Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 1898 20 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Did They Know How Events Would End at Laylat al-Mabit and Karbala?

Primary reference: See the answer text 64 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-1898

All the examples cited themselves require careful consideration and are open to discussion. In each case, one may also argue that the disastrous outcome was not known in advance:

1. Regarding Laylat al-Mabīt, it should be said:

Although Imam Ali slept in the Prophet’s bed intending to sacrifice his life, this was, first, one of the requirements of the Prophet’s emigration. Second, it was not certain that the affair would necessarily result in Ali’s death, since the polytheists intended to kill the Prophet, not someone else.

2. The episode of Imam Husayn requires a detailed discussion. According to the analysis presented in the book *Shahid-e Javid*, which is based on the views of major Shi‘i scholars such as Sharif al-Murtada and Shaykh al-Tusi, the Imam did not already know how the matter would turn out.

Please state your view.

# Response 1900, first page

The master, Amir al-Mu'minin (AS), was prepared for martyrdom on Laylat al-Mabīt!

The account of Laylat al-Mabīt as narrated by Amir al-Mu'minin (AS) in a conversation with a Jewish man!

“As for the second, O Jewish brother, Quraysh were constantly devising plans and contriving schemes to kill the Messenger of God, until, at the end, they gathered for this purpose on the Day of the House, at a place called Dar al-Nadwa. The accursed Satan was also present in the form of a one-eyed man from the tribe of Thaqif (al-Mughira ibn Shu‘ba). They consulted one another about the matter and collectively reached the conclusion that a man should be selected from each clan of Quraysh. Each of them would take up his sword and go to the Prophet while he was asleep in his bed, striking him together with their swords as though a single man had struck him, and killing him. Once they had killed him, Quraysh would prevent his relatives from taking action and would not surrender the killers; thus, his blood would go unavenged.

Then Gabriel descended upon the Prophet and informed him of this plot. He told him the night on which they intended to carry it out and the hour at which they would come to his bed, and instructed him to leave the house at that time and make his way to the cave. The Messenger of God informed me of this and ordered me to sleep in his bed and shield him with my life. I hastened to obey him, gladly accepting the prospect of being killed in his place. He departed, and I lay down in his bed. The men of Quraysh came, convinced that the Prophet would be killed. When I found myself face-to-face with them in the house where I was staying, I rose with my sword and drove them away from me in a manner known to God and to the people.”

Then Ali (AS) turned to his companions and said, “Was it not so?” They replied, “Yes, O Amir al-Mu'minin!”

*Al-Khisal*, translated by Ja‘fari, vol. 2, p. 48

أمیر المؤمنین فقال ع و أما الثانیه یا أخا الیهود فإن قریشا لم تزل تخیل الآراء و تعمل الحیل فی قتل النبی ص حتى کان آخر ما اجتمعت فی ذلک یوم الدار دار الندوه و إبلیس الملعون حاضر فی صوره أعور ثقیف «3» فلم تزل تضرب أمرها ظهر البطن حتى اجتمعت آراؤها على أن ینتدب من کل فخذ من قریش رجل ثم یأخذ کل رجل منهم سیفه ثم یأتی النبی ص و هو نائم على فراشه فیضربونه [فیضربوه‏] جمیعا بأسیافهم ضربه رجل واحد
فیقتلوه و إذا قتلوه منعت قریش رجالها و لم تسلمها فیمضی دمه هدرا فهبط جبرئیل ع على النبی ص فأنبأه بذلک و أخبره باللیله التی یجتمعون فیها و الساعه التی یأتون فراشه فیها و أمره بالخروج فی الوقت الذی خرج فیه إلى الغار فأخبرنی رسول الله ص بالخبر و أمرنی أن أضطجع فی مضجعه و أقیه بنفسی فأسرعت إلى ذلک مطیعا له مسرورا لنفسی بأن أقتل دونه فمضى ع لوجهه و اضطجعت فی مضجعه و أقبلت رجالات قریش موقنه فی أنفسها أن تقتل النبی ص فلما استوى بی و بهم البیت الذی أنا فیه ناهضتهم بسیفی فدفعتهم عن نفسی بما قد علمه الله و الناس ثم أقبل ع على أصحابه فقال أ لیس کذلک قالوا بلى یا أمیر المؤمنین‏

*Al-Khisal*, vol. 2, p. 366

Yes, the master embraced martyrdom with love; he passionately longed for martyrdom!

