Can the following hadith from Imam Ali (AS) be regarded as an explicit refutation of the philosophical theory of form and matter?
و أما الرد على الزنادقه فقوله تعالى و من نعمره ننکسه فی الخلق أ فلا یعقلون فأعلمنا تعالى ...
Does a Hadith from the Commander of the Faithful Refute the Theory of Form and Matter?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
It would be a stretch to connect the hadith “و من نعمره ننکسه فی الخلق” attributed to Imam Ali (AS) with the philosophical theory of form and matter. The hadith cannot be regarded as an explicit refutation of that theory, since the connection does not seem sound.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterConnecting the discussion of form and matter with the hadith in question invites strained interpretation.
In brief, if the philosophers’ account of form and matter is correct, then the form that is supposed to serve as matter—so that matter, as the substrate receiving an imprint, is not itself the form’s painted image—would actualize no potentiality. If that were so, there would be no difference between matter and form.
Can the following hadith from the Commander of the Faithful, Imam Ali, peace be upon him, be regarded as an explicit refutation of the theory of form and matter discussed in philosophy?
و أما الرد على الزنادقه فقوله تعالى و من نعمره ننکسه فی الخلق أ فلا یعقلون فأعلمنا تعالى ...
#Answer 794
Connecting the discussion of form and matter with the hadith in question invites strained interpretation.
In brief, if the philosophers’ account of form and matter is correct, then the form that is supposed to serve as matter—so that matter, as the substrate receiving an imprint, is not itself the form’s painted image—would actualize no potentiality. If that were so, there would be no difference between matter and form.