Do Paradise and Hell Exist in This World?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Paradise and Hell in their full reality lie beyond the capacity of this world: Paradise is as vast as the heavens and the earth, while Hell encompasses the unbelievers. Yet their effects and manifestations can be perceived, in due measure, in this world and in the barzakh. This world may also be regarded as a lesser resurrection.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThis world cannot contain the highest Paradise, for the whole of the heavens and the earth are swallowed up within the promised Paradise!
آلعمران : 133 و سارعوا إلى مغفره من ربکم و جنه عرضها السماوات و الأرض أعدت للمتقین
“Hasten toward forgiveness from your Lord and a Garden as vast as the heavens and the earth, prepared for the God-conscious.”
Hell, too, encompasses the disbelievers, whether they are in this world or their souls are in the intermediate realm—even if its effects have not yet become apparent in them!
التوبه : 49 و منهم من یقول ائذن لی و لا تفتنی ألا فی الفتنه سقطوا و إن جهنم لمحیطه بالکافرین
“Some of them say, ‘Give us leave, and do not expose us to temptation!’ Surely, they have already fallen into temptation, and Hell encompasses the disbelievers!”
العنکبوت : 54 یستعجلونک بالعذاب و إن جهنم لمحیطه بالکافرین
“They demand that you hasten the punishment, while Hell encompasses the disbelievers!”
The effects of Hell upon its inhabitants and of Paradise upon its inhabitants will vary in this world according to their station. This world may be regarded as the lesser resurrection, the intermediate realm as the middle resurrection, and the Hereafter as the greater resurrection!
The grave, for example, is either a garden from among the gardens of Paradise or a pit from among the pits of Hell!
، و قال علی بن الحسین ع إن القبر روضه من ریاض الجنه أو حفره من حفر النیران
تفسیر القمی، ج2، ص: 94