In Sermon 1 of Nahj al-Balagha, the perfection of tawhid is equated with sincerity, and the perfection of sincerity with denying God’s attributes. So, on this reading, if someone does not deny God’s attributes, are they a monotheist (rather than a polytheist), but lacking in perfect sincerity? Given the wording of the Sermon of Fadak (و حرم الله الشرک اخلاصا له بالربوبیه. ), which places shirk in opposition to sincerity, what is the relationship between sincerity, tawhid, and shirk?
Does failing to deny God’s attributes merely fall short of perfect sincerity, or does it take one outside the very foundation of tawhid?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The perfection of tawhid lies in sincerity (ikhlas), and worship is accepted only with sincerity. The perfection of sincerity lies in denying attributes of God. Therefore, whoever does not deny God’s attributes is a monotheist, but does not possess perfect sincerity. Shirk stands opposed to sincerity, and tawhid without sincerity is tainted by shirk.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWorship is accepted only when it is sincere; without sincerity, tawḥīd is tainted by shirk! In his blessed sermon, the Mawla has charted the stages by which one attains sincerity in tawḥīd. We must not stop; we must keep moving until we reach the summit of sincerity in tawḥīd. Anyone who ceases to advance is at fault and has failed to bring their tawḥīd to perfection!