فأسرعت إلى ذلک مطیعا له مسرورا لنفسی بأن أقتل دونه فمضى ع لوجهه

To be continued...

# Response 1900, second page

God, the “Most Truthful of the Truthful,” bears witness to Amir al-Mu’minin’s yearning for martyrdom. Ali had sold his soul to his Beloved!

البقره : 207 و من الناس من یشری نفسه ابتغاء مرضات الله و الله رؤف بالعباد

Some people sell their souls in pursuit of God’s pleasure, and God is compassionate toward His servants.

Narrations concerning the occasion of the revelation of this noble verse bear eloquent, mass-transmitted witness to this truth. I shall relate just one of them.

On the night when al-Mustafa صلى الله علیه و آله intended to migrate from Mecca to Medina and concealed himself in the Cave of Thawr, Ali ibn Abi Talib عليه السلام lay in the Prophet’s bed to protect the life of God’s Messenger and his family. The Almighty God said to Gabriel and Michael: “I have made you two brothers, and I shall prolong the life of one of you beyond that of the other. Let one of you choose the longer life.” Yet both of them chose the longer life, and each wanted it for himself. God, the Most Glorious, said:

“Now look at the selflessness and self-sacrifice of Ali ibn Abi Talib عليه السلام, and know that I have also established brotherhood between the Prophet صلى الله علیه و آله and Ali عليه السلام. Ali عليه السلام is lying in the bed of his brother, al-Mustafa صلى الله علیه و آله.

Both of you, descend to earth and protect him from his enemies.” Gabriel and Michael entered the house of the Messenger of God صلى الله علیه و آله. Gabriel stood at Ali’s head, and Michael at his feet, while Gabriel called out:

بخ بخ یا بن ابى طالب!

“O son of Abu Talib, blessed are you! Through your self-sacrifice, Almighty God boasts of you before the angels of the heavens.” Then the verse و من الناس من یشری نفسه ابتغاء مرضات الله و الله رؤف بالعباد was revealed that night in honour of Ali’s selflessness.

فحدثنا رسول الله و نحن معه بقباء، عما أرادت قریش من المکر به و مبیت علی (علیه السلام) على فراشه، قال: أوحى الله (عز و جل) إلى جبرئیل و میکائیل (علیهما السلام) أنی قد آخیت بینکما و جعلت عمر أحدکما أطول من عمر صاحبه فأیکما یؤثر أخاه فکلاهما کرها الموت، فأوحى الله إلیهما: عبدی ألا کنتما مثل ولیی علی بن أبی طالب، آخیت بینه و بین نبیی فآثره بالحیاه على نفسه، ثم ظل- أو قال: رقد- على فراشه یفدیه بمهجته، اهبطا إلى الأرض کلاکما فاحفظاه من عدوه، فهبط جبرئیل فجلس عند رأسه، و میکائیل عند رجلیه، و جعل جبرئیل یقول: بخ بخ من مثلک یا ابن أبی طالب و الله (عز و جل) یباهی بک الملائکه! قال: فأنزل الله (عز و جل) فی علی (علیه السلام): «و من الناس من یشری نفسه ابتغاء مرضات الله و الله رؤف بالعباد»

الأمالی (للطوسی)، النص، ص: 469

May my soul be sacrificed for you, O master, O Amir al-Mu’minin. May God’s blessings and peace be upon you!

To be continued...

#Reply 1900, third page

The journey of martyrdom of Imam Husayn, peace be upon him, was the foundation for the establishment of Islamic government!

Even if the analyses of the author of *The Everlasting Martyr* accord with the views of other eminent scholars, this is not evidence that they are based on sound sources, for there are a thousand and one reasons—or more—why His Eminence was certain of his own martyrdom.

