Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 729 4 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Does the Guardianship of the Jurist and His General Deputation Fall Within the Guardianship of the Infallibles?

Primary reference: See the answer text 28 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-729

What is your view on the guardianship of the jurist and the jurist’s general deputation? Is this authority exercised under the authority of the Infallible Imams, peace be upon them? Thank you.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

According to the narrations, during the Occultation, turning to qualified jurists is a proof from God, and obeying them is tantamount to obeying the Imam of the Age (AJ). Their authority is exercised under the authority of the Infallibles (AS) and is essential to securing justice in an Islamic society.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

(First statement)

A statement citing several hadiths

فی کتاب إکمال الدین و إتمام النعمه عن محمد بن محمد بن عصام عن محمد بن یعقوب عن إسحاق بن یعقوب قال: سألت محمد بن عثمان العمری أن یوصل لی کتابا قد سألت فیه عن مسائل أشکلت علی فورد التوقیع بخط مولانا صاحب الزمان ع- أما ما سألت عنه أرشدک الله و ثبتک إلى أن قال و أما الحوادث الواقعه فارجعوا فیها إلى رواه حدیثنا فإنهم حجتی علیکم و أنا حجه الله ...
وسائل الشیعه، ج‏27، ص: 140

Imam al-Mahdi (peace be upon him): “When events arise, refer to the narrators of our hadith, for they are my proof over you, and I am God’s proof over them…”

فإنهم حجتی علیکم و أنا حجه الله

عن أبی محمد العسکری ع : ... أما من کان من الفقهاء صائنا لنفسه حافظا لدینه مخالفا على هواه مطیعا لأمر مولاه فللعوام أن یقلدوه و ذلک لا یکون إلا بعض فقهاء الشیعه لا کلهم فإن من رکب من القبائح و الفواحش مراکب علماء العامه- فلا تقبلوا منهم عنا شیئا و لا کرامه و إنما کثر التخلیط فیما یتحمل عنا أهل البیت لذلک لأن الفسقه یتحملون عنا فیحرفونه بأسره لجهلهم و یضعون الأشیاء على غیر وجهها لقله معرفتهم و آخرون یتعمدون الکذب علینا الحدیث.
وسائل الشیعه، ج‏27، ص: 131

Imam al-Askari (peace be upon him): “As for any jurist who guards his own soul, preserves his faith, resists his desires and obeys the command of his Lord, the common people may follow him. Such a person is to be found only among some of the Shi‘i jurists, not all of them…”

قال علی بن محمد ع لو لا من یبقى بعد غیبه قائمنا ع من العلماء الداعین إلیه و الدالین علیه و الذابین عن دینه بحجج الله و المنقذین لضعفاء عباد الله من شباک إبلیس و مردته و من فخاخ النواصب لما بقی أحد إلا ارتد عن دین الله و لکنهم الذین یمسکون أزمه قلوب ضعفاء الشیعه کما یمسک صاحب السفینه سکانها أولئک هم الأفضلون عند الله عز و جل.
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج‏2، ص: 6

“If it were not for the scholars who remain after the occultation of our Qa’im—those who call people to him, guide them to him, defend his religion with God’s proofs, and rescue God’s vulnerable servants from the snares of Satan and his minions, and from the traps of the Nasibis—not a single person would remain without apostatising from God’s religion. But these scholars hold the reins of the hearts of the vulnerable among the Shi‘a, just as the captain of a ship holds its helm. They keep the ship’s passengers safe from mortal danger. They are the best of people in the sight of God, Mighty and Exalted.”

