Suppose that in a world (where there is no Imam) punishment were to befall a person the moment they erred—this would prevent anyone from erring. For example, when a creature touches fire, it burns; and because the result of the act occurs immediately, it prevents the wrong act from occurring.
Can it be said that the existence of the Imam for the rebellious causes an increase in punishment, and is the very respite that God grants them so that they may add to their sin?
And if so, why does God, in the shadow of His dearest creature, give respite to disobedient servants so that they may increase what is detestable to God?
Does the Presence of the Imam Increase the Punishment of the Rebellious?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The presence of the Imam does not mean increased punishment for the rebellious; rather, it is an opportunity to benefit from the blessing of his presence—unless their hearts have been sealed. The immediate descent of punishment is a hastening of the recompense for one's deeds, while God's granting respite to the oppressors means giving them the opportunity to benefit from the conditions and the blessing of the Imam's presence, not mere gradual entrapment (istidraj). In the Quran, God has mentioned instances of respite and of returning to the truth.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe immediate descent of punishment upon those who rebel is, in reality, an acceleration of the recompense for their deeds. The respite granted to wrongdoers is not merely a means of gradually leading them to destruction; they are still given the opportunity to benefit from the circumstances and the blessing of the Imam’s presence, unless their hearts have been sealed.
For the friends of God, the path to God is always open; this way has no dead end.
الروم : 41 ظهر الفساد فی البر و البحر بما کسبت أیدی الناس لیذیقهم بعض الذی عملوا لعلهم یرجعون
Corruption has appeared on land and sea because of what people’s hands have earned. He wishes to make them taste something of what they have done, so that perhaps they may return.
الزخرف : 48 و ما نریهم من آیه إلا هی أکبر من أختها و أخذناهم بالعذاب لعلهم یرجعون
We showed them no sign except that it was greater than the one before it, and We seized them with punishment so that perhaps they might return!
الأحقاف : 27 و لقد أهلکنا ما حولکم من القرى و صرفنا الآیات لعلهم یرجعون
We destroyed the communities around you, and We presented the signs in various ways, so that perhaps they might return.
The wrongdoers hasten toward divine punishment!
الأنعام : 58 قل لو أن عندی ما تستعجلون به لقضی الأمر بینی و بینکم و الله أعلم بالظالمین
Say: “If what you are asking to be hastened were in my possession, the matter between you and me would already have been settled. But God knows the wrongdoers best and punishes them at the proper time.” (58)
یونس : 11 و لو یعجل الله للناس الشر استعجالهم بالخیر لقضی إلیهم أجلهم فنذر الذین لا یرجون لقاءنا فی طغیانهم یعمهون
Had God hastened evil for people as they hasten toward good, their term would soon have come to an end and they would all have been destroyed. But We leave those who do not hope to meet Us to wander blindly in their rebellion!
مریم : 84 فلا تعجل علیهم إنما نعد لهم عدا
So do not hasten against them. We are carefully counting out their days and deeds! (84)
البقره : 18 صم بکم عمی فهم لا یرجعون
They are deaf, dumb and blind, so they will not return from the wrong path! (18)
الأنعام : 36 إنما یستجیب الذین یسمعون و الموتى یبعثهم الله ثم إلیه یرجعون
Only those who listen can respond. As for the dead—and those who have lost their human spirit—they will not believe. God will raise them, and then they will return to Him.