Teacher, what does the station of fanāʾ fi Allāh, as discussed by the mystics, mean? Is it the same as the idea of waḥdat al-wujūd? Thank you.
Is Annihilation in God’s Essence a Valid Concept?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The annihilation of created beings in God’s Essence is indefensible and conflicts with divine unity. To set a created being against the Essence of the Real is plainly mistaken, since this conflicts with the oneness of the Essence. Comparing creation with the Creator is unbelief, and the Creator’s existence cannot be compared with the existence of creation. Perhaps “annihilation in the Essence” can be understood as a created being’s awareness of its own dependence.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe Divine Essence is exalted above anything that can be designated by “in.”
The Divine Essence cannot, in any respect whatsoever—whether in terms of the realm of malakūt, jabarūt, lāhūt, or anything else—serve as a container. For the Essence to contain something, or for something to be annihilated or dissolved within the Essence, would indicate that the Essence is limited and subject to that which it contains. This claim cannot be defended through any interpretation or exegesis.
The Divine Essence is not compared with anything. When we say هو الباقي, we are in fact acknowledging that everything, when measured against the Divine Essence, is truly perishing. Note that this concerns comparison with the Divine Essence, not comparison between one created thing and another.
As was mentioned earlier in our discussions, if there is any annihilation, it is annihilation in the divine Names of Beauty, not in the Divine Essence.
It should also be stressed that the Divine Essence is not compared even with His Beautiful Names. He has absolutely no likeness or counterpart.
و من أشار إلیه فقد حده و من حده فقد عده و من قال فیم فقد ضمنه و من قال علام فقد أخلى منه