Mr. Hakimi, peace be upon you. The relationship between a word and its meaning is established either by deliberate convention or through customary usage; in either case, it is conventional. There is no reason, then, why the word and sound “water,” or its written form (“w” and “a”), should signify a drinkable liquid. In English, too, the word and sound “water” signify the same meaning. These are conventions agreed upon by people. My question is this: the Most Beautiful Names of God are not conventional. How, then, can they signify a particular meaning? How should we understand the relationship between meaning and a name in two cases: (1) verbal and written names, and (2) names embodied in beings (the Infallibles, peace be upon them)? (This is another way of putting my previous question: How does Imam Ali, peace be upon him, know Almighty God—through Himself or through something else? Please focus on the text outside the parentheses.) May God grant you abundant reward and every blessing in this world and the next, God willing.
How Do the Most Beautiful Names Signify Meaning?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The connection between created beings and the Most Beautiful Names takes the question beyond convention: the very existence of beings is itself the Name, and all beings are signs of God. The Most Beautiful Names reach their perfection when they serve as signs of an existence that is without sign and in need of none, and point to a particular meaning.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWhen the relationship of beings to the Most Beautiful Names is taken into account, the question looks very different from the question of whether names are conventional. For the very existence of beings is itself a name, though at a particular level. In other words, all beings are names of the Most Exalted Lord, since every being, without exception, is a divine sign, and every sign points to the Essence that cannot be described or expressed. In truth, it is the name itself, in its very nature, that is a convention, an agreement. Yet when a name reaches perfection in its being a name, it attains to the divine Most Beautiful Names and becomes a sign of the signless Being, who has no need of a sign.