Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2325 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Does Denying the Attributes Entail Denying God’s Eternal Knowledge?

Primary reference: See the answer text 30 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2325

محمد بن أبی عبد الله‏ رفعه‏ إلى‏ أبی هاشم الجعفری‏ قال: کنت عند أبی جعفر الثانی ع فسأله رجل فقال أخبرنی عن الرب تبارک و تعالى له أسماء و صفات‏ فی کتابه‏ و أسماؤه و صفاته هی هو فقال أبو جعفر ع إن لهذا الکلام وجهین‏ إن کنت تقول هی هو أی إنه‏ ذو عدد و کثره فتعالى الله عن ذلک‏ و إن کنت تقول هذه الصفات و الأسماء لم تزل‏ فإن لم تزل محتمل معنیین فإن قلت لم تزل عنده فی علمه‏ و هو مستحقها فنعم‏ و إن کنت تقول لم یزل تصویرها و هجاؤها و تقطیع حروفها فمعاذ الله أن یکون معه شی‏ء غیره‏ بل کان الله و لا خلق‏ ثم خلقها وسیله بینه و بین خلقه یتضرعون بها إلیه و یعبدونه‏ و هی ذکره‏ و کان الله و لا ذکر و المذکور بالذکر هو الله القدیم الذی لم یزل‏ و الأسماء و الصفات مخلوقات‏ و المعانی‏ و المعنی بها هو الله‏ الذی لا یلیق به الاختلاف‏ و لا الائتلاف‏ و إنما یختلف و یأتلف‏ المتجزئ‏ فلا یقال الله مؤتلف‏ و لا الله قلیل‏ و لا کثیر و لکنه القدیم فی ذاته‏ لأن ما سوى الواحد متجزئ و الله واحد لا متجزئ و لا متوهم بالقله و الکثره و کل متجزئ أو متوهم بالقله و الکثره فهو مخلوق دال على خالق له‏ فقولک‏ إن الله قدیر- خبرت‏ أنه لا یعجزه شی‏ء فنفیت بالکلمه العجز و جعلت العجز سواه‏ و کذلک قولک عالم إنما نفیت بالکلمه الجهل و جعلت الجهل سواه‏ و إذا أفنى الله الأشیاء أفنى الصوره و الهجاء و التقطیع‏ و لا یزال من لم یزل عالما فقال الرجل‏ فکیف سمینا ربنا سمیعا فقال‏ لأنه لا یخفى علیه ما یدرک بالأسماع‏ و لم نصفه بالسمع المعقول فی الرأس‏ و کذلک سمیناه بصیرا لأنه لا یخفى علیه ما یدرک بالأبصار من لون أو شخص أو غیر ذلک‏ و لم نصفه ببصر لحظه العین‏ و کذلک سمیناه لطیفا لعلمه بالشی‏ء اللطیف‏ مثل البعوضه و أخفى من ذلک‏ و موضع النشوء منها و العقل‏ و الشهوه للسفاد و الحدب‏ على نسلها و إقام‏ بعضها على بعض‏ و نقلها الطعام و الشراب إلى أولادها فی الجبال و المفاوز و الأودیه و...........

الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج‏1، ص: 116 حدیث شماره 7

In light of the hadith above, several questions arise. Are the attributes that are eternal being denied, or are the attributes that are not eternal being denied? For example, in view of the hadith cited above and the following hadith, should we deny knowledge of God?

سمعت أبا عبد الله ع یقول‏ لم یزل الله عز و جل ربنا و العلم‏ ذاته‏ و لا معلوم و السمع ذاته و لا مسموع و البصر ذاته و لا مبصر و القدره ذاته و لا مقدور فلما أحدث الأشیاء و کان المعلوم‏ وقع العلم منه على المعلوم و السمع على المسموع و البصر على المبصر و القدره على المقدور قال قلت فلم یزل الله متحرکا قال فقال تعالى الله عن ذلک إن الحرکه صفه محدثه بالفعل قال قلت فلم یزل الله متکلما قال فقال إن الکلام صفه محدثه لیست بأزلیه کان الله عز و جل و لا متکلم.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه) ؛ ج‏1 ؛ ص107 کلینى