عن أبی محمد عن أبیه ع قال: تأتی علماء شیعتنا القوامون بضعفاء محبینا و أهل ولایتنا یوم القیامه و الأنوار تسطع من تیجانهم على رأس کل‏ واحد منهم تاج بهاء قد انبثت «1» تلک الأنوار فی عرصات القیامه و دورها مسیره ثلاثمائه ألف سنه فشعاع تیجانهم ینبث فیها کلها فلا یبقى هناک یتیم قد کفلوه و من ظلمه الجهل أنقذوه و من حیره التیه أخرجوه إلا تعلق بشعبه من أنوارهم فرفعتهم إلى العلو حتى یحاذی بهم فوق الجنان ثم ینزلهم على منازلهم المعده فی جوار أستادیهم و معلمیهم و بحضره أئمتهم الذین کانوا یدعون إلیهم و لا یبقى ناصب من النواصب یصیبه من شعاع تلک التیجان إلا عمیت عینه و صمت أذنه و أخرس لسانه و تحول علیه «2» أشد من لهب النیران فیتحملهم حتى یدفعهم إلى الزبانیه «3» فتدعوهم إلى سواء الجحیم.
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج‏2، ص: 6
عن عمر بن حنظله قال: سألت أبا عبد الله ع- عن رجلین من أصحابنا بینهما منازعه فی دین أو میراث فتحاکما إلى السلطان و إلى القضاه أ یحل ذلک قال من تحاکم إلیهم فی حق أو باطل فإنما تحاکم إلى الطاغوت و ما یحکم له فإنما یأخذ سحتا و إن کان حقا ثابتا لأنه أخذه بحکم الطاغوت و قد أمر الله أن یکفر به قال الله تعالى یریدون أن یتحاکموا إلى الطاغوت و قد أمروا أن یکفروا به «1» قلت فکیف یصنعان قال ینظران إلى من کان منکم ممن قد روى حدیثنا و نظر فی حلالنا و حرامنا و عرف أحکامنا فلیرضوا به حکما فإنی قد جعلته علیکم حاکما فإذا حکم بحکمنا فلم یقبله منه فإنما استخف بحکم الله و علینا رد و الراد علینا الراد على الله و هو على حد الشرک بالله قلت فإن کان کل رجل اختار رجلا من أصحابنا فرضیا أن یکونا الناظرین فی حقهما و اختلفا فیما حکما و کلاهما اختلفا فی حدیثکم- قال الحکم ما حکم به أعدلهما و أفقههما و أصدقهما فی الحدیث و أورعهما «1» و لا یلتفت إلى ما یحکم به الآخر قال قلت فإنهما عدلان مرضیان عند أصحابنا لا یفضل واحد منهما على الآخر قال فقال ینظر إلى ما کان من روایتهم عنا فی ذلک الذی حکما به المجمع علیه من أصحابک فیؤخذ به من حکمنا و یترک الشاذ الذی لیس بمشهور عند أصحابک فإن المجمع علیه لا ریب فیه و إنما الأمور ثلاثه أمر بین رشده فیتبع و أمر بین غیه فیجتنب و أمر مشکل یرد علمه إلى الله و إلى رسوله قال رسول الله ص حلال بین و حرام بین و شبهات بین ذلک فمن ترک الشبهات نجا من المحرمات و من أخذ بالشبهات ارتکب المحرمات و هلک من حیث لا یعلم قلت فإن کان الخبران عنکما «3» مشهورین قد رواهما الثقات عنکم قال ینظر فما وافق حکمه حکم الکتاب و السنه و خالف العامه فیؤخذ به و یترک ما خالف حکمه حکم الکتاب و السنه و وافق العامه قلت جعلت فداك أ رأیت إن کان الفقیهان عرفا حکمه من الکتاب و السنه و وجدنا أحد الخبرین موافقا للعامه و الآخر مخالفا لهم بأی الخبرین یؤخذ قال ما خالف العامه ففیه الرشاد فقلت جعلت فداك فإن وافقهما الخبران جمیعا قال ینظر إلى ما هم إلیه أمیل حکامهم و قضاتهم فیترک «4»

و یؤخذ بالآخر قلت فإن وافق حکامهم الخبرین جمیعا قال إذا کان ذلک فأرجه «5» حتى تلقى إمامک فإن الوقوف عند الشبهات خیر من الاقتحام فی الهلکات.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج‏1، ص: 67

It is narrated from Umar ibn Hanzala that he said: I asked Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq علیه السلام about two of our companions who had fallen into a dispute over a loan or an inheritance. They took their case to the ruler or to the Sunni judges. Was it permissible for them to do so? The Imam said: “Whoever takes a dispute to them, whether his case is right or wrong, has taken it to the taghut «1». Whatever the taghut rules in his favor, and whatever he obtains on the basis of that ruling, is unlawful and devoid of blessing—even if it is rightfully his—because he has obtained it through the taghut’s judgment. God has commanded them to disbelieve in him and reject him. God Most High says: «یریدون أن یتحاکموا إلى الطاغوت و قد أمروا أن یکفروا به»”—that is, “They wish to take their disputes to one who is tyrannical and transgressing. They have indeed been commanded to reject the taghut and his judgment.”