The author of *The Everlasting Martyr* maintains that His Eminence rose up with the aim of establishing an Islamic government...

Yet if we look at the matter through a Husayni lens, we will understand that the sovereignty of divine law is the purpose and aspiration of every true prophet and divinely appointed guide. In truth, through his martyrdom, His Eminence laid the spiritual foundations for the establishment of an Islamic government, and that objective was ultimately realised. For we know that had this uprising not taken place, nothing of the Qur'an or the Ahl al-Bayt would have remained. There would have been no trace of the rightful successors or the friends of God. The sacred existence of Imam al-Mahdi, peace be upon him, is the jewel and legacy of Imam Husayn's uprising, and the son of the Master of Martyrs, peace be upon him, will bring a wholly and perfectly Islamic government into being upon the earth. Thus, through his martyrdom, His Eminence succeeded in realising his own objective.

Through his uprising, His Eminence became the ruler of hearts and of history. This is the inward meaning of government: in reality, he conquered hearts and made history his own, causing the light of religious government to shine forever upon the earth.

The Journey of Martyrdom

It is related that when Imam Husayn, peace be upon him, was preparing to depart for Iraq, he rose and delivered a sermon, saying:

Praise belongs to God; what He wills comes to pass, and there is no power or strength except through God. May God bless His noble Messenger, and may God's peace be upon him. Death has been inscribed for the children of Adam as a necklace is destined for the neck of a young woman. My longing and yearning to meet my forebears—my grandfather, father, mother and brother—is like Jacob's longing for Joseph. A place of death has been chosen for me, and I must go there. It is as though I can see the desert wolves tearing my limbs apart between Nawawis «1» and Karbala. How many bellies will be filled with me, and how many sacks will be stuffed with me? There is no escape from the day decreed by the pen. We, the Ahl al-Bayt, regard God's pleasure as our own pleasure, and we are patient in the face of His tribulation; He will grant us the reward of the patient. No part of the flesh of God's Messenger, peace be upon him, will be separated from him without being gathered to him in the Holy Enclosure. His eyes will be gladdened by them, and through them His promise will be fulfilled. Whoever is ready to offer his blood for our sake and has prepared himself to meet God should set out with us, for we shall depart tomorrow morning, God willing.

*Luhuf / translated by Mir Abu Talibi, p. 111*

و روی أنه ع لما عزم على الخروج إلى العراق قام خطیبا فقال الحمد لله ما شاء الله و لا قوه إلا بالله و صلى الله على رسوله خط الموت‏ على ولد آدم مخط القلاده على جید الفتاه و ما أولهنی إلى أسلافی اشتیاق یعقوب إلى یوسف و خیر لی مصرع أنا لاقیه کأنی بأوصالی تتقطعها عسلان الفلوات بین النواویس و کربلاء فیملأن منی أکراشا جوفا و أجربه سغبا لا محیص عن یوم خط بالقلم رضى الله رضانا أهل البیت نصبر على بلائه و یوفینا أجر الصابرین لن تشذ عن رسول الله ص لحمته و هی مجموعه له فی حظیره القدس تقر بهم عینه و ینجز بهم وعده من کان باذلا فینا مهجته و موطنا على لقاء الله نفسه فلیرحل معنا فإننی راحل مصبحا إن شاء الله تعالى‏
اللهوف على قتلى الطفوف / ترجمه فهرى، النص، ص: 61

To be continued...

#Response 1900, page four

The awareness possessed by the Master of the Martyrs, peace be upon him, of this matter was neither extraordinary nor unlikely for His Eminence; rather, his lofty station had soared beyond the Lote Tree of the Utmost Boundary!

From Husayn ibn Ali to the Banu Hashim: “Whoever among you joins me will be martyred, and whoever does not accompany me will not attain victory.”

