Greetings, Professor. Would you kindly explain the circumstances surrounding Lady Fatima’s martyrdom? Did Imam Ali know in advance what would happen and remain silent? It seems out of character for him to do nothing in the face of an attack on Lady Fatima. Or did the Prophet instruct him to remain silent in response to Umar’s actions and the attack on her home? That, too, seems unreasonable. I have also seen a video of Sheikh Fazlollah from which one might infer, based on his remarks, that no attack on her home took place and that her death was caused by other circumstances. If so, would that not amount to denying her martyrdom? Please explain.
The truth about Lady Fatima’s (SA) martyrdom and Imam Ali’s (AS) silence?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Imam Ali’s (AS) silence in the face of the events following the Prophet’s (PBUH) passing and the martyrdom of Lady Fatima (SA) stemmed from his complete submission to God’s decree and his understanding that preserving the faith was essential—not from indifference. The attack on her home and her martyrdom are established facts and should not be called into question on the basis of simplistic arguments.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterFirst Page
I will answer the question with several questions whose answers are self-evident.
Why, on the night of the Hijra, after the council of Dār al-Nadwa, did Ḥaḍrat ʿAlī علیه السلام sleep in the bed of the Messenger of Allah صلی الله و علیه و آله و سلم? And why did the Prophet knowingly leave the life of a young man exposed to the swords of the executioners? Is it not clear that something exalted lay behind this event and this decision, and that both the Messenger and the Walī freely chose this course, with complete knowledge and awareness, so that the light of guidance might reach its perfection? And did not Mawlā ʿAlī عاشقانه embrace martyrdom in order to preserve the life of the Prophet of God?
Why did Imām Ḥusayn علیه السلام take his family with him to Karbalā—from ʿAlī Akbar to the young Ruqayya, ʿAlī Asghar and Zaynab al-Kubrā علیهم السلام? Is it not the case that all of them were the pure, clear oil of the lamp of guidance, and that unless they were consumed, the world of existence could not take on the beautiful colour of guidance? It is therefore clear why the Imām of the Martyrs personally sent ʿAlī Akbar, Qāsim and others علیهم السلام into the field of martyrdom. Is becoming a sacrifice for the religion of God really a matter of little consequence?
Was Ḥaḍrat ʿAlī علیه السلام not the very truth of the religion of God?! Was Mawlā not the firm pillar of the Two Weighty Things?! Was wilayah not the starting point of prophethood and imamate?! Was it not the case that if the events of Saqīfa, following the political coup, had ended in religious negligence, it would have been regarded as the end of the religion? The awakening of the heedless community required an epic of Fāṭima. Both ʿAlī علیه السلام and Fāṭima al-Zahrā سلام الله علیها knew this. The home of ʿAlī علیه السلام became the battlefield for the defence of religion.
An emotional, childish approach, immature arguments, and questioning the martyrdom of the Lady and the mother of the martyrs indicate nothing other than the immaturity of reasoned understanding.
Let us bear in mind that ʿAlī Asghar, held in the arms of his father, the embodiment of love and tenderness, was struck in the chest by the arrow of the accursed Ḥarmala—and that Fāṭima’s chest, within the household of ʿAlī, stood beside the Conqueror of Khaybar...
To be continued...
#Response 1898, Second Page
Awareness of the unseen, by God’s permission, concerns matters that are certain to occur—that is, events destined inevitably to take place. Therefore, anything open to intervention or alteration does not fall within the sphere of knowledge of the unseen. Thus, Mawlā was aware through unseen knowledge of the event that would occur on the night when the door was set alight and the attack was made from behind it against the Lady Zahrā سلام الله علیها. Any intervention in such an event was therefore meaningless. Despite knowing what was taking place, Mawlā’s conduct remained natural, as though he had no knowledge of it. This is the conduct of a person wholly surrendered to the divine decree—the very conduct he displayed on the night of his martyrdom in dealing with the accursed Ibn Muljam.
The absence of a precise account of what occurred inside the house of wilayah is not evidence of Mawlā’s indifference. Events certainly took place that were not recorded, and Amīr al-Muʾminīn علیه السلام fulfilled to the utmost his duty and obligation to protect Lady Zahrā سلام الله علیها.
If we carefully investigate the event of the burning of the door of ʿAlī علیه السلام, we will discover that the house of Mawlā and its surroundings were no different from a fierce battlefield; indeed, the circumstances were even more severe. Intoxicated men, whose desire for power had robbed them of their reason, religion and loyalty, carried out calculated and indiscriminate attacks. Careful examination makes this clear.
From one perspective, it becomes apparent that the companions of Saqīfa intended to take the lives of the entire household of wilayah. We must not underestimate the matter.
Fāṭima’s defence is the most beautiful defence in the history of existence, for the ocean of prophethood rose to defend the ocean of knowledge. The blessed martyrdom of that noble Lady was the sealed certificate bearing the result of Fāṭimī excellence in defence.
We must not view the events surrounding the martyrdom of Lady Zahrā سلام الله علیها through a narrow lens. The same person who, out of love for God, fasted for three days together with her blessed family and fed the needy, the orphan and the captive, thereby attaining the distinction of the verse of feeding, also conducted her blessed defence according to a sublime plan and with profound purpose.
The discussion of “trading” and making a transaction with God entails a divine object of exchange.
