Is it correct to regard the Hadith of the Armies of Reason and Ignorance as concerning practical reason?
Does the Hadith of the Armies of Reason and Ignorance Concern Practical Reason?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The division of reason into theoretical and practical is not sound. Reason, as God’s first creation, is a single, pure and indivisible reality. Each of the armies of reason—which are the noble virtues—has both a theoretical and a practical dimension. Even this distinction, however, is not without its problems, since the same person both thinks and understands (the theoretical dimension) and puts that understanding into practice (the practical dimension).
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIntellect is not divisible or capable of being broken down; it is solid, pure and undiluted. Dividing it into theoretical and practical intellect is a mistake.
The discussions of theoretical and practical intellect that are common in this field have no connection to intellect as the first thing God created. In fact, they loosely divide and interpret certain aspects of human character as theoretical and practical.
Yet each of the forces of the intellect—that is, the noble virtues—has both a theoretical and a practical aspect in itself. Even here, however, the distinction is not without problems. Actions take shape both inwardly and through the bodily faculties: thinking, perceiving and understanding are activities of the inner faculties, while their expression in material affairs and the routines of daily life is carried out through the bodily members. Human intentions, for example, are themselves a kind of human act, shaping the pattern of what a person does thereafter.
Knowledge of the actions one ought to perform is like a light illuminating the path ahead; we should not mistakenly interpret it as theoretical intellect. For the one who sees and the one who acts are the same person.
If we accept this division into theoretical and practical intellect, we would also have to posit an intellect that observes and an intellect that acts, whereas there is only one intellect.