عن أبی عبد الله علیه السلام ... إن الحسین لما فصل متوجها دعا بقرطاس و کتب من الحسین بن علی إلى بنی هاشم أما بعد فإنه من ألحق [لحق‏] بی منکم استشهد معی و من تخلف لم یبلغ الفتح و السلام..
بصائر الدرجات فی فضائل آل محمد صلى الله علیهم، ج‏1، ص: 481

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

At Laylat al-Mabit, the polytheists intended to kill the Prophet, but it was not certain that Ali (AS) would be martyred; rather, this was one of the necessary consequences of the Prophet’s migration. In examining the events of Karbala, the views of Shia scholars such as Sayyid al-Murtada and Shaykh al-Tusi indicate that the Imam did not know how events would turn out—a fact regarded as a virtue in his case.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

First Page

Mawla Amir al-Mu'minin (AS) was prepared for martyrdom on Laylat al-Mabit!

The event of Laylat al-Mabit, as related by Mawla Amir al-Mu'minin (AS) in conversation with a Jewish man!

“As for the second, O Jewish brother, Quraysh were constantly devising plans and schemes to kill the Messenger of God. Finally, on the Day of the House, they gathered at a place called Dar al-Nadwa. The accursed Satan was also present in the form of a one-eyed man from the tribe of Thaqif (al-Mughira ibn Shu'ba). They deliberated over the matter and collectively concluded that a man should be chosen from each clan of Quraysh. Each of them would take up his sword and go to the Prophet while he was asleep in his bed, striking him with their swords in such a way that it would appear as though a single man had struck him, and thus kill him. Once they had killed him, Quraysh would protect these men and refuse to hand them over, and his blood would go unavenged. Then Gabriel descended upon the Prophet and informed him of this plot. He told him the night on which they intended to carry it out and the hour at which they would come to his bed, and instructed him to leave the house at that time and make his way to the cave. The Messenger of God informed me of this and commanded me to sleep in his bed and shield him with my life. I hastened to carry out this command, gladly offering myself to be killed in his place. He departed, and I lay down in his bed. The men of Quraysh came, convinced that the Prophet would be killed. When I and they came face to face in that house, I rose with my sword and drove them away from myself in a manner known to God and the people.” Then Ali (AS) turned to his companions and said, “Was it not so?” They replied, “Yes, O Commander of the Faithful!”

Al-Khisal / translated by Ja'fari, vol. 2, p. 48

“As for the second, O Jewish brother, Quraysh never ceased devising opinions and employing stratagems to kill the Prophet until, at last, they gathered for that purpose on the Day of the House, at Dar al-Nadwa. The accursed Iblis was present in the form of a one-eyed man from Thaqif. They continued to turn the matter over from every angle until they reached a consensus that a man should be selected from each clan of Quraysh. Each man would then take up his sword and approach the Prophet while he was asleep in his bed, striking him all together with their swords as though a single man had struck him,

killing him. Once they had killed him, Quraysh would protect their men and refuse to surrender them, so his blood would go unavenged. Then Gabriel (AS) descended upon the Prophet and informed him of this. He told him the night on which they would gather and the hour at which they would come to his bed, and commanded him to leave at the same time he departed for the cave. The Messenger of God informed me of this and ordered me to lie in his place and protect him with my life. I hastened to obey him, rejoicing that I might be killed in his place. He went on his way, and I lay down in his bed. The men of Quraysh came, inwardly certain that they would kill the Prophet. When I and they stood facing one another in the house where I was, I confronted them with my sword and drove them away from myself in a manner known to God and the people.” Then he turned to his companions and said, “Was it not so?” They replied, “Yes, O Commander of the Faithful.”

Al-Khisal, vol. 2, p. 366

Yes, Mawla had a passionate love for martyrdom!

“I hastened to obey him, rejoicing that I might be killed in his place. He went on his way…”

To be continued...

#Response 1900, Second Page

God, the “Most Truthful of the Truthful,” bears witness to the Commander of the Faithful’s longing for martyrdom. Ali had sold his soul to his Beloved!

البقره : 207 و من الناس من یشری نفسه ابتغاء مرضات الله و الله رؤف بالعباد

Some people sell their souls in pursuit of God’s pleasure, and God is Most Kind to His servants.