I asked, “What should they do, then?” He replied: “They should turn to someone among you, the Shia, who has narrated our traditions, considered our rulings on what is lawful and unlawful, and learned our laws. They should accept him as judge and appoint him to arbitrate, for I have appointed him as judge over you. If he rules according to our judgment and his ruling is rejected, the one who rejects it has slighted and belittled God’s judgment, and has rejected us, the People of the Household. Whoever rejects us has rejected God, and that is tantamount to associating partners with God.”

I asked, “What if each of them chooses a man from among our companions, and both agree to let their chosen men examine their case and judge between them, but the two judges disagree in their ruling and differ over the traditions you have narrated?”

He replied: “The ruling to follow is the one given by the man who is superior in justice, knowledge of the law, truthfulness in narrating traditions, and piety. No heed is paid to the other man’s ruling.”

I asked, “Both are considered just and trustworthy by our companions, and neither is superior to the other.”

Umar says that the Imam replied: “Consider the reports they have narrated from us concerning the matter on which the two judges have ruled, and which your companions have unanimously accepted. Take the ruling we have established and act upon it, for it is one of our rulings, spoken on behalf of God and the Messenger. The anomalous report, which is not well known among your companions, should be set aside. «2» For whatever is unanimously accepted is free of doubt and uncertainty.

“Matters are of three kinds: one is plainly true, and should be followed; another is plainly error and misguidance, and must be avoided; and a third is problematic, its soundness or invalidity, and its agreement or disagreement with the Book and the Sunna, being unknown. Knowledge of it must be referred to God and the Messenger of God صلى الله علیه و آله. The Messenger of God صلى الله علیه و آله said: ‘There is what is plainly lawful, what is plainly unlawful, and matters of doubt and uncertainty between the lawful and the unlawful. Whoever avoids doubtful matters is safe from what is forbidden; whoever acts upon doubtful matters commits what is forbidden and is ruined without realizing it.’”

I asked, “If both reports narrated from you are well known, having been transmitted from you by reliable and trusted narrators, what should be done?” He replied: “They should be examined. The one whose ruling accords with the Book and the Sunna and differs from the Sunnis should be accepted and acted upon. The one whose ruling conflicts with the Book and the Sunna and agrees with the Sunnis should be set aside.”

I asked, “May I be your ransom! Tell me: if the two jurists have derived their rulings from the Book and the Sunna, and we find that one of the reports agrees with the Sunnis and the other differs from them, which of the two should we follow?” He replied: “The right path lies in the report that differs from the Sunnis.”

I asked, “May I be your ransom! What should be done if both reports agree with the Sunnis?” He replied: “Consider which one the Sunni rulers and judges are more inclined to follow; set that one aside, and take the other and act upon it.”

I asked, “What if their rulers agree with both reports and are not more inclined to either one?” He replied: “Defer the matter until you meet your Imam, for holding back in the face of doubt is better than plunging into things that bring about your ruin.”

تحفه الأولیاء (ترجمه أصول کافى)، ج‏1، ص: 236

#Answer729 (Second Explanation)

Rational Argument

With the occultation of the Imam of the Age (peace be upon him), the necessity of implementing the divine laws still remains; the divine laws are not suspended by his occultation. For the precise implementation of all divine laws, either every person must himself be a fully qualified jurist, or he must follow a fully qualified jurist. For the performance of obligations such as Hajj, jihad, and the execution of the divinely ordained penalties and limits, and the like, the jurist must, for the sake of better cohesion, establish a particular organization and system—which is precisely governance and leadership at the macro level of society.

For the precise implementation and realization of the divine laws, there is no alternative to the formation of a government in Islamic society.

Obligations such as enjoining the good and forbidding the wrong are set forth at the individual, familial, collective, and national levels. The obligation of enjoining the good and forbidding the wrong will be fully implemented only when it is managed by the government and leadership of society.

