Hasan al-Muthanna, Imam Hasan (AS), went to his uncle, Imam Husayn (AS), to ask for one of his daughters (Fatima or Sukayna) in marriage.
Imam Husayn (AS) said to him: “I choose Fatima for you, because she bears a closer resemblance to my mother, Fatima, daughter of the Messenger of God صلى الله عليه و آله.
She was devout, staying awake throughout the night and fasting by day, and in her appearance and beauty she resembled the houris.
As for Sukayna, absorption in God had so overcome her that she was not suited to marry a man.”
Lady Fatima al-Zahra (SA), The Joy of the Prophet’s Heart, p. 456.
Please advise me about the authenticity of this report, especially this passage: “As for Sukayna, absorption in God had so overcome her that she was not suited to marry a man.”
How authentic is the report about Hasan al-Muthanna proposing to Imam Husayn’s daughters?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The report that Hasan al-Muthanna proposed to Imam Husayn’s daughters and that Sukayna was unfit for marriage because she was absorbed in God is not found in reliable sources. The book al-Irshad mentions his proposal for Fatima and notes her resemblance to Lady Fatima al-Zahra (SA).
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterI have not found the report in question in reliable sources! I am sending the account of Hasan al-Muthanna’s marriage proposal from the book al-Irshad:
It is related that Hasan ibn Hasan asked to marry one of his two cousins, the daughters of Husayn علیه السلام. Husayn said to him, “My son, choose whichever of the two you love more, and I will give her to you in marriage.” Hasan was too shy to answer. Husayn then said, “I choose my daughter Fatima for you, because she bears a closer resemblance to my mother, Fatima, daughter of the Messenger of God صلى الله عليه و آله و سلم.”
When Hasan ibn Hasan died, he was thirty-five years old. His brother Zayd ibn Hasan was still alive, but Hasan had named his maternal half-brother, Ibrahim, son of Muhammad ibn Talha, as his executor. After Hasan ibn Hasan died, his wife Fatima, daughter of Husayn ibn Ali علیهما السلام, pitched her tent over his grave. She fasted by day and spent her nights in worship. Because of her beauty, people likened her to a houri. After a year had passed in this way, she told her servants, “When night falls, take this tent down from here.” When night came, she heard someone say, “Have they found what they lost?” Another replied, “No; they returned in despair.”
Hasan ibn Hasan died without claiming the imamate, and no one made such a claim on his behalf, as we have explained regarding his brother Zayd.
الإرشاد للمفید / translated by Rasuli Mahallati, vol. 2, p. 22