Narrations concerning the occasion of the revelation of this noble verse: reports transmitted through successive chains bear eloquent witness to this fact. I will relate only one of them.

On the night when Mustafa صلى الله علیه و آله intended to emigrate from Mecca to Medina and hid in the Cave of Thawr, Ali ibn Abi Talib عليه السلام lay in the Prophet’s bed to protect the life of God’s Messenger and his family. Almighty God said to Gabriel and Michael: “I shall establish brotherhood between the two of you, and I shall grant one of you a longer life than the other. Let one of you choose the longer life.” Yet both chose the longer life, and each wanted it for himself. God, the Most Glorious, said:

“Now look at the self-sacrifice and renunciation of Ali ibn Abi Talib عليه السلام, and know that I have also established brotherhood between the Prophet صلى الله علیه و آله and Ali عليه السلام. Ali عليه السلام is lying in the bed of his brother, Mustafa صلى الله علیه و آله.

Both of you descend to earth and protect him from his enemies.” Gabriel and Michael entered the house of the Messenger of God صلى الله علیه و آله. Gabriel stood above Ali عليه السلام’s head, while Michael stood at his feet, and Gabriel called out:

بخ بخ یا بن ابى طالب!

“O son of Abu Talib, congratulations! Almighty God boasts of your self-sacrifice before the angels of the heavens.” Then the verse و من الناس من یشری نفسه ابتغاء مرضات الله و الله رؤف بالعباد was revealed that night in honour of Ali عليه السلام’s self-sacrifice.

: فحدثنا رسول الله و نحن معه بقباء، عما أرادت قریش من المکر به و مبیت علی (علیه السلام) على فراشه، قال: أوحى الله (عز و جل) إلى جبرئیل و میکائیل (علیهما السلام) أنی قد آخیت بینکما و جعلت عمر أحدکما أطول من عمر صاحبه فأیکما یؤثر أخاه فکلاهما کرها الموت، فأوحى الله إلیهما: عبدی ألا کنتما مثل ولیی علی بن أبی طالب، آخیت بینه و بین نبیی فآثره بالحیاه على نفسه، ثم ظل- أو قال: رقد- على فراشه یفدیه بمهجته، اهبطا إلى الأرض کلاکما فاحفظاه من عدوه، فهبط جبرئیل فجلس عند رأسه، و میکائیل عند رجلیه، و جعل جبرئیل یقول: بخ بخ من مثلک یا ابن أبی طالب و الله (عز و جل) یباهی بک الملائکه! قال: فأنزل الله (عز و جل) فی علی (علیه السلام): «و من الناس من یشری نفسه ابتغاء مرضات الله و الله رؤف بالعباد»

Al-Amali (by al-Tusi), text, p. 469

جان عالم فدایت یا مولا یا امیر المومنین صلوات الله و سلامه علیک!

May the soul of the world be sacrificed for you, O Master, O Commander of the Faithful. May God’s blessings and peace be upon you!

To be continued...

#پاسخ1900 برگ سوم

The journey to martyrdom of Imam Husayn, peace be upon him, was the foundation for the establishment of an Islamic government!

Although the analyses presented by the author of *The Immortal Martyr* may accord with the views of other eminent scholars, this does not prove that they are supported by evidence. There are a thousand and one reasons—and more—to show that the Imam was certain of his own martyrdom.

The author of *The Immortal Martyr* holds that the Imam rose with the aim of establishing an Islamic government...

Yet if we examine the matter through a Husayn-centered perspective, we will understand that the sovereignty of divine law is the aspiration and ultimate purpose of every true messenger and divinely appointed guide. In reality, through his martyrdom, the Imam laid the spiritual foundations for the establishment of an Islamic government, and that aim was eventually realised. For we know that had this uprising not taken place, nothing of the Qur'an or the Household of the Prophet would have remained. There would have been no trace of the true successors or the friends of God. The sacred existence of Imam al-Mahdi, peace be upon him, is the jewel and legacy of Imam Husayn's uprising, and the son of the Master of Martyrs will fully establish a genuinely Islamic government upon the earth. Thus, through his martyrdom, the Imam succeeded in achieving his purpose.

