According to the hadith, wrath does not mean that God undergoes a change of state. Rather, divine wrath and displeasure refer to the wrath and displeasure of God’s friends, who become angry sincerely for His sake. Divine wrath and displeasure are understood to mean the wrath of the Fourteen Infallibles (AS). How can this hadith be reconciled with the report that, during a battle, Imam Ali (AS) paused before killing Abd Wudd after Abd Wudd spat in his blessed face, so that he would not kill him out of anger, and then returned once he had calmed down to kill him sincerely for God’s sake? Please explain how these two reports can be reconciled and resolve their apparent contradiction.
How Can Divine Wrath Be Reconciled with Imam Ali’s (AS) Pause Before Killing Abd Wudd?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Divine wrath does not mean that God undergoes a change of state; rather, it refers to the wrath of God’s devoted friends. Imam Ali’s (AS) pause before killing Abd Wudd was meant to preserve his sincerity and keep personal anger from influencing his action. Just as the Imam defeated his enemy on the battlefield, he also refused to let his inner enemy—anger—master him, and instead overcame it.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe All-Merciful and the All-Subduer are both among God’s Most Beautiful Names. We may regard mercy as a manifestation of the blessed name al-Rahman, and wrath as a manifestation of the blessed name al-Qahhar.
As for Mawla Ali عليه السلام, I should say that just as he brought his external enemy, Amr ibn Abd Wudd, to the ground, he also humbled wrath, his inner enemy!
Mawla Ali عليه السلام brought hardships low, and their onslaught had not the slightest effect on his noble character!
The arising and manifestation of wrath is like an enemy’s attack!