Please explain to Dr. Delgosha the main reason for proposing mubahala, and whether it is applicable to matters of tawhid.
Is Mubahala Used Only in Matters of Tawhid?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Mubahala is an effective way to seek the truth in serious debates, especially those concerning tawhid. When argument and obstinacy stand in the way of discovering the truth, mubahala can help clear a path to guidance by revealing the certainty—or doubt—of those involved. Matters of tawhid lie at the heart of mubahala.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWhen, in important debates—including those concerning tawhid, prophethood, and imamate—contentious disputation and stubbornness on one side prevent some people from recognizing the truth, mubahala can be a highly effective way to break the impasse, clarify the truth, and clear the path to guidance. A heartfelt conviction in the truth of one’s claims gives each party the courage to proceed. But anyone who doubts their own claims, or is aware of their own contentiousness and obstinacy, will avoid mubahala.
And if both parties are certain of their claims and proceed with mubahala, then surely the one whose certainty in their claim is born of ignorance will be defeated.
In any case, whether a party agrees to mubahala or backs away from it can give observers a good indication of where the truth lies.
Questions of tawhid lie at the heart of mubahala. There is no subject greater than tawhid.