Given the fact that secular governments are an obstacle to the divine laws and the performance of divine obligations, the necessity of forming an Islamic government under the leadership of a fully qualified jurist becomes a religious obligation.

#Answer 729 (Third Statement)

Quranic Argument

Most of the commands and prohibitions of the Quran are collective in nature, which necessitates collective movements in obeying them; therefore, collective movements require an organizer and a leader!

For example, for collective piety, the leadership of a pious jurist must hold authority.

Al-Imran: 102 — یا أیها الذین آمنوا اتقوا الله حق تقاته و لا تموتن إلا و أنتم مسلمون

O you who have believed! Fear God as He deserves to be feared, and do not die except as Muslims! (You must preserve the jewel of faith until the end of life!)

The unbelievers must not be allowed to dominate the affairs of the Muslims; the severance of their domination is possible only through the formation of an Islamic government by a fully qualified jurist, for the infiltration of foreigners occurs mostly through governmental organizations.

Al-Imran: 118 — یا أیها الذین آمنوا لا تتخذوا بطانه من دونکم لا یألونکم خبالا ودوا ما عنتم قد بدت البغضاء من أفواههم و ما تخفی صدورهم أکبر قد بینا لکم الآیات إن کنتم تعقلون

O you who have believed! Do not take as intimates those other than yourselves, who spare no effort to corrupt you; they wish you distress. Hatred has already appeared from their mouths, and what their hearts conceal is greater. We have made clear to you the signs, if you understand!

To prevent the Islamic society from being contaminated by financial corruption—especially usury, which is prominently manifested in present-day societies through the establishment of banks—the financial guidance and management of the wealth of society is possible only through the formation of an Islamic government.

Al-Imran: 130 — یا أیها الذین آمنوا لا تأکلوا الربوا أضعافا مضاعفه و اتقوا الله لعلکم تفلحون

O you who have believed! Do not consume usury, doubled and multiplied, and fear God, so that you may succeed!

To bring about unity in the bonds of faith in carrying out the divine commands and in confronting the enemies of Islam, a government must be formed under the leadership of a worthy jurist.

Al-Imran: 200 — یا أیها الذین آمنوا اصبروا و صابروا و رابطوا و اتقوا الله لعلکم تفلحون

O you who have believed! Be steadfast, and persevere, and hold fast to the frontiers, and fear God, so that you may succeed.

The obligation of obeying God, the Messenger, and the friend of God (wali) remains in force in the age of occultation as well. The most pious jurist is certainly the closest person, in terms of spiritual and faith-related stations, to our Imam of the Age, and following him is equivalent to following our Imam of the Age.

Al-Nisa: 59 — یا أیها الذین آمنوا أطیعوا الله و أطیعوا الرسول و أولی الأمر منکم فإن تنازعتم فی شیء فردوه إلى الله و الرسول إن کنتم تؤمنون بالله و الیوم الآخر ذلک خیر و أحسن تأویلا

O you who have believed! Obey God, and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you dispute over anything, refer it to God and the Messenger, if you believe in God and the Last Day. That is better and more excellent in outcome.

For the vindication of rights in Islamic society, a government led by a jurist must hold authority; otherwise, no right will ever be vindicated.

Al-Nisa: 59 — یا أیها الذین آمنوا أطیعوا الله و أطیعوا الرسول و أولی الأمر منکم فإن تنازعتم فی شیء فردوه إلى الله و الرسول إن کنتم تؤمنون بالله و الیوم الآخر ذلک خیر و أحسن تأویلا

O you who have believed! Obey God, and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you dispute over anything, refer it to God and the Messenger, if you believe in God and the Last Day. That is better and more excellent in outcome.

Referring to the unbelievers for the vindication of rights is contrary to the divine command.

Al-Nisa: 60 — أ لم تر إلى الذین یزعمون أنهم آمنوا بما أنزل إلیک و ما أنزل من قبلک یریدون أن یتحاکموا إلى الطاغوت و قد أمروا أن یکفروا به و یرید الشیطان أن یضلهم ضلالا بعیدا

Have you not seen those who claim to believe in what has been revealed to you and to those before you, yet wish to seek judgment from false authorities, even though they have been commanded to reject them? Satan only wants to lead them astray, far from the right path.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022