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

God’s knowledge of the attributes is eternal; the attributes themselves are not. The attributes and names are created and serve as intermediaries between God and creation in worship and supplication. God is pre-eternal, while the attributes are created. Thus, denying the attributes does not mean denying God’s eternal knowledge; it means affirming that the attributes and names are created.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

We should note that the hadith makes no reference to the pre-eternity of God’s attributes or names. Rather, it stresses that God’s knowledge of those attributes and names is pre-eternal. In other words, the heading of the question does not accord with the text of the narration.

لم تزل عنده فی علمه

Abu Hashim relates: I was in the presence of Imam al-Jawad (AS) when a man asked him, “Tell me: Are the names and attributes of the Lord found in the Qur’an the Lord Himself?”

The Imam replied, “Your words can be understood in two ways. If by saying that these are He, you mean that God is multiple and many, then God is far above that. But if you mean that these names and attributes are eternal, ‘eternal’ has two meanings. First, if you mean that God has always known them and has always been worthy of them, then that is correct. But if you mean that their forms, their alphabet and their individual letters have always existed, then I seek refuge in God from there having been anything else alongside God in pre-eternity. Rather, God existed when there was no creation. Then He brought these names and attributes into being, so that they might serve as intermediaries between Him and His creation, through which they might beseech God and worship Him, and so that they might be His remembrance. God existed when there was no remembrance; and the One remembered through that remembrance is the same God, the Eternal who has always existed.

“The names and attributes are created; their meanings and what they signify refer to God, to whom neither division nor composition can be ascribed. Whatever has parts is subject to division and composition, unlike the One, the Unique God. Therefore, one must not say that God is composite, or that He is few or many. Rather, He is eternal in His very essence, for whatever is not one can be divided. God is One and cannot be divided; neither quantity nor multiplicity can be conceived of in relation to Him. Anything that can be divided, or to which lesser or greater quantity may be ascribed, is a created thing that points to its Creator.

“When you say that God is powerful, you are declaring that nothing can overpower Him; by these words, you deny incapacity of Him and place incapacity elsewhere. Likewise, when you say that God is knowing, you deny ignorance of Him and place ignorance elsewhere. When God brings all things to an end, He will also bring to an end the spoken forms and individual letters, while the One whose knowledge is eternal will remain.

“The man asked, ‘If the words pass away, how can we call our Lord Hearing?’

“He replied, ‘We call Him that because nothing that can be perceived by the ear is hidden from God. But we do not describe Him as hearing with an ear conceived of as being in the head. Likewise, we call Him Seeing because nothing that can be perceived by the eye—such as colour, a person, or anything else—is hidden from Him; but we do not describe Him as seeing with the sight of the eye.

“We also call Him Subtle because He knows every subtle thing, such as the mosquito and anything smaller than it: its place of growth and development, its perception and sexual appetite, its affection for its young, how some ride upon others, and how they carry food and drink to their young in the mountains, deserts, riverbeds and arid lands. From this we know that the Creator of the mosquito is Subtle, without any modality; modality belongs only to created things, which have a ‘how.’

“Likewise, we call our Lord Powerful, not in the sense of the power to strike with the fist, as this is known among created beings. If His power were the power of striking with the fist, familiar among created beings, He would resemble a created being; and the possibility of increase would apply to Him. Whatever may increase may also decrease, and whatever is deficient or diminished is not eternal. What is not eternal is incapable.

“Thus our Lord—blessed and exalted is He—is neither like anything, nor its opposite, nor its equal. He has no modality or limit, and cannot be seen with the eye. Hearts are forbidden to liken Him to anything, minds to delimit Him, and thoughts to regard Him as originated. He is exalted far above the instruments of His creation and the signs of His creatures—far, far above them.”

Usul al-Kafi, trans. Mustafavi, vol. 1, p. 157.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022