Is there a contradiction with the recent proposal for mubahala (#Question2566)?
#Answer2567
Regarding
notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque
Is there a contradiction with the recent proposal for mubahala (#Question2566)?
#Answer2567
Regarding
The recent proposal for mubahala does not contradict the position taken in Question 2070, since it did not concern a serious matter and was merely intended to promote someone making false claims. Question 2070 explained that mubahala is an important tool that should not be used in minor matters or to substantiate baseless claims.
The matter proposed for *mubāhala* was one that had never been the subject of any serious debate, and the person who proposed it intended to promote a false claimant. Moreover, the subject had never been seriously discussed in any gathering and had nothing to do with matters of belief. Even if it had been a serious matter, it would still not have been a proper occasion for *mubāhala*!