What was offered in exchange for the life of the Most Pure Zahrā, the Lady of all the women of the worlds? What an immense transaction took place! The sacrifice of the chaste Zahrā—the queen of beauty and purity—saved the earth from the danger of destruction through polytheism and unbelief.
To be continued...
#Response 1898, Third Page
The Event of the Burning of the Door of ʿAlī علیه السلام According to Sunni Sources
عن سلمه بن عبد الرحمن قال لما جلس أبو بکر على المنبر کان علی ع و الزبیر و ناس من بنی هاشم فی بیت فاطمه فجاء عمر إلیهم فقال و الذی نفسی بیده لتخرجن إلى البیعه أو لأحرقن البیت علیکم فخرج الزبیر مصلتا سیفه فاعتنقه رجل من الأنصار و زیاد بن لبید فبدر السیف فصاح به أبو بکر و هو على المنبر اضرب به الحجر فدق به قال أبو عمرو بن حماس فلقد رأیت الحجر فیه تلک الضربه و یقال هذه ضربه سیف الزبیر ثم قال أبو بکر دعوهم فسیأتی الله بهم قال فخرجوا إلیه بعد ذلک فبایعوه
. قال أبو بکر و قد روی فی روایه أخرى أن سعد بن أبی وقاص کان معهم فی بیت فاطمه ع و المقداد بن الأسود أیضا و أنهم اجتمعوا على أن یبایعوا علیا ع فأتاهم عمر لیحرق علیهم البیت فخرج إلیه الزبیر بالسیف و خرجت فاطمه ع تبکی و تصیح فنهنهت من الناس و قالوا لیس عندنا معصیه و لا خلاف فی خیر اجتمع علیه الناس و إنما اجتمعنا لنؤلف القرآن فی مصحف واحد ثم بایعوا أبا بکر فاستمر الأمر و اطمأن الناس
شرح نهج البلاغه لابن أبی الحدید، ج2، ص: 56
The account of Fatima’s being struck and her miscarriage of Muhsin was not related solely by Shiite transmitters; a number of Sunni scholars also explicitly recorded it. It was the Umayyad and Abbasid political establishment that tried, in vain, to conceal these facts—like someone trying to hide the sun with a sieve.
Al-Shahrastani writes in *al-Milal wa-l-Nihal* (vol. 1, p. 59), in his biography of al-Nazzam:
“He said: ‘Umar struck Fatima’s abdomen on the day of the pledge of allegiance, causing her to miscarry the child in her womb. He was shouting: “Burn down her house and everyone in it.” There was no one in the house except Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Husayn, peace be upon them.’”
Al-Safadi writes in *al-Wafi bi-l-Wafayat* (vol. 6, p. 17), in his biography of al-Nazzam:
“Among his traits was his inclination toward rejectionism and his criticism of the leading Companions. He said: ‘The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him and his family, explicitly designated Imam Ali, peace be upon him, as imam and appointed him; the Companions knew this, but Umar concealed it for Abu Bakr’s sake.’ He also said: ‘Umar struck Fatima’s abdomen, peace be upon her, on the day of the pledge of allegiance, causing her to miscarry Muhsin.’”
In *Mizan al-I‘tidal* (vol. 1, p. 139), in the biography of the imam and hadith scholar Abu Bakr Ahmad ibn Muhammad al-Sari ibn Yahya ibn al-Sari ibn Abi Darim, it is stated:
“He was upright for most of his life. Then, in his final days, he would most often have accounts of the faults of others read to him. I was present when a man was reading to him: ‘Umar kicked Fatima, causing her to miscarry Muhsin.’”
See also *Lisan al-Mizan* (vol. 1, p. 406) and *Siyar A‘lam al-Nubala’* (vol. 15, p. 578). This Abu Ibn Abi Darim was among the trustworthy transmitters and among the teachers of al-Hakim al-Naysaburi and Ibn Mardawayh.
*A Selection of Reports and Virtues*, p. 397
Ibn Abi al-Hadid also transmitted in his commentary on *Nahj al-Balagha* (vol. 14, pp. 192–193) the words of the naqib Abu Ja‘far. After recounting the story of Habar ibn al-Aswad frightening Zaynab, the daughter of the Messenger of God, until she miscarried what she was carrying, he wrote:
“I read this report to the naqib Abu Ja‘far, and he said: ‘If the Messenger of God permitted the killing of Habar ibn al-Aswad because he had frightened Zaynab and caused her to miscarry what she was carrying, then it is clear that, had the Messenger of God been alive, he would have permitted the killing of whoever frightened Fatima and caused her to miscarry what she was carrying.’
“I said: ‘May I relate from you what some people say: “Fatima was frightened and miscarried Muhsin”?’ He replied:
‘Do not relate it from me, but do not relate from me that it is false either, for I withhold judgment on this matter because the reports concerning it conflict in my view.’”
Thus, from all the sources and transmitted reports, we learn that the order to attack, burn, strike and cause the miscarriage had been issued by Abu Bakr ibn Abi Quhafa. The first person to carry it out was Umar ibn al-Khattab, assisted by Qunfudh, al-Mughira ibn Shu‘ba and those who accompanied them. This accursed group was the one that plotted the coup against the Household of Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon them, and usurped their rights.
*A Selection of Reports and Virtues*, p. 398