Through his uprising, the Imam became the ruler of hearts and of history. This is the inner meaning of government: the Imam truly conquered hearts, made history his own, and caused the light of religious governance to shine upon the earth forever.

**The Journey to Martyrdom**

It is related that when Imam Husayn, peace be upon him, was setting out towards Iraq, he rose and delivered a sermon, saying:

ستایش مر خداى راست، و مشیت از آن او، و قوت و نیرویى جز به خدا نباشد (قوت هم ازوست) و درود خدا به رسول مکرم او (و آلش) و سلام خدا بر او باد، آرایش مرگ بر فرزند آدم چون آرایش گردنبند بر گردن دوشیزگان است، گرایش و اشتیاقم به زیارت اسلافم (جد و پدر و مادر و برادرم) چون اشتیاق یعقوب به یوسف است، و برایم قتلگاهى گزیده شد که من بدان جایم باید رفت، گوئیا مى‏نگرم که گرگهاى بیابان بند بند مفاصلم را از هم جدا کنند در میان نواویس «1» و کربلاء، چه شکمها از من پر، و چه انبانها که از من آکنده گردد، گریزى از آنچه بر قلم تقدیر رفته نیست، ما- اهل البیت- خشنودى خدا را خرسندى خود دانسته، بر بلایش صابریم، و او اجر صابران را به ما مى‏دهد، هیچ گوشت پیامبر (پاره تن) او از وى جدا نگردد مگر آن که در حضیره القدس نزدش گرد آید، چشمش بدانها روشن گردیده و بدانها وعده‏اش انجاز گردد، هر کس که در راه ما خون نثار و بذل مى‏کند، و لقاى خدا را توطین نفس خویش مى‏نماید، پس آماده کوچیدن با ما باشد، چه ما ان شاء الله بامداد فردا حرکت مى‏کنیم.

*Luhuf / translated by Mir Abu Talibi, p. 111*

و روی أنه ع لما عزم على الخروج إلى العراق قام خطیبا فقال الحمد لله ما شاء الله و لا قوه إلا بالله و صلى الله على رسوله خط الموت‏ على ولد آدم مخط القلاده على جید الفتاه و ما أولهنی إلى أسلافی اشتیاق یعقوب إلى یوسف و خیر لی مصرع أنا لاقیه کأنی بأوصالی تتقطعها عسلان الفلوات بین النواویس و کربلاء فیملأن منی أکراشا جوفا و أجربه سغبا لا محیص عن یوم خط بالقلم رضى الله رضانا أهل البیت نصبر على بلائه و یوفینا أجر الصابرین لن تشذ عن رسول الله ص لحمته و هی مجموعه له فی حظیره القدس تقر بهم عینه و ینجز بهم وعده من کان باذلا فینا مهجته و موطنا على لقاء الله نفسه فلیرحل معنا فإننی راحل مصبحا إن شاء الله تعالى‏

*Allahuf 'ala qatla al-Tufuf / translated by Fahri, text, p. 61*

To be continued...

#Response 1900, fourth page

The awareness possessed by the Master of Martyrs, peace be upon him, was neither extraordinary nor improbable for him; rather, his lofty stations had soared beyond the Lote Tree of the Farthest Boundary!

From Husayn ibn Ali to the Banu Hashim: “Whoever among you joins me will be martyred, and whoever does not accompany me will not attain victory.”

عن أبی عبد الله علیه السلام ... إن الحسین لما فصل متوجها دعا بقرطاس و کتب من الحسین بن علی إلى بنی هاشم أما بعد فإنه من ألحق [لحق‏] بی منکم استشهد معی و من تخلف لم یبلغ الفتح و السلام..

*Basa'ir al-Darajat fi Fada'il Al Muhammad صلى الله علیهم، vol. 1, p